Copernicus
Industrial Strength Linguist
Evidence exists and is being studied. See, for example:
Independent reviews of the evidence appears to suggest and errant Islamic Jihad missile. Muddying the waters with ad hoc conspiracy theories serves neither the victims nor the Israelis. It's simply propagating "alternative facts" consistent with one's biases and, as such, differs little methodologically from the claims being propagated by Hamas.
I made what was clearly a passing remark that I "wouldn't put it past" Hamas (or now Islamic Jihad) to have deliberately blown up the building themselves precisely because of the effect it would have on the now-delayed ground invasion, not to mention stoking up outrage. You keep spinning it as a "conspiracy theory" and "alternative facts", but false flag operations are not unprecedented. For fanatics, the end justifies the means sometimes. This is just an internet discussion board, and it is perfectly permissible here to air opinions about what might account for an event where all of the facts are not known.
I have said nothing to contradict the facts as reported, but Israel has been spinning video evidence from an Al Jazeera feed that Al Jazeera itself says has been misused by them:
Video investigation: What hit al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza?
Israel says Palestinian fighters bombed Gaza’s al-Ahli Arab Hospital in a misfire. Is that true?
www.aljazeera.com
Al Jazeera is trying to make it look like the tragedy was caused by a misfired rocket from the terrorists, but their analysis does not really explain what caused the explosion. It looks possible to me that debris from the Iron Dome defensive strike may have rained down on the ground and set off that explosion. Maybe it hit an ammo dump near the hospital. Maybe the cause was really just a misfired rocket that wasn't caught on video. We may never know.
What concerns me is what I consider an incontrovertible fact:
which concludes:
In sum, I am not suggesting that anyone should uncritically accept whatever Israel says. But that same skepticism should certainly extend to Hamas, a terrorist organization that is not noted for its devotion to either honesty or human decency. The “battle of the narrative” is more important than ever. That makes it all the more imperative that the world — journalists especially — not echo the claims of either side without first checking them out.
That makes a lot of sense, and I agree with it up to a point. The problem is that it isn't clear what the facts are, and what people accept as facts tends to be reporting that confirms their biases. I think that Bloomberg's Marc Champion has a great take on how the truth gets buried in competing claims by both sides.
Gaza hospital tragedy escalates war risk, no matter who’s to blame
Truth, infamously, is the first casualty of war and that’s never more important to remember than after a major tragedy such as the reported strike on a Gaza hospital, with the death-toll estimate at about 500.
It isn’t just the scale and pain of the human loss that has shocked. The event also upended U.S. President Joe Biden’s visit to the region, where he had been due to meet separately with Israeli and Arab leaders on containing the conflict and getting aid to civilians in Gaza.
That latter summit has now been canceled, and inevitably so. Such is the outrage on the Arab Street that no regional leader can afford to be seen negotiating today with Israel’s most important ally. And whereas European lawmakers have avoided attributing blame while condemning the attack, Egypt and Saudi Arabia immediately pointed to Israel.
In a very small pool, Israel is a top suspect: It has been conducting an intense aerial bombing campaign with just the kind of heavy munitions that could collapse a hospital and cause mass casualties. Yet at this point, there are very few things that can be said with certainty and none concern the details of the attack or its perpetrators.
Obviously, we need to suspend judgment until all the facts are known, but we can never be sure that we've arrived at a time when all the facts are known.