metis
aged ecumenical anthropologist
I've long been of the opinion that, when it comes to voting, only what the people choose should count. IOW, why should land get a vote? [rhetorical]These two posts demonstrate the problem with defining a fair vote. Nous wants a straight popular vote which will give the presidential selection to the five most populous states. Esmith wants every state to get a single vote, which completely ignores the relative populations in each state.
The Electoral College is the compromise which gives more weight to the large population states whilst still giving the smaller populous states a say in the election.