• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What would you do?

If you felt conviction with certainty that a fetus is human, would you take a stand for life?

  • Yes

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • No

    Votes: 5 38.5%

  • Total voters
    13

columbus

yawn <ignore> yawn
so I will be a superstitious fool and humiliate myself for doing what my heart tells me is God's will and my responsibility as a Catholic.
Have you considered going to your church and offering to volunteer for something?
I don't know anything about your parish, but one big reason I am connected here is because they do so much organized charity work.

And, nothing personal, but you aren't the easiest person to work with.
I think you could do a great deal of good for "the least". But I also think you'd benefit from doing it in a structured environment with advice from experienced people.
Tom
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
Abortion happens to married women as well - my mother had one because they could not care for a baby due to economic circumstances.

Her experience, admitted to me late in her life, cemented how I view being pro-life which is close to @columbus "Breathing" is not life except in the most reductionistic sense and there are many reasons why a woman might have an abortion.

To be pro-life really means to be pro-human. We need to have universal health care that includes helping women decide when to get pregnant. We need to stop the horrible slaughter by the gun that shows that we're uncivilized savages compared to the developed nations. We need to ensure that children are cared for and not allowed to suffer due to privation by sharing our wealth with the "least of these" and that includes a health care system which takes care of those who have handicaps of various sorts so there is no economic pressure to abort because of a lack of money.

We've not learned the lesson yet because we keep repeating the mistake of thinking that outlawing something will stop people. People drank during prohibition. People take drugs today. People including my mother had an abortion when it was strictly illegal.

People change behavior not because something is outlawed but because something obviously better and more attractive exists. So far we're not willing to do what is necessary to build that attractive alternative.
 

Spiderman

Veteran Member
Have you considered going to your church and offering to volunteer for something?
I don't know anything about your parish, but one big reason I am connected here is because they do so much organized charity work.

And, nothing personal, but you aren't the easiest person to work with.
I think you could do a great deal of good for "the least". But I also think you'd benefit from doing it in a structured environment with advice from experienced people.
Tom
My parish currently is mainly Hispanic. Most masses are in spanish and the immigrants speak little English and I don't speak Spanish. I've been looking into volunteer work with my caseworker.

My volunteer work turned into a disaster in the ghetto of New York when I got into a fight, but it was drug related. Now that I'm committed to sobriety, and since I broke so many bones in a drug related suicide attempt, I don't think I'll get into anymore fights :)
 

Spiderman

Veteran Member
It boils down to men using women as objects to satisfy their lusts. Some of the weakest most hedonist men I know are pro choice. I wonder why? ;)

If you all knew how much I loved women, you would know how much it hurts to be labeled a misogynist who shames women who have had abortions. I want women to know it isn't their fault and get over it.

I place the fault primarily on weak, undisciplined, hedonistic, men who use women as objects or get women pregnant and leave them.

Men are more at fault for the abortion epidemic than women. FAR more! But people will still accuse me of bashing women.

I'm sick to death of lust, selfishness, pride, and hedonism in our culture of death! That is primarily coming from men!
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
I'm sick to death of lust, selfishness, pride, and hedonism in our culture of death! That is primarily coming from men!

In the Eastern system of 4 ages, the Kali/Dark/Iron age now ending is one where masculine energies predominate. In the Golden age now being born, feminine energies come to the fore.

I sense that this great transition has just barely started. It can be aided by people of good will who try to live a positive life.
 

crossfire

LHP Mercuræn Feminist Heretic Bully ☿
Premium Member
Human trafficking is thoroughly disgusting to me, and I cannot fathom what the victims go through! It is far worse than death. If I can find a way to successfully fight it I will!

Human trafficking to me is worse than abortion! However, I feel in God's eyes the 50 million humans terminated legally is a worse abomination because of the sheer quantity and how prevalent it is. Me and God disagree there. I'm texting this post and literally every time I push a letter on this phone, an abortion happens somewhere, a human is legally slain and a mother is wounded!

You think I like talking about this on a predominantly liberal forum, that I've been a member of for years, and made friends with liberals I admire very much who supported me in my dark moments and trying times??

You think I like looking like a simple-minded misogynistic fascist that people lose respect for? Not even slightly! It leaves me feeling rather Ill to be honest!

But I don't see human trafficking as something the Government and media support, so I will be a superstitious fool and humiliate myself for doing what my heart tells me is God's will and my responsibility as a Catholic.

We are to be hot or cold. If we are lukewarm God will vomit us out. God is demanding that I not be lukewarm over the slaying of more than a trillion humans made in his image and likeness!

I hope you understand.
Like I said, it's easier for you to harass women than it is to do something about the modern-day slavers that disgust you even more.
 

crossfire

LHP Mercuræn Feminist Heretic Bully ☿
Premium Member
It boils down to men using women as objects to satisfy their lusts. Some of the weakest most hedonist men I know are pro choice. I wonder why? ;)

If you all knew how much I loved women, you would know how much it hurts to be labeled a misogynist who shames women who have had abortions. I want women to know it isn't their fault and get over it.

I place the fault primarily on weak, undisciplined, hedonistic, men who use women as objects or get women pregnant and leave them.

Men are more at fault for the abortion epidemic than women. FAR more! But people will still accuse me of bashing women.

I'm sick to death of lust, selfishness, pride, and hedonism in our culture of death! That is primarily coming from men!
....and how do you know the reasons why women choose to have an abortion? (Do you even consider women capable of making that choice?)
 

Nous

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
I didn't vote for Trump but my heart tells me to vote in the future for the most pro-life candidate.

I hear the spirit of slain infants crying when I pray. I'm completely convinced that roughly 50 million humans are slain by abortion every year. I know this forum is predominantly liberal, and I will be seen as a simple-minded, misogynistic, leper for my views, for that is how I once viewd pro-lifers. That is the sacrifice I'm willing to make for the slain spirits of the unborn. My work in the pro-life movement will be more than posting online. I will take action and you won't see me on this forum much.

I believe the babies are in Paradise and my concern is less for them and more about God's wrath and the hedonism, lust, secularism, sexual addiction, and immorality in our world that leads to so many abortions. My prayers are for the souls of women in these predicaments and my anger is at the men who get these women pregnant and leave them! My grievances are also at the government and culture. The women are not at fault or to be shamed, but homicide is still homicide. If you were convinced that life begins at conception, would you word the atrocious acts of baby-killing differently.

I find it heartbreaking what women must go through and I'm angry at God for their pain, desperation, sorrow, and fear, that leads to the choice. My heart is torn! If I was a female rape victim or pregnant from incest, I would have an abortion as the most merciful approach for me and the child. I would give the child a name, apologise, and beg God for Mercy for having an innocent defenseless human slain. That is what I would do if I were a woman, and I know of women who did just that.

I watched a movie called"a silent scream". I saw the baby struggling, panicking, frantic, and in agony as the instruments of abortion dismembered it's body. I am sickened, disturbed, and convicted from the holy Spirit, through much prayer and reflection, that I can't remain passive about this.

I know liberals will see me as a sick, simple-minded leper, but this is the message my heart keeps receiving when I pray, and I had to get it out. God will punish the world for sin! I don't agree with God's treatment of people, but my heart is convicted that this is true, and that I am to take a stand for life.

God bless you all and have a Merry Christmas! I would be sick in the head if I delighted in starting a thread like this... the truth is heartbreaking, but I can't shake these convictions, and I see a sick, hedonistic, decadent, materialistic, selfish, Godless, abominable culture of death heading for destruction and grievous chastisement from Almighty God!

I was a leftist but no more. Communists killed far more people than fascists. Leftist policies kill more than the right, especially when you add the 50 million souls of aborted babies every year and the souls harmed and murdered through secularism and it's errors.

What would you do if you were haunted by these convictions? I love liberals and I hope and pray we all receive enlightenment and eternity in Paradise. Peace and good-will to you all!
In answer to the title question, I do not doubt that a fetus inside a human body is in fact a Homo sapiens. But the Court has held that “Constitutional protection of the woman's decision to terminate her pregnancy derives from the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment,” and that “viability marks the earliest point at which the State's interest in fetal life is constitutionally adequate to justify a legislative ban on nontherapeutic abortions.” Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey.

The most effective way to reduce the number of abortions is to seek to ensure that women have access to birth control. Defund Planned Parenthood If You Want to Increase Teen Birth Rates and Abortions I definitely support anyone who endeavors to make birth control more available to women and teens who can become pregnant.
 

Spiderman

Veteran Member
....and how do you know the reasons why women choose to have an abortion? (Do you even consider women capable of making that choice?)
I'm sure I don't know all the reasons. It's an unwanted pregnancy which is almost always the result of someone not exercising self-control and being responsible.
I consider women capable of making the choice and sometimes abortion is the lesser of two evils, but still evil nonetheless
 

TripleZ

The Empty Cross
Actually I think you'll find the translation should be basically "do NOT commit murder". (There was quite a bit of God sanctioned killing in the Old Testament.) Also, murder is a legal term. It means to take a person's life in a manner that goes against the written law. Abortion is legal, therefore it cannot be murder. Let me ask you a question: would you be okay if a fourteen year old impregnated rape victim wanted to abort the unwanted fetus planted in her?

you say that " you think ,,, " etc the CJB says; "Exo 20:13 ו "Do not murder. " then this is Gos Word not man's word..Remember that God gave Israel 620 Ordinances to follow up the 10 basic Laws...
 

TripleZ

The Empty Cross
Actually I think you'll find the translation should be basically "do NOT commit murder". (There was quite a bit of God sanctioned killing in the Old Testament.) Also, murder is a legal term. It means to take a person's life in a manner that goes against the written law. Abortion is legal, therefore it cannot be murder. Let me ask you a question: would you be okay if a fourteen year old impregnated rape victim wanted to abort the unwanted fetus planted in her?

I did not mention any of those issues, they are all your suppositions...You are also now talking about man made laws anyway....
 

crossfire

LHP Mercuræn Feminist Heretic Bully ☿
Premium Member
I'm sure I don't know all the reasons. It's an unwanted pregnancy which is almost always the result of someone not exercising self-control and being responsible.
I consider women capable of making the choice and sometimes abortion is the lesser of two evils, but still evil nonetheless
Even the best birth control (tubal ligation) is not 100% effective.
 

TripleZ

The Empty Cross
Actually I think you'll find the translation should be basically "do NOT commit murder". (There was quite a bit of God sanctioned killing in the Old Testament.) Also, murder is a legal term. It means to take a person's life in a manner that goes against the written law. Abortion is legal, therefore it cannot be murder. Let me ask you a question: would you be okay if a fourteen year old impregnated rape victim wanted to abort the unwanted fetus planted in her?
Exo 20:13 ו "Do not murder. and so ?
 
Top