• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Vamachara

Wannabe Yogi

Well-Known Member
What are you talking about?
I provided archaeological evidence from the sites of the Bactria and Margiana Archaeological Complex.
The reason my ideas sound like "100% speculation" is because the BMAC wasn't discovered until 1976. It isn't nearly as well known as Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro (which were discovered in the 1920s).

There is no archaeological evidence for an invasion into Bactria and Margiana.[5] Furthermore, there is no evidence that the complex even represented an ethnic/linguistic unity. Moreover, cultural links between the BMAC and the Indus Valley can also be explained by reciprocal cultural influences uniting the two cultures, or by the transfer of luxury or commercial goods.[6]

Bactria

He even won the 2009 Kalaignar M. Karunanidhi Classical Tamil Award!

This award has received much criticism as being politically based and not given for good scholarship.
 

TTCUSM

Member
There is no archaeological evidence for an invasion into Bactria and Margiana.[5] Furthermore, there is no evidence that the complex even represented an ethnic/linguistic unity. Moreover, cultural links between the BMAC and the Indus Valley can also be explained by reciprocal cultural influences uniting the two cultures, or by the transfer of luxury or commercial goods.[6]

Bactria

Page 76 of The Afghans by Willem Vogelsang:
Whatever the specific ramifications we will probably never understand, there probably was, for some time, a situation of equilibrium. Symbiosis implies exchange between two parties. When at some stage one of the parties becomes too strong or too weak, the symbiosis is disrupted. In Margiana and Bactria this happened in the late first half of the second millennium BC when pressure from the north upon the oasis settlements of the BMAC simply became too strong for the sedentary population to resist. There was no longer any exchange. The Indo-Iranians who had been in constant contact with BMAC were themselves swept aside by their kinsmen who pushed from behind. Masses of Indo-Iranians settled and passed through the lands that formerly had been inhabited by the BMAC people, without adopting any of their characteristics. It was a matter of numbers. When the Indo-Aryans eventually arrived in the northwest of the Indian subcontinent, their knowledge of the BMAC culture was almost nil. Only recent archaeological research has brought this great civilization from northern Afghanistan back to life.
 
Top