You can't go by that alone. Like Star Wars. It's been told thousands of times before and hundreds of times since. But that doesn't capture the special effects and movie engineering achievements and accomplishments of the Trilogy. It also retold this tale--a tale that even our ancient ancestors knew some form of--in a way for the modern era of computers and doing things in space.
It also can't capture the presence of Darth Vader, a character so impressively imposing and powerful that for a a few decades the whole physical disability and handicap thing really just doesn't come up, not even after the Prequels and more people than just nerds knew about Anakin's story. Let's be honest, most other circumstances it would be cruel and barbaric to elevate the sound of a breathing assistance machine like Vader's breathing has.
Or the Boondock Saints. Two Irish brothers whacking mobsters doesn't really sound appealing. But Wilhelm Dafoe, as usual, is worth watching. The jokes aimed at itself are pretty good. And it raises some very great questions about vigilantism because these are dangerous mobsters who, for this reason and that, have been untouchable by the law in any meaningful way, and at the end even has a news segment thingy with people giving their views on it.
And, as
@Revoltingest can attest, a kids-adults teams playing a game of dodgeball at the behest of .01% ultra-wealthy pukes with gambling problems (the white American puts the whole community on the line) doesn't sound like it's entertaining but it is great, a moment of shining brilliance of a star for a character who's normally dull(as far as the characters personality goes) and an emotional black hole to be around, a wonderful Peanuts bit for one of the best TV kids ever made, and there's a huge bonus for Mel Brooks fans.