• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Should All NC-17 Films Be Released In Worldwide Mainstream Theaters?

Titanic

Well-Known Member
Exactly.

Theatres will want to make money, and NC-17 films don't get the kind of draw other films do.

Oh, and I saw Showgirls once. It was laughable for 20 minutes. Then I was embarrassed that I was still watching it. It wasn't even in the "so-bad-it's-good" camp because it kept trying to be dramatic.

I stand by what I have said. I will make a NC-17 film one day that will bring the rating into the mainstream. Like all other film ratings. I guarantee it.
 

The Sum of Awe

Brought to you by the moment that spacetime began.
Staff member
Premium Member
I don't really know, most NC-17's that I heard of kinda suck
 

HonestJoe

Well-Known Member
I don't really know, most NC-17's that I heard of kinda suck
I think there could be an element that a big-budget film involving know producers, directors, actors etc. is less likely to be given the NC-17 rating than a low-budget film by unknowns, even if the content were the same as far as rating goes. That could be a factor in many NC-17 films being low-budget trash. I've no doubt there is lots of other politics involved to, with the big production companies having an easier time than smaller ones and independents. Of course, most mainstream producers these days will avoid anything close to even R to keep their films open to a wider audience. Only the big horror films are likely to come close.

I think there is little within the scope of the ratings that should mean a film is prevented from being shown in any cinemas who wish to show them, though equally there shouldn't be any expectation that they should. After all, it's the cinemas that ultimately have the legal responsibilities concerning kids getting in and the like.
 

Titanic

Well-Known Member
I think there could be an element that a big-budget film involving know producers, directors, actors etc. is less likely to be given the NC-17 rating than a low-budget film by unknowns, even if the content were the same as far as rating goes. That could be a factor in many NC-17 films being low-budget trash. I've no doubt there is lots of other politics involved to, with the big production companies having an easier time than smaller ones and independents. Of course, most mainstream producers these days will avoid anything close to even R to keep their films open to a wider audience. Only the big horror films are likely to come close.

I think there is little within the scope of the ratings that should mean a film is prevented from being shown in any cinemas who wish to show them, though equally there shouldn't be any expectation that they should. After all, it's the cinemas that ultimately have the legal responsibilities concerning kids getting in and the like.

You do realize that there has been one NC-17 film released worldwide? Maybe when I make my NC-17 film it will change everything...
 

Poisonshady313

Well-Known Member
After all, it's the cinemas that ultimately have the legal responsibilities concerning kids getting in and the like.
What legal responsibilities? I thought the MPAA wasn't enforced by law. It's a voluntary ratings system that cinemas choose to abide by. An unsupervised 16 year old getting into an R movie may be against theater policy... but it's not against the law.
 

Titanic

Well-Known Member
What legal responsibilities? I thought the MPAA wasn't enforced by law. It's a voluntary ratings system that cinemas choose to abide by. An unsupervised 16 year old getting into an R movie may be against theater policy... but it's not against the law.

Correct.
 

HonestJoe

Well-Known Member
So no snappy comebacks?
Why would you expect a snappy comeback? Your single line response didn't change anything I'd written. There may well have only been one NC-17 "released worldwide" but there have been more made and released to some extent plus plenty given minor edits to get down to an R rating instead.

I wasn't really disagreeing with your basic premise, just responding to someone else's comment.
 

HonestJoe

Well-Known Member
What legal responsibilities? I thought the MPAA wasn't enforced by law. It's a voluntary ratings system that cinemas choose to abide by. An unsupervised 16 year old getting into an R movie may be against theater policy... but it's not against the law.
Fair point. I knew there were legal aspects in the UK (though apparently only for videos, not cinemas). Maybe there could be scope for some kind of civil suit though.
 

Titanic

Well-Known Member
Fair point. I knew there were legal aspects in the UK (though apparently only for videos, not cinemas). Maybe there could be scope for some kind of civil suit though.

Only if the kid does not leave the theater. From what I have seen that would be the only way it would be against the law. Refusing to leave. I do not think a civil suit would come into play on either side. I have never heard of one in this case.
 

Titanic

Well-Known Member
Why would you expect a snappy comeback? Your single line response didn't change anything I'd written. There may well have only been one NC-17 "released worldwide" but there have been more made and released to some extent plus plenty given minor edits to get down to an R rating instead.

I wasn't really disagreeing with your basic premise, just responding to someone else's comment.

Alright. Everything I have said has been right though. I am a expert when it comes to the movie industry.
 

Skwim

Veteran Member
Everything I have said has been right though. I am a expert when it comes to the movie industry.
arnie-levin-is-this-really-necessary-your-honor-i-m-an-expert-new-yorker-cartoon.jpg
 
Top