rosends
Well-Known Member
The Hebrew word is teven, not tevel.
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Where did Exodus 5:7 take place (needs a lot of straw)
- Thread starter River Sea
- Start date
-
- Tags
- egypt exodus indus valley
dybmh
ויהי מבדיל בין מים למים
River Sea
Well-Known Member
Awe, now I understand. Wrong word. Well, only one letter difference.
Hey, we all make mistakes. I made plenty of mistakes myself when it came to words.
Teven
Ok, The Hebrew word there is Teven. Ok so then Teven is either straw or chaff or a mixture.
Last edited:
River Sea
Well-Known Member
Re-sending PDF due to other one doesn't work any more
It could have occurred in the imagination of the writer.
Why are you just assuming the story must have taken place if you are going to declare parts of it mistaken or fabricated when the whole story of the exodus could have been fabricated?
River Sea
Well-Known Member
@danieldemol
danieldemol wrote: It could have occurred in the imagination of the writer.
River Sea response: How cold was the river's ice or its rising water when drowning Pharaoh's army? So, what season is it?
During the ending of Dwapar Yug, the Exodus from the Indus Valley, the Indus River flowed while the land was so dry that Yadavas (Hebrews) crossed the Indus River in time before, further south-west, the Hingol Mud Volcano's eruption of mud eroded upstream, causing the Indus River to rise, drowning Pharaoh and his army and ending their pursuit of the Yadavas Hebrews. What season would describe this?
Last edited:
Bharat Jhunjhunwala
TruthPrevails
There would be a kernel of truth for the imagination to take place. And, why should we assume so when evidence for exodus from india is visible all over. We look at wrong place then call it fabrication. Can you call new York a fabrication if you do not find it in Australia?
IndigoChild5559
Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
It means that the Opening Post is just another example of this trend among Indians to try to make claim for Jesus and other biblical events, with zero justification.
Bharat Jhunjhunwala
TruthPrevails
Plagues caused by drying of hakra river. Yam suf 1 is flow of the Indus obstructed by mud volcano. Yam suf 2 is hamun.e.mashkel. Sinai is the living taftan volcano. Living Paran exists near Isfahan. Kings highway is the silk road. Mt hor is kangavar. Yam suf 3 is shatt al arab. Pl show me these in the egypt route.
River Sea
Well-Known Member
Krishna is Moses, not Jesus. Why do you think Krishna is Jesus?
Jesus is in another era compared to Moses.
River Sea
Well-Known Member
River Sea
Well-Known Member
I re-looked at my art, and wow, that looks loud. Yikes.
I understand many people think Krishna was Jesus. I understand Krishna was Moses.
Well, lesson learned. Next time I do art, I won't make it so huge.
Also, I think the way I wrote it sounds so loud too.
But because Jesus was mention in an Exodus thread, I wonder how some people think Krishna is Jesus compared to Krishna being Moses, or do some people think Krishna is only Krishna?
I do understand that Krishna was from the sun association family tree.
I'm not sure why people were chosen to associate with either the sun or moon to begin these kings and their family trees.
River Sea
Well-Known Member
@Bharat Jhunjhunwala Yep, I really made a mess and confused everyone. However, now I understand where Canaan was. Canaan is not Israel or Yisrael. Canaan in India—this makes more sense now for traveling back and forth as the Yadavas remain in India 'til they leave for Israel, Yisrael which is a different location than Canaan.
I'll add an edit: I understand Yadavas travel from the Indus Valley to Yisrael, or Israel. I finally understood that Canaan was located in Ghuram, India. So that means Canaan is in a different location than Yisrael or Israel.
Another added edit, what a mess: However I was thinking Canaan was the old way of writing Israel, same as KMT was the old way of writing Egypt, however now I know Canaan is in India
I was completely mistaken about Canaan's location. Canaan is located Ghuram in India
Place Ghuram
Semitic Name Ai, Bethel, Canaan
Hindu Name Ayodhya, Kosala
I keep learning, and yes, at times I'm wrong. Yep, I was wrong where Canaan was.
I was considering how others have renamed Canaan Israel Yisrael.
However, there's Canaan located at Ghuram in India
I added the yellow background and red typing to the page to show where Canaan was.
Last edited:
IndigoChild5559
Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
You guys are hysterical
There is a kernel of truth, egypt was real, the Pharaohs were real, that's about it givr or take a small amount.
So you claim. I suggest you submit your claims to archaeologists for peer review.
No, but the place (Egypt) is not in dispute as being fabricated. It is the story of Moses contention with the Pharaoh and subsequent leaving with the nation of Israel that is in dispute as I understand it.
The scientifically peer reviewed archaeological evidence as far as I recall suggests the Israelites were simply a people descended from Cananites that never went as a nation to Egypt.
If you can find archaeological evidence that the ancient nation of Israel migrated as a nation to India then back again then you may have a case that the exodus was really from India, although you would still have to evidence the magical nonsense said to have occurred there and even then the Biblical story would still be at least largely false as I see it.
Bharat Jhunjhunwala
TruthPrevails
This is tricky. Abraham lived in Canaan. Moses led exodus to Canaan. So there have to be two places named Canaan.
IndigoChild5559
Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
You are just missing the part of how Abraham's grandson Jacob and his family left Canaan for Egypt. So, sorry but no two Canaan's.
River Sea
Well-Known Member
@Bharat Jhunjhunwala @IndigoChild5559
How come the people who wrote the Torah didn't choose Vadnagar, Gujarat, India, and change to their new location to be their canaan that they'd later changed their name to Yisrael Israel? Instead, they chose Ghuram India (Canaan) and replaced it with their location, Canaan (Yisrael, Israel).
Place Ghuram
Semitic Name Ai, Bethel, Canaan
Hindu Name Ayodhya, Kosala
Later became Canaan Yisrael Israel location
How did that area of India (Ghuram Canaan) become that other location (Canaan Israel) instead of Vadnagar, Gujarat, India became that other location, I hope my question makes sense?
Or what about any other locations of India could be taken for that new location? Why was Ghuram chosen for and then relocated to this Israel as Canaan - what about other locations in India such as Vadnagar, Gujarat, or Chanhu Daro, couldn't those locations be chosen to relocate in area of Israel, how come people chosen Ghuram for and taken that and replace it to new location as Canaan? What causes this choice?
Bharat Jhunjhunwala
TruthPrevails
Indeed it looks like a fairy tale. Jacob went to mitsrayim in Indus valley from Canaan in Indus valley. Moses went from mitsrayim in Indus valley to israel. Yam suf was Indus river. Sinai was taftan volcano. Second yam suf was hamun e.mashkel. Paran was paran. Mt hor was kangavaar. Kings highway was silk road. Third yam suf was shatt al arab. Only when you match exodus with these it may make sense.
IndigoChild5559
Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
Look, you can make up any fairy story you want. But as to the story of Jacob in Genesis, sorry, but nothing in that about Indus Valley. And no, you aren't making any sense at all.