I think you're right
Revelations are never exact
Hence these claims are "not smart" at best
People seem to love their cherries indeed
Cherry picking usually happens when Religious Superiority kicks in. I believe anyone with or without Religion can reach the Goal of Life (whatever that is), so
I never cherry pick to prove a Religion is false, because I don't believe any Religion is false.
Followers just should not belittle Feelings or faith of others, because that obviously is wrong (proof is simple: read RF Rule nr ...
)
True, much smarter
Even better: first do introspection and ask "why I feel the need to prove/impose my faith to/on others"
Messy indeed it gets