Yes it should be, but paraphrasing from Animal Farm: "Some Americans are more equal than others". In June 2015 thanks to the SCOTUS more Americans became equal.
I can't tell because, at least to me, this is worded slightly confusingly, but are you suggesting that because of the 2015 ruling on gay marriage that somehow gay Americans are "more equal" than non-gay Americans? Because if that's the case, I'd like you to explain how being granted the same rights and protections as everyone else is somehow Orwellian.