• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Proof of God(s)?

Nicolombian77

New Member
Ok theists, I want you to submit any evidence that there is a god(s). I don't want posts that say:"well scientists don't know how this works therefore its god". I want any empirical evidence that you have to submit.

After giving me proof that there is a god(s), then you must give me evidence that your god is the true god. Again I don't want circular logic that "my holy book says that my god exists, so he does."

If anyone can do this, I will convert to their faith and spend the rest of my life worshiping. This "evidence" will also change the world forever.

Ready. Begin.
 

ChristineES

Tiggerism
Premium Member
This question again??? How many times does it need to asked? (No offense, though).

If you want my answer, look at some of the other threads where it was already asked. (I doubt you care about my answer, though).:)
Welcome to the RF, friend. (No, I am not being crass, I mean that).
 
Last edited:

Quintessence

Consults with Trees
Staff member
Premium Member
This question again??? How many times do it need to asked? (No offense, though).

Apparently until everyone in the "proof" school realizes that asking for proof of the divine is, in many cases, of missing the point entirely.

As far as my own immanent deity-concept goes, I've said it before and I'll say it again: you either decide that the definition of God/Sacred/Deity/Magic is equated with the universe/nature/reality or you don't. There is no "proving" a definition of something. It's a construct; a description. Evidence of the existence of reality is pretty obvious unless you're going to pull out extreme philosophical skepticism. That can be a fun intellectual exercise, sure, but it is also inadequate for anything resembling practical living. You sort of have to assume that reality exists. This is no different to me than assuming deity exists, because deity = reality.
 

Quagmire

Imaginary talking monkey
Staff member
Premium Member
"There are only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle."
---Albert Einstein

I doubt anybody can fulfill your request, Nicolombian77. Problem is, as the Einstein quote suggests, if you're a theist, you'll see everything in existence as proof of God's existence. If you're not, then there isn't any small part of that Everything that's liable to change your mind.
 
Last edited:

elmarna

Well-Known Member
In my darkest hour a voice in form of thought came to me calmly and sincere.
"Stop whisphering." It said.
I was confused since I was yelling and not likely a thought rational to the religion I followed at the time. It spoke in a language that was not my own (at that time) I have adopted some of it now. I knew nothing of the Quran.
Had no interest in Islam!
This voice of guidence (once I undertood I was not crazy)
Was intelegent and reasonable in it's approach. While it could get pushy in isisting that I consider certain things it was always my choice in the end to heed the words and world of it or ignore that which it wanted me to turn to.
I was never looking to confirm God exists.
It was God who made me realize! It was not without the understanding 1st!
Blind faith never offers you "a way to see." It operates on a formula to consider.
Those who speak of the third eye know what I mean.
I meditate. I am not sure it is a mandatory Islamic practice.
Please do not go rushing into Islam if your feelings and thoughts do not embrace it whole heartedly.
Allah wants the truth of you to speak and capture the avenues in the resources that speak the name in the virtues of you. What you name it is up to you.
How you live life matters. The truths that bind you are the 1's he/she sees.
Connecting with god through them is a relationship just as strong as the 1 I have in meditation and prayer!
Some people go there whole life without being aware of God.
I do not doubt he exists now. I would not want you to wear my shoes and live my journey to capture the concepts I speak.
Perhaps if you embrace meditation in it's true form. God can answer on his own behalf and you need not listen to so much testifing!
 
Last edited:

ChristineES

Tiggerism
Premium Member
It's just kind of demeaning. I mean we all know- both atheist and theist- that there is no empirical or scientific proof of God. Anyone who asks the questions seems to be doing for sport and not asking as a legitimate question. I can't say I know everyone's intent when they ask questions like this, but I can guess it isn't usually because they really think we can offer them any empirical proof.
 

Quintessence

Consults with Trees
Staff member
Premium Member
In a fashion, if you regard deity as synonymous with the universe, the entire body of science is "proof" of the existence of deity. However, this is only true if you accept the definition of god as being equated with the universe, which in of itself cannot be proven since it is a foundational premise.

This kind of question could be more interesting if the types of evidence deemed valid for consideration were opened up to their full breadth. I find it interesting to understand what kinds of experiences people regard as proofs for their beliefs, regardless of whether or not that evidence passes scientific muster.
 

ChristineES

Tiggerism
Premium Member
In a fashion, if you regard deity as synonymous with the universe, the entire body of science is "proof" of the existence of deity. However, this is only true if you accept the definition of god as being equated with the universe, which in of itself cannot be proven since it is a foundational premise.

This kind of question could be more interesting if the types of evidence deemed valid for consideration were opened up to their full breadth. I find it interesting to understand what kinds of experiences people regard as proofs for their beliefs, regardless of whether or not that evidence passes scientific muster.
Frubals!

I think I can look it that way. After all, I have my own proofs of God, that I just don't share with anyone other than theists- I am afraid that they will made fun of by non-theists- I mean, not all non-theists, but some of them. I have always been hypersensitive, which is really not a good thing in this world. :)
 

Nicolombian77

New Member
who said i was atheist, i believe in the flying spaghetti monster. May his noodly appendage strike heathens down and torture you forever. he will punish your personality based on the location you were born in and those who form your personality and life.
One term will disprove any religion that says this: Tabla Rasa
 

Quagmire

Imaginary talking monkey
Staff member
Premium Member
who said i was atheist, i believe in the flying spaghetti monster. May his noodly appendage strike heathens down and torture you forever. he will punish your personality based on the location you were born in and those who form your personality and life.
One term will disprove any religion that says this: Tabla Rasa

I see. :rolleyes:
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
May his noodly appendage strike heathens down and torture you forever. he will punish your personality based on the location you were born in and those who form your personality and life.

Badda Boom Badda Bing 2:14

1st standard edition. (FSE)

The only reliable sauce er, I mean source.
 

Sgloom

Active Member
who said i was atheist, i believe in the flying spaghetti monster. May his noodly appendage strike heathens down and torture you forever. he will punish your personality based on the location you were born in and those who form your personality and life.
One term will disprove any religion that says this: Tabla Rasa
that makes you a theist then, so are you going to answer your own question?
 

1137

Here until I storm off again
Premium Member
Look up 'golden ratio', 'Fibonacci sequence', and 'sacred geometry'. They are the only decent evidence out there that there may be intelligence behind the design of the universe. The problem is that they could very possibly occur on their own without gods, aliens, etc. They can give us an interesting insight into the spiritual aspect of reality, depending who is looking at it...
 

kerravon

Anti-subjugator
Ok theists, I want you to submit any evidence that there is a god(s). I don't want posts that say:"well scientists don't know how this works therefore its god". I want any empirical evidence that you have to submit.
The universe is 13.7 billion years old according to science. If the universe was 0.01% younger, us intelligent humans wouldn't be here and the world would be a boring place. If the universe was 0.01% older, humans would be redundant as we would have invented artificial intelligence. Instead, we've been placed at a remarkable period in history. Incredibly remarkable. We have nuclear weapons able to wipe out humanity, we are on the verge of spreading democracy across the globe, and we've just had the internet give everyone a voice in the global debate so we can discuss our differences and chart a course for the future.

It's too damned neat.

It's far more likely that the extra 0.01% of history (ie 1 million years from now) has already happened, and our "descendants" have fantastic computer technology available to them, and they are running a computer simulation of which we are now a part. The interesting things they have packed into our timeframe probably didn't happen in such a short space in theirs.

OR THE EQUIVALENT - ie there are no "descendants", there's another way these computer simulations are being created.

Regardless, the overwhelming evidence as I see it is that this is a gigantic setup. We've been given a challenge of creating a free world without human rights abuses in our lifetimes.

Then there are all those fine-tuned parameters that make the universe as something that is capable of supporting life instead of just one large black hole.

Then if you look hard enough and with certain assumptions there is a verifiable miracle.

So this is why I am a theist, but I have an atheistic mindset as I was a long time atheist.

After giving me proof that there is a god(s), then you must give me evidence that your god is the true god.
I don't have proof of a particular god. It could be a 3rd grader running this computer simulation, just as 3rd graders here would run "Sim City".

I speculate what is most logical. You can see the results of my speculation here:

http://www.religiousforums.com/forum/religious-debates/127205-proposals-cycle-life.html

If anyone can do this, I will convert to their faith and spend the rest of my life worshiping. This "evidence" will also change the world forever.
To me the world is changed forever with the computer simulation model. I now attempt to derive the rules of the current simulation and try to decide what I'd prefer the rules to be. You can post on the above thread if you like.

Note that even in the "worst" case where this isn't a computer simulation after all, we can still expect that in a short time (0.01% or whatever) we will have the ability to create artificial universes and download our brains onto silicon so that we can join those universes, so we need to determine what we want the rules to be anyway, for preparation of when we (or our descendants) are gods ourselves. But like I said, I doubt that we'll be the very very first to create AI. And given that according to science intelligence was created just by accident in evolution, I doubt that it'll take us a whopping 0.01% to create it deliberately with all our technology. More like 0.000001% (137 years).
 

Jinse

Lawrence's other half
The reason why I doubt in the existence of god is there are no enough proof or evidence to point out that there is. There are some instances though that makes me think if there really is but experiences is not much reliable.
 

zenzero

Its only a Label
Friend Nicolombian77,
Proof of God(s)?
Ok theists, I want you to submit any evidence that there is a god(s). I don't want posts that say:"well scientists don't know how this works therefore its god". I want any empirical evidence that you have to submit.

After giving me proof that there is a god(s), then you must give me evidence that your god is the true god. Again I don't want circular logic that "my holy book says that my god exists, so he does."

If anyone can do this, I will convert to their faith and spend the rest of my life worshiping. This "evidence" will also change the world forever.

Ready. Begin.

Since follow no path, and know of any *God* and not expecting any followers; need no evidence to be given.
It is your journey and for which you have to do something even *nothing* to reach such a state.

Love & rgds
 

Jinse

Lawrence's other half
Friend Nicolombian77,


Since follow no path, and know of any *God* and not expecting any followers; need no evidence to be given.
It is your journey and for which you have to do something even *nothing* to reach such a state.

Love & rgds

Can you blame someone who does not know of any *God* because there is *no* sufficient evidence? Exactly the reason why I doubt if there is *God* most of the time.
 

Pegg

Jehovah our God is One
the evidence is seen in the organization of the universe and the laws of nature

chaos will produce a random mess....not order
there is no way that the forces of nature can produce life...they simply cannot.
 

kerravon

Anti-subjugator
the evidence is seen in the organization of the universe and the laws of nature

chaos will produce a random mess....not order
there is no way that the forces of nature can produce life...they simply cannot.
Right. With all our technology we can't even create a living cell, yet atheists require that life be created purely by accident. Unlikely. Plus the other evidence.
 

illykitty

RF's pet cat
Well what I'm going to say isn't new but this question isn't new either. What proof is there about not being any form of God, Creator or higher power? None whatsoever! There is no evidence or scientific discovery that disproves a God existing.
 
Top