Rational Agnostic
Well-Known Member
In this post, I am going to briefly highlight my thoughts on the concept of hell and "eternal punishment" that is found in many religions, most notably in Christianity and Islam and why the "hell" that is presented in these religions is necessarily immoral and unjust. In these religions, eternal suffering in hell is declared to be the just punishment for "sins," which are so-called infractions against the god. However, it should be quite obvious that acts of immorality committed by humans must necessarily be finite in nature, since the human lifespan is finite. Infinite punishment for finite crimes is necessarily unjust. It also makes no sense mathematically. Let's say we would like to think of God's game of cosmic retribution as a mathematical equation. Suppose the "sins" commit against it are considered to be subtractions from one side of the equation, and then God is compelled to "balance" the equation by adding a quantity back that is equal to the amount subtracted by his creations. This added quantity would be the punishment that he would visit upon his creations. If a finite number is subtracted from one side of an equation, the equation is no longer an equation if infinity is added to that side. This is one, logical way of objecting to the morality of eternal punishment.
Possible objection 1: Sins are infinite because they are crimes against an infinite god. However, this certainly does not follow. In fact, the exact opposite would be true. Crimes committed against the less powerful are worse than crimes committed against the more powerful. For example, stealing $100 from an impoverished person is a much more heinous act than stealing $100 from a billionaire, because in the case of the former, it is a much larger percentage of his/her wealth. It logically follows that an infinite being cannot even be effected by humans at all, which would imply that any sins committed against it would be infinitely small atrocities.
Possible objection 2: God can do whatever he wants, even if it disagrees with your concept of what is "logical." This is also untrue. Even a god cannot violate logic. If you disagree, then answer this question. Can God create a square circle? Or, more pertinent to the topic at hand, can God create a universe where 7+2 does not equal 19-10? Can God create a universe where 5 does not equal 5?
Possible objection 1: Sins are infinite because they are crimes against an infinite god. However, this certainly does not follow. In fact, the exact opposite would be true. Crimes committed against the less powerful are worse than crimes committed against the more powerful. For example, stealing $100 from an impoverished person is a much more heinous act than stealing $100 from a billionaire, because in the case of the former, it is a much larger percentage of his/her wealth. It logically follows that an infinite being cannot even be effected by humans at all, which would imply that any sins committed against it would be infinitely small atrocities.
Possible objection 2: God can do whatever he wants, even if it disagrees with your concept of what is "logical." This is also untrue. Even a god cannot violate logic. If you disagree, then answer this question. Can God create a square circle? Or, more pertinent to the topic at hand, can God create a universe where 7+2 does not equal 19-10? Can God create a universe where 5 does not equal 5?