Kolibri
Well-Known Member
Quick question. Are you disfellowshiped? Or did you write a letter to be disassociated? or did you simply stop with no judicial hearing?I went to Jehovah on what you posted #95. He knows I'm not smart enough to figure out which way to turn. He has given me an answer in you post #95.
I have stood for Jehovah all my life, and will always do so. I will not follow men if I do not agree with how they understand the scriptures. One thing I did learn from JW's..".How to identify a false religion." I was baptized as a JW in 1968. Most of my family, and congregation had been JW’s for 60+ years. The stories go way back. I have read printed material of the WT dating back to their start. Their history is not what they say it is. They claim they started as Bible Students…not true. They broke off from them. The Bible Students are still around, and as crazy as ever.
I left the WT 19 years ago. I was told about the changes they made because what they were doing was not in line with what the scriptures said. And yes, they always have a scape goat on the top who is removed…with bonus, and retirement money. It’s the same old story again.
They don’t have the right to make someone pass 60 questions before being baptized, nor do they have the right to tell anyone they are no longer a servant of Jehovah. I will never follow men. There is only one between humans and God, his name is Jesus. The WT has put men between man, and Jesus.
The big hook of the WT is they tell 99% truth. I still stand that all religions are false…I wish it was not so. Being alone serving God is not easy.
When I was a JW, I would have wrote what you wrote in post #95. I have learned more in the past 19 years than I did in the first 30. Ask yourself this question: "All the trees in the Bible are symbolic. Why is the tree in the Garden treated as a real tree?"
I ask so I know how to act according to my own conscience.
I was disfellowshipped for about 10 years once, but I personally had no issue with the arrangement from a doctrinal standpoint. And I longed for the time I could show love for God w/o hypocrisy. (Ro 12:9; 1 Cor 15:11-13)
Please understand, as much as I am happy to have been of some help to you in answering a prayer, that I will defer to the elders in your local congregation to handle any further questions if you are disfellowshipped or wrote a letter of disassociation.
I do not know the particulars of Raymond Franz's 'retirement.' However, if he was unable to provide for himself due to long term absence from anything more than a stipend, it only seems natural to me that his basic needs would have been provided for in a way that would not require further direct contact. But as I said this is a personal opinion, I do not know the particulars nor do I have an interest in finding out.
Last edited: