Shad
Veteran Member
In a single payer healthcare system they do not "hire" doctors. They take the function of health insurance. Your premimum is taxes and you are covered 100%. You have waiting lists and you have wait times. You may be denied a specific treatment or surgery because it requires a specific diagnosis that you do not qualify for. This is our current system. It will be the same with single payer healthcare.
I said government hires doctors under a national system. The government is the employer. Go look up Canadian laws as you are clueless.
It is the same with insurance companies here. If you don't want to accept what the insurance is willing to pay then you dont' get paid. Canadian doctors make about the same as American doctors.
No you do not understand. I can not cancel my plan. Americans can. I can not use certain services outside government regulations as it is illegal. I am forced by law to use the national system in many cases. Canadian doctors make half as much as American doctors.
http://www.oecd.org/health/health-systems/41925333.pdf
It does not. If you want to pay for fast service out of pocket you are allowed to. In Canada it is not illegal to practice medicine and work purely out of pocket of your customers. A doctor in Canada can set up office and practice (within legal parameters of medicine) and never take a dime from the government. However they will go out of buisiness rather quickly since Canadians often just go to the doctor for free rather than paying to get there faster. Same here. We will still have private doctors for the ultra rich who want to pay for them out of pocket. But the vast majority of people will just go to the doctor for free.
Wrong. Read the Canada Health Act which outlines certain services provided by the national system can not be provided by private sources.
Such as?
Wages of doctors and access to parallel services just I have repeatedly brought up.
Results matter. Americans are not drastically more unhealthy than Canadians for example. Yet they pay far less for better service.
The cost of the results matter. All you have done is put forward the end justifies the means. The obesity rate in Canada compared to the US shows otherwise as do the diets. Quality of service in a private system varies based on income and insurance policy. Under a national system the minority classes (upper) pay more into the system than those below with a reduction in quality in comparison to a private one they could use.
This requires evidence.
Linked above
Canadian doctors make about the same as Americans and get their degree's for far cheaper.
False a per the link. Cheaper degrees is due to the Canadian government subsidies student debt to offset what they pay practitioners. It is cheaper as the taxpayer pays a part of this debt. Go look up the subsidies provided to doctors. Do note that even after all of this they still take home less than Americans.
Requires evidence.
Go look any Canadian news paper covering healthcare over the last twenty years. Go look up the budget of the system which increases yearly. You would know about this if you were actually informed about the system being discussed or actually lived here.
Requires evidence.
Linked within this comment
The government does not tell people to go die if they reach their lifetime limit of coverage.
Hyperbole and emotional pandering. If a contract terms have been reached the contract has been fulfilled. A contract which the customer agreed. More so these companies will tell people to use the public system or their own funds. Your point is inane.
It is handled no differnetly than the US system with two major exceptions. Currently we have a large number of specialists in America and few primary providers. Canada is the opposite. They have tons of primary providers and few specialists.
Yes I know. However even our GP are working 50 hours or more a week. The workload has been an issue for years.
It has little to do with how much money they make as they make about the same as America does.
Which is completely false as the wage difference is as large as 50%. When one has two job opportunities wages and workload do matter. You live in la la land if you think otherwise.
Secondly poor people don't just ignore horrible symptoms till its too late in Canadian system.
So? They choose to ignore their health issues. That is their problem. More so the government system does not force people to visit their doctors. What you mean one system provides care to the poor so they are more willing to use it as it cost them little. That is called being cheap.
http://www.oecd.org/health/health-systems/41925333.pdf
Hospital closures cited in debt report as way to save money
http://www.ontariohealthcoalition.c...-Report-on-Hospital-Cuts-final-for-print1.pdf
B.C. health overhaul includes hospital closures
Nova Scotia logs record-breaking year for ER closures