• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Secular Power is a blessing to humanity, not some sort of divine chastisement

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I think it has been a blessing to get religious leaders out of power over people. The down side is the lowest common denominator wins out. So, especially for religious people, society is going downhill.

But many religious were "given" supposedly by God with laws and rules that were meant for all the people in that religion to follow. So what happens when a religion is able to control a whole empire or nation? As far as I can tell there was all kinds of abuses of power.

So now, since you are a Baha'i, we got the same situation all over again. Are we going to give the power to a religion to rule over us? I think even if the Baha'i were ever to get a majority, there would be a lot of opposition to them imposing their laws. Baha'is here on the forum say that is not their intent. That the Baha'i laws are only for Baha'is. But they sure sound like God wants them to be applied to the whole world. So would Baha'is be okay with having to continue living in a world where they live under their laws from God and having to obey secular laws?
Not my problem, I’m a liberal, not a Baha’i so I have no desire to live in a Baha’i theocracy.
 

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Which theocracy of which particular period?
I may as well ask you the same question, name the theocracy that has ever treated people better than modern democracy?
I think you will have to look at history through rose coloured glasses to find a theocracy that was better than modern democracy.

Theocracy simply can’t keep up with new knowledge and create new laws in retrospect of new knowledge.

Rather it is stuck with old laws imposed by humans but alleged to be of God and thus unchangeable due to the nature of such an allegation.
 

firedragon

Veteran Member
I may as well ask you the same question, name the theocracy that has ever treated people better than modern democracy?
I think you will have to look at history through rose coloured glasses to find a theocracy that was better than modern democracy.

Theocracy simply can’t keep up with new knowledge and create new laws in retrospect of new knowledge.

Rather it is stuck with old laws imposed by humans but alleged to be of God and thus unchangeable due to the nature of such an allegation.

Bro. I never promoted a theocracy. I am asking your position in specific details rather than general statements.

this question is no answer.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Nuke two cities and justify it to your people happened by a secular society. So many sanctions on Iran, not convinced secularism enjoins compassion, to be honest. They always pick on someone, Native Americans were seen as less human, slaves were taken and bred by a secular society founded on human rights. It's self-deception to take away God's voice in a democracy and that he has no role in guiding humans.

I haven't seen any good from secularism. Freedom of speech against oppression has taken a form of everyone is scared to speak because of being accused of being anti-Semitic. Don't accept the oppressive way of the US and Israel, and speak out, and you will be discriminated.

So freedom of speech is allowed but limited to what suits their Agenda.

I don't believe secularism is accurate. The hidden societies that rule the US are mostly Jinn Worshippers, and there is plenty of evidence for this, but for a people who don't know how reflect and see beyond their education systems telling them how to think and what to believe, there is no hope of exposing them.

God exposes reality of the fight between good and evil, don't let slogans blind you to it.

The fact is a certain flavor of spirituality has taken the west away from God's rope, is because, of constantly planning of Jinn Worshippers.

This is the reality and mental clarity that Anselm and Descartes for example provided, is strawman played in education so that they make people disbelieve in their Lord, and they use Atheists as a tool, while not even believing in the things taught by them from history or Archaeology or biology or Theology.

They want to eventually bring their own theocracy but on their own terms.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Palestinians are not even recognized as human beings and everyone taking side of an Apartheid state. You guys are racist and are using secularism to not allow other cultures a voice. This is the reality.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Little kids making you chocolate. Tricking nations to funnel all resource to making bananas or coffee with no other industry on false theories that you knew would make them slaves. Tricking nations into a debt system they cannot escape.

There is no doubt, you are ruled by Satan and his forces, and are blind by self-deception. You can cling to secular slogans, they meaning nothing, when reality is you do so much evil to the world.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Even Pharoah's people appreciated the blessings they had by oppressing others. This is all secularism has proven to be.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
And forcing the world and other counties by gun point to accept trade policies and authority of your governments on their government. You are the most evil people to exist in history, yet, talk about good and evil like you are champions of good.
 

CG Didymus

Veteran Member
Not my problem, I’m a liberal, not a Baha’i so I have no desire to live in a Baha’i theocracy.
Well that's good. Being too conservative is, what I think, a usual problem for religions that make the rules for a society... and their own people, including their leaders, have trouble keeping them.
 

Link

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Secularism has failed the world and the solution is God's rope, and returning to his guidance, and finding the king appointed by him so as to return Government to the light of God's judgment and the best one in judgment among his servants who God knows best how to prove.

We are to strive for guidance of God. Humans enforcing their unjust ways by deception and the oligarchies are not the solution.
 

Samantha Rinne

Resident Genderfluid Writer/Artist
So it looks to me like a certain person who shall not be named is using the cover of a DIR to bash secularism.

I decided to counter that by proposing the polar opposite statement in Religious Debates.

Secular Power is a blessing to humanity, not some sort of divine chastisement.

Why? Because it gives humans the power to rule themselves compassionately and in my opinion sociopaths do not constitute the majority of human beings.

You would think this, but it's not actually the case.

Many of my friends are secular. What I've noticed is that the average atheist is trying to escape the Law by denying God. Unfortunately, the curse of the Law does not go away because you say that a "big man in the sky" is not real.

When you don't have a God to worship and give you religious law, instead of becoming free from the Law, you instead become enslaved to a secular Law. "Am I earning enough? Do I have a successful career?" "Have I done charity donations?" "Am I being racist/sexist?" And so on, until you finally are in the same exact state as the sinners that the Pharisees condemned. Christianity says the solution to the Law is not to deny to Law, but to understand and accept Grace.

For a secular version of Grace, I recommend reading two books instead of the Bible. The Gifts of Imperfection, and When Panic Attacks. One is a self-help book, the other is a cognitive therapy book, but both greatly help for anyone who has issues with coping with unrealistic expectations.
 

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
We are to strive for guidance of God. Humans enforcing their unjust ways by deception and the oligarchies are not the solution.
All theocracies are a type of oligarchy, if oligarchy isn’t the solution clearly then types of oligarchy such as theocracy are not either.
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
I’m a liberal, not a Baha’i so I have no desire to live in a Baha’i theocracy.
You are a 'Bahai inspired liberal'. But Bahaism is 'old wine in new bottle', the same 7th Century 'One Allah' talk with the addition of Bahaollah being a 'mirror image' of that Allah; and curses for those who do not believe in his 'One Allah' and 'his divine mission'. In what way Bahaism has inspired you?
 
Last edited:

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
You are a 'Bahai inspired liberal'. But Bahaism is 'old wine in new bottle', the same 7th Century 'One Allah' talk with the addition of Bahaollah being a 'mirror image' of that Allah; and curses for those who do not believe in his 'One Allah' and 'his divine mission'. In what way Bahaism has inspired you?
It has inspired me to believe in certain general principles such as the one-ness of humanity, and the equality of men and women, all without the religious baggage of not allowing women on the top institutions etc, in other words I have taken as much of the hypocrisy out of the general principles as I could manage.
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
Bahais have insistnce on 'One Allah' and a manifestation who speaks for this Allah, and all people are supposed to accept his ministry for the fear of Allah. What more religious baggage do you want?
 

1213

Well-Known Member
...Because it gives humans the power to rule themselves compassionately and in my opinion sociopaths do not constitute the majority of human beings.

That could be possible even without secularism. Secularism doesn’t bring anything good that could not be without it. Instead it takes people away from God who tells that people should love even their enemies.
 

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Bahais have insistnce on 'One Allah' and a manifestation who speaks for this Allah, and all people are supposed to accept his ministry for the fear of Allah. What more religious baggage do you want?
As a liberal i’m not bound by any of that. I believe in Allah, but not in insisting on Allah.

I don’t believe in the concept of individuals who are manifestations of Allah, rather I believe everyone manifests the attributes of Allah in accordance with their capacity to do so, even you and I.

I don’t believe in the need to accept anyone’s ministry, only in the need to practice virtues according to one’s own best knowledge of them.

I’m not entirely free of religious baggage, but i’m doing the best that I can under the circumstances.

And I might add that as a liberal i’m free to accept the diversity of humanity, so I can respect the path of the atheist without feeling any compulsion to join him/her as I have my own path.
 

Maximus

the Confessor
And forcing the world and other counties by gun point to accept trade policies and authority of your governments on their government. You are the most evil people to exist in history, yet, talk about good and evil like you are champions of good.

My government has done and continues to do many horrible things in the world. There is no denying that. But I blame bad leaders more than anything else. Your average Joe on the street is much more likely than not to have a good heart and acknowledges their Creator. At least that has been my experience. We are all brothers and sisters.
 

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
That could be possible even without secularism. Secularism doesn’t bring anything good that could not be without it. Instead it takes people away from God who tells that people should love even their enemies.
It is possible to have compassionate oligarchs, it is just not very probable.

Hence the need to have power in the hands of the people. Especially when you consider that the heir to a compassionate oligarch may be a non-compassionate one it just makes sense to have enough power in the hands of the people to vote him out.

Secularism does not take people away from God, it gives them the freedom to follow God or not, which is the purpose of free will anyway. Theocracy is merely a human attempt to override the free-will god gave us.

Secularism does not prevent people loving their neighbors either, I see that as an untruth. Moreover since you cannot force someone to love someone else I fail to see how theocracy accomplishes that anyway.
 
Top