There Are No Errors In The Gathas

[Rival]

That sounds great and I do agree, the aim of any sane religion would be to do good but what does "Good Thoughts, Good Words and Good Deeds" actually mean in real terms? For example, what would it mean for me if I was in a situation of, like I said before, familial dispute. What practical advice am I receiving? What does "good deeds" mean in this situation?

Do what seems best to you. And even if you're wrong, it's a learning curve.

Night folks!

 

[Augustus]

That's Zorophobic.

That's only if the fear is irrational...

I bet your so called 'fire temples' don't have a health and safety licence. It's one rule for you Zoroastrians and another for the rest of us...

 

[paarsurrey]

They are a bit like psalms, only more theological They are the only text Reform Zoroastrians believe to have been composed by The Prophet himself, so of course they are special.

Did Zoroaster claim that the Gathas are perfect? Please quote from Gathas? Do all the Zoroastrians, not only specific to Reform Zoroastrians, believe that only Gathas are perfect and none else? Please
Regards

 

[Subhankar Zac]

No errors in the bhagavad gita.
Prove me wrong and I'll... Leave this book out!!
Lol. JK. JK. JK.
In India we have many Zoroastrians, tge highest in the world, though I've never met with one to this date.
Most Zoroastrians in India or Parsis practice their ancestral faith as well as Hinduism, Islam, Sikhism, etc.
It's very beautiful to see such diversity.

 

[Shiranui117]

Prove me wrong and I'll convert

Here are the Gathas http://zoroastrian.org/GathaSongs/song01.htm

"Righteousness is the best good."
If this is true, then why is the PlayStation the best-selling good of all time?
Checkmate, Gathas!

 

[lewisnotmiller]

That's only if the fear is irrational...

I bet your so called 'fire temples' don't have a health and safety licence. It's one rule for you Zoroastrians and another for the rest of us...

Heck, I don't think they even had a building permit in the first place. That explains how they could just spring up when required.

 

[paarsurrey]

No errors in the bhagavad gita.
Prove me wrong and I'll... Leave this book out!!
Lol. JK. JK. JK.
In India we have many Zoroastrians, tge highest in the world, though I've never met with one to this date.
Most Zoroastrians in India or Parsis practice their ancestral faith as well as Hinduism, Islam, Sikhism, etc.
It's very beautiful to see such diversity.

This means such persons adhere to Zoroastrianism as a race, otherwise they are not satisfied with the present form of Zoroastrianism, and look for guidance elsewhere.
Maybe such persons are confused or undecided. Right?
Regards

 

[The Emperor of Mankind]

This means such persons adhere to Zoroastrianism as a race, otherwise they are not satisfied with the present form of Zoroastrianism, and look for guidance elsewhere.
Maybe such persons are confused or undecided. Right?
Regards

You've mistaken what Subhanker is saying. Because Parsis are so strict on who they consider Zoroastrians, the terms 'Zoroastrians' and 'Parsis' are sometimes used interchangeably. So it's an easy mistake to make. What Subhanker is saying that there are Parsis (who are descendants of those fleeing Islamic persecution in the conquered Persian Empire) who are Muslims or Hindus or Sikhs or Zoroastrians - not that they're practising more than one at the same time.

What you've said is equivalent to calling Islam a race, or Christianity a race; none of that is true because there are members of these faiths who aren't members of that religion's dominant ethnicity. Respectively, non-Arabs, non-Caucasians and (in the case of Zoroastrianism) non-Iranis.

 

[idav]

Prove me wrong and I'll convert

Here are the Gathas http://zoroastrian.org/GathaSongs/song01.htm

I know many of loving songs that go unanswered.

For I know, loving songs for a worthy purpose
never go unanswered by You.(Gathas: Song 1 stanza 10)

Checkmate!

 

[Rival]

I know many of loving songs that go unanswered.

For I know, loving songs for a worthy purpose
never go unanswered by You.(Gathas: Song 1 stanza 10)

Checkmate!

You can only understand the Gathas after you become a Zoroastrian!

There's no error Try again!

 

[paarsurrey]

There Are No Errors In The Gathas

Gathas says there are prophets which is plural and needs three at least if not more. Please name all of them.
Regards

 

[paarsurrey]

There Are No Errors In The Gathas
Gathas says there are prophets which is plural and needs three at least if not more. Please name all of them.

Did Zoroaster name the "Prophets" or did Zoroaster define the office of prophet? If he did not then the Gathas are sure in error. Right? Please correct me if I am wrong.
Regards

 

[Aquitaine]

Hahahaahahahahaahahaha, hello.


The Gathas is man made.

If only you could see it. . .

 

[paarsurrey]

There Are No Errors In The Gathas

Please give claims and reasons from Gathas that:

1. Gathas have complete teachings that were given to Zorosater by G-d (Ahura-Mazda).
2. Did G-d (Ahura Mazda) took the responsibility that it will be protected by Him? Please quote from Gathas in the connection.
3. Zoroaster was given a religion from G-d (Ahura Mazda) that was for the whole world.
4. Did G-d (Ahura Mazda) tell Zoroaster as to what will happen to his religion afterwards, 1400 ago (approximately).

Regards

 

[paarsurrey]

There Are No Errors In The Gathas

Please give claims and reasons from Gathas that:

1. Gathas have complete teachings that were given to Zorosater by G-d (Ahura-Mazda).
2. Did G-d (Ahura Mazda) took the responsibility that it will be protected by Him? Please quote from Gathas in the connection.
3. Zoroaster was given a religion from G-d (Ahura Mazda) that was for the whole world.
4. Did G-d (Ahura Mazda) tell Zoroaster as to what will happen to his religion afterwards, 1400 ago (approximately).

Regards

Gathas are prayers, they don't contain complete words revealed on prophet Zoroaster, his teachings and the guidance provided by him. What else is to error?
Regards