Once again.....you are not being clear as to what it is was....that I said.....that necessitated your comments.
Here you are combining the [incorrect Calvinistic Predestination theory] with the true---correct doctrine of "Election by Grace." And then you are confusing the correct "Election by Grace" with the doctrine of having one's "Calling and Election Sure." If you are going to speak about true Doctrines.....don't confuse them with incorrect theories. And then don't mix up different Doctrines either.
Calvinism is a THEORY that should not be confused with actual Biblical Doctrines (which you misunderstand).
Anciently the "Elect" were CHOSEN by God because:
1). CHOSEN: They were the natural descendants of Abraham through his Covenent Birthright Sons (Abraham>Isaac>Jacob>Judah & Joseph) being Born of the Abrahamic Covenant.
2). ELECT: Besides being of the right pedigree and having the opportunity to receive the Covenant---the Elect are those who have KEPT their Covenant with God. (In other words, they were OBEDIENT to the covenant that they received).
Presently the Elect are CHOSEN by God because:
1). CHOSEN: After they are taught by Authorized Messengers of God's Covenant---they choise to be baptized (the covenant of adoption) to become the children of Jesus Christ.
2). ELECT: After receiving the Covenant of Adoption---the Elect are those who have KEPT their Covenant that God made with them. (In other words, they are OBEDIENT to the covenant that they received).
In order to make a Covenant with God--
1). ELECTION BY GRACE: It starts out with receiving the opportunity that is given by God---to HEAR HIS MESSAGE. The person is chosen because he lives in a time and place in which the true Gospel message is available and that person has the FREEDOM (agency) to CHOOSE it or reject it. One has been chosen (Election by Grace) to hear the gospel message.
2). ELECT: The Elect accept the message, make the Covenant with God, and KEEP that Covenant.
The correct understanding of Election by Grace---only God decides when and where His pure Gospel is presented. Those who hear that message are required to act with both faith and works (faith + works) to accept the opportunity and contnue to be faithful to the Covenant entered into.
Calvinism is a falsehood----Certain People are not PREDESTINED to go to heaven. Certain People are not PREDESTINED to go to hell either. Faith and Works are required of all people who end up in heaven. The better word to be used is that those people were FOREORDAINED to hear the message (because they lived in a day and place the gospel was available to them). But it is not enough to live in that place or time that it is available.....because one has to CHOOSE to accept it and live it to gain a seat in heaven.
People are not PREDESTINED (to be chosen or elected to go to heaven or hell) but rather EVENTS and CALLINGS in world history are PREDESTINED to happen. Individual people are FOREORDAINED to live in the time and place that they are born (which allowed them the opportunities that were theirs).
The Chosen can be led astray.... It is not enough to live in a time and place you have the opportunity to hear the Gospel....YOU HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT. The Elect (those who choose to do something about it) can also be led asray if they discontinue to KEEP their Covenant.
The only ones who have proved their faithfulness are those who have done all the above and through a period of testing have proven themselves faithful----that they receive their "Calling and Election made Sure." This is what the Apostle Peter was admonishing the early Saints to work towards after they worked on their Divine Nature when he said,
- 2 Peter 1:10
10 Wherefore the rather, brethren, give diligence to make your calling and election sure: for if ye do these things, ye shall never fall:
11 For so an entrance shall be ministered unto you abundantly into the everlasting kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.
12 Wherefore I will not be negligent to put you always in remembrance of these things, though ye know them, and be established in the present truth.