• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Q and A's

F0uad

Well-Known Member
I want to make a thread for newcomers to Islam were all Muslim branches, sects and interpretations will be heard.
If anyone has a question they simply can post it here and a fellow Muslim can gives hes interpretation or opinion regarding it (please include your sect or branch) when you respond.
 

Assad91

Shi'ah Ali
I have a question.

Is the political views necessary as muslims? In other words, do we need to strive to establish shariah, instead of secularism? Do we need to wage jihad in order to force out dominance in places?

I also have another question. In America, a lot of muslims seem to adopt Saudi culture. The women wear the Saudi style khemars and niqabs, while the men wear the keffiyah and thobes. Some even go and change their names to Arabic names. Is all of this necessary?
 

Rational_Mind

Ahmadi Muslim
I have a question.

Is the political views necessary as muslims? In other words, do we need to strive to establish shariah, instead of secularism? Do we need to wage jihad in order to force out dominance in places?

As an Ahmadi Muslim I hold the view that Shariah teaches that when dealing with a nation of multiple faiths the only proper system is secular. An excellent example of this is that in every incident of dispute with a Non-Muslim the Holy Prophet (saw) always asked under which law the person would like to be judged (Islamic, Judaic, or through Arbitration). Under this system the main requirement is of absolute justice, how it is achieved under each religious teaching differs, where we find through scripture that Islam is most lenient. Every religion teaches to shun evil and grasp good, so this is a concept that is universal.

I also have another question. In America, a lot of muslims seem to adopt Saudi culture. The women wear the Saudi style khemars and niqabs, while the men wear the keffiyah and thobes. Some even go and change their names to Arabic names. Is all of this necessary?

To me the popularity of dressing in such a style appears to be more of an act of imitation. It appears to me that some people feel that dressing with Saudi Culture makes them a better Muslim.

Occasionally dressing as a different culture is perfectly fine but making it appear as if it is a commandment is another issue.

It is absolutely not necessary to adopt a particular culture of clothing. Those who feel so should try adopting Saudi warm weather clothing in Northern Canada where the climate will teach them that such an teaching could not be from God. Islam only teaches to dress decently. As long as you can find such decent clothing you are good to go.

As for changing names, you would definitely want to change it in the case that it is named after a deity. Other then that I feel it would be your own personal decision. I have not heard anything about it being mandatory.
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
I have a question.
and hopefully i have a Sunni answer.

Is the political views necessary as muslims? In other words, do we need to strive to establish shariah, instead of secularism? Do we need to wage jihad in order to force out dominance in places?
Hmm good question well in a Non-Islamic country certainly not but being in a country what as a majority of Muslims i think its better to advocate for a Sharia based society then secular one.

Secularism was never part of Islam history, secularism can lead to individualism and many other aspects in extreme forms and therefore contradict Islam teachings. Also the whole notion that secularism and a majority of Muslims can co-exist is foolish these countries become more "Westernized" and the "Islam" inside it will be finished off by the secularists.

I also have another question. In America, a lot of muslims seem to adopt Saudi culture. The women wear the Saudi style khemars and niqabs, while the men wear the keffiyah and thobes. Some even go and change their names to Arabic names. Is all of this necessary?
The Niqab is not a Saudi cultural clothing rather its a Middle-Eastern/Africa clothing in Iran, Somali, Afghanistian and many different countries its wearied. Most of the women who do live in Europe or America who do wear these clothes belief that showing your body-form and parts of your body (not including hands, face) is not Sunnah therefore they use these kind of clothing to be sure off it.

Islam does not oblige Muslim people to choose specific names, Arabic or non-Arabic, for their children, whether boys or girls. It is rather up to people to choose the names for their children. However, selecting names should be pursuant to some Islamic rules that will be stated below. Islam emphasizes that Muslims should have good names and give good names to their children. It is reported in a Hadith that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "You will be called on the Day of Resurrection by your names and the names of your fathers, so have good names." (Reported by Abu Dawud)

We must certainly avoid names that indicate any trace of shirk or association of partners with Allah. Therefore it is forbidden to call someone `Abd al-Ka`bah, or `Abd al-Nabi (servant of the Ka`bah or servant of the Prophet), since all of us are servants of Allah alone.
We must also avoid names that imply meanings that are offensive or unpleasant in connotations. The Prophet (pbuh) changed names such as Harb (War) with Salam (Peace), ‘Asiyah (Rebellious) with Jamilah (Beautiful), Sa`b (Difficult) with Sahl (Easy to deal with), etc.

Having said this, I must add: There is nothing in the Islamic sources to indicate that we are allowed only to give our children Arabic names. Since Islam is a universal religion, there is no such requirement. Any name is okay so long as we keep in mind the above points. But, at the same time, while choosing names, we must strive our best not to compromise our Islamic identity.”

And more information can be found here
 
Last edited:

MatthiasGould

Alhamdulillah!
Quick prayer question: I've noticed some variations in the way some people have been telling me I should pray. It's usually a case of an omission/addition of a few words or an optional section such as qunut. I'm wondering, is there any reason behind such variations and if so, what is the correct way to pray?
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
Quick prayer question: I've noticed some variations in the way some people have been telling me I should pray. It's usually a case of an omission/addition of a few words or an optional section such as qunut. I'm wondering, is there any reason behind such variations and if so, what is the correct way to pray?

Could you maybe elaborate a little more what are the differences you found, which "branch or sect" showed the differences and to whom are they different?
 

MatthiasGould

Alhamdulillah!
Could you maybe elaborate a little more what are the differences you found, which "branch or sect" showed the differences and to whom are they different?

It's more of an issue of reading the various 'prayer guides' different Islamic sites give. I'm not sure if these guides differ according to sect guidelines or not.

I seem to remember getting confused as one prayer guide said to do qunoot during the second rakah of the prayers, yet I was told by an actual Muslim this was only for Ishaa prayers.

I'm also confused as one prayer guide said to recite Takbir and then Fatihah to begin prayers, whilst THIS guide gives a series of other supplications to begin the first rakah in addition to the takbir and Surah al-Fatihah.
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
It's more of an issue of reading the various 'prayer guides' different Islamic sites give. I'm not sure if these guides differ according to sect guidelines or not.

I seem to remember getting confused as one prayer guide said to do qunoot during the second rakah of the prayers, yet I was told by an actual Muslim this was only for Ishaa prayers.

I'm also confused as one prayer guide said to recite Takbir and then Fatihah to begin prayers, whilst THIS guide gives a series of other supplications to begin the first rakah in addition to the takbir and Surah al-Fatihah.

If you don't mind my brother i will reply tomorrow its 1:42 here and i have to do some sleeping.
I am sure someone else can help you out if not you will get an answer tomorrow ASAP.

Asalaam alaykoem.
 

Assad91

Shi'ah Ali
Hmm I have noticed such as well. I usually just pray the sameway I learned. Only thing I say after takbeer and before fatihah is "aouthu billahi minshatan irijeem.". Then rcite fatihah and maybe another sura(when its sunnah) then ruku then back up then prostrate twice. When I was learning I mimicked what was done at the masjid near my house. It is salafi. I know Islamicfinder.org has a very good guide.
 

MatthiasGould

Alhamdulillah!
Hmm I have noticed such as well. I usually just pray the sameway I learned. Only thing I say after takbeer and before fatihah is "aouthu billahi minshatan irijeem.". Then rcite fatihah and maybe another sura(when its sunnah) then ruku then back up then prostrate twice. When I was learning I mimicked what was done at the masjid near my house. It is salafi. I know Islamicfinder.org has a very good guide.

I think I will do the same and do as I've been learning how to do. The basic 'bones' of the prayers (number of rakahs and the ruku/sujud) remain the same across the differing forms of the prayers in any case.
 

Assad91

Shi'ah Ali
Inshallah you will learn quickly. I am a convert to. Its hard at first but as you learn more, the salat will start to feel more ajd more peaceful and a true blessing.
 

Rational_Mind

Ahmadi Muslim
If this helps here is a guide that also speaks about some differences, they are quite minor in general. One should not be overly concerned with them.

Salat Prayer Guide

It has actually quite nicely covered some of the aspects and provided references as to the differences.
 

Peace

Quran & Sunnah
I have a question.

Some even go and change their names to Arabic names. Is all of this necessary?

You don't need to change your name in order to become a Muslim. There are some converts who prefer to change their names but for those who want to keep it, there in nothing wrong with that.

Peace
 

Peace

Quran & Sunnah
MatthiasGould said:
It's more of an issue of reading the various 'prayer guides' different Islamic sites give. I'm not sure if these guides differ according to sect guidelines or not.
I seem to remember getting confused as one prayer guide said to do qunoot during the second rakah of the prayers, yet I was told by an actual Muslim this was only for Ishaa prayers.

This video will help you incha'Allah to pray properly.
The Deen Show Teach Me How to Pray | The Deen Show with Eddie

I'm also confused as one prayer guide said to recite Takbir and then Fatihah to begin prayers, whilst THIS guide gives a series of other supplications to begin the first rakah in addition to the takbir and Surah al-Fatihah.

It's not a must to recite the supplication before starting reciting al-Fatiha. That can come later, once you master how to pray.
 
Last edited:

Gharib

I want Khilafah back
I have a question.

Is the political views necessary as muslims? In other words, do we need to strive to establish shariah, instead of secularism? Do we need to wage jihad in order to force out dominance in places?

I also have another question. In America, a lot of muslims seem to adopt Saudi culture. The women wear the Saudi style khemars and niqabs, while the men wear the keffiyah and thobes. Some even go and change their names to Arabic names. Is all of this necessary?

Islam is a way of life, it has it's own rules and regulations. The primary and secondary sources of Islamic teachings are the Qur'an and Sunnah (hadith) of our Prophet.

One cannot be a Muslim and say that the laws of Allah (shariah) are not necessary. The whole point of being a Muslim is to live in accordance to what Allah has permitted and prohibited.

Islam is not merely about 'beliefs' it is about everything that you can think of.

Waging Jihad against other countries is seen as evil because the people of those 'other countries' present it so. Ask a non-Muslim about the US and it's forcing of it's democracy over non-democratic countries. They will say that it is justice. But ask them about Islam and Shariah they will say it is injustice and evil to force other people to live under the laws of another country. They dislike Islam therefore everything Islamic is evil, they like democracy therefore every crime the US and it's allies commit is justice.

As Muslims we must show support for Shariah (the laws of Allah by which humanity is to live).

And the correct ruling on this is that first we offer people to accept Islam, if they reject it we offer them to accept our rule over them and if they reject this also then we fight them.
 
Last edited:
Top