"Bigger" depends on how you define it. It gets complicated. Moreover, if government isn't promoting the general welfare, corporations step
The general welfare isn't usually part of corporate business plans.
The true story: Democratic presidents shrink government; Republican presidents grow it.
Using the Daily KOS to prove Democrats
shrink government?
That's like asking RJ Reynolds if cigarettes are dangerous.
Even their own presented data contradict the title.
But there's another measure....the CFR (Code Of Federal Regulations)
You'll find that every administration, regardless of party, expands it.
Here's a fun illustration....
Ref....
Reg Stats | Regulatory Studies Center | The George Washington University
Here's another fun thingie....
More things are being privatized, not federalized, and what federal agencies remain are often deliberately being defunded and mismanaged, often with a view toward eliminating them altogether:
Astounding: David Koch's 1980 VP Run: Kill Medicare, Social Security, Minimum Wage, Public Schools
More and more private companies are grabbing a share of the public pie.
Education? State universities used to be free or nearly so, and students used to be able to afford most private colleges working Summer jobs.
There isn't much privatization going on.
The Fed's budget continues increasing faster than inflation.
And there's more than just the Fed...the state & local governments are increasing regulation.
Taxes? The post-war golden age, the period of America's most rapid industrial growth and greatest personal prosperity; was a product of protectionism, strong unions, high wages, high taxes (91% top rate), strong economic regulations and generous social services. It was a prosperity born of what some would call big government.
So few understand what happened post WW2.
They see high tax rates, & think that was the cause of prosperity.
Instead, other factors led to expansion....
- The rest of the world was industrially ruined, so there was little competition.
- There was great demand after all the destruction.
- Much of our workforce switched from war to production.
- We had a huge technological advantage over everyone else.
- The high marginal tax rates praised by leftists were offset by massive tax avoidance devices, so that average tax rates were far lower. If you liked that system, that makes you pro-loophole for the wealthy.