Katzpur
Not your average Mormon
This thread is specifically for the benefit of Thana, who asked some questions in a recently closed thread titled, "Odd Mormon Beliefs." Thana, I answered your first question before the thread was closed, but told you I'd get back to you this morning with answers to your other questions. When I went to do so, the thread had been closed. I asked Quintessence, who had closed it, what he would suggest I do about your unanswered questions. I wanted to be sure that it was okay with the staff that we continue our discussion. He advised me to go about it by starting a new thread. So, you asked the following:
I would agree that the vast majority of the prophets mentioned in the Old Testament are Jewish. Balaam, whose story is told in Numbers 22, however, was not. While he was never considered a major prophet, the fact is that he was a prophet and was not Jewish. I would think that the Old Testament prophets were Jews is merely a reflection of the fact that the Old Testament is the religious history of the Jewish people. The Messiah was born of a Jewish woman and had a Jewish lineage. But Jesus Christ commanded His Apostles to preach His gospel to the gentiles as well as to the Jews. And certainly, if God can speak to a Jew, He can speak to a Christian. There is really no qualification that a person be Jewish in order to be chosen by God as a spokesperson. As to why God would change His pattern for Joseph Smith, I think a much, much more significant question is this: Why would God change His pattern of speaking to His children here on earth through a chosen prophet and suddenly, after guiding and directing mankind for 4000 years by means of a prophet, simply decide to leave us with a few ancient writings and stop talking to us entirely?Thana said:Also all the prophets in the bible (As well as Jesus) were Jewish whilst Joseph Smith was not. So why would God change pattern for Him?
These are merely depictions. They are artistic renderings made by human beings who tend to picture God looking the way they want Him to look. This has been the case for nearly 2000 years. All of the earliest Christian art shows Jesus as being a white man. Medieval art depicts Mary as being dressed as a medieval noblewoman, for Heaven's sake, and shows Christ as holding a golden scepter. I believe that Jesus probably looked pretty much like an average Middle-eastern man of His time period. They way He is depicted in general by either non-LDS or LDS Christian artists is immaterial in my opinion. Joseph Smith did describe Him as having a "brightness and glory [which] defy all description." If this was the case, and if the pillar of light surrounding Him was "above the brightness of the sun," His glory itself would have overshadowed any particular skin color.Thana said:And a lot of depictions of Joseph Smith's meeting with God and Jesus has them as white, but as far as I'm aware they are not and would not have been.
Actually Joseph apparently did pass out as a result of his vision. He said, "When I came to myself again, I found myself lying on my back, looking into Heaven. When the light had departed, I had no strength." When he was finally able to get up and return to his home, his mother could tell that there was something very wrong. He seemed exhausted and was unable to stand without leaning against the fireplace. As to why he didn't die as a result of his vision, about all I can say (and I don't mean this to sound sarcastic) was that if God had allowed him to die, there really wouldn't have been much point to the whole experience at all. Wouldn't you agree?Thana said:Not to mention that anyone who has ever witnessed the divine fell prostrate/dead, So why didn't that happen to Joseph Smith?
Well, it would certainly indicate that Mormon leaders aren't perfect. They mess up from time to time just like everybody else.Thana said:And I know this might be a bit touchy, feel free not to answer if you like, but if the practices of polygamy and exclusion of black men from the priesthood were abandoned by the Church, wouldn't the very fact that they were ever practiced and accepted indicate that Mormonism is just as corrupted as any other denomination?
Last edited: