Lukethethird asked: (paraphrased) "What was our sin that Jesus died for?"
On the cross, Jesus asked God "why hath thou foresaken me?" So, it was not Jesus's idea to be tortured to death on a cross, nor was it Jesus's idea to die for our sins.
Presumably, it was God's demand for payment for sins, and God's idea to kill Jesus.
Why would an all-powerful and all-knowing God need a demi-God sacrifice to forgive someone? Couldn't God just say "it is all forgiven?" Unless, we consider the idea that Jesus was a good person to be around (feeding the hungry, healing the sick, telling us how to live well). Then, the death of Jesus would be a punishment for mankind.
Does a loving God punish? Or is God vengeful and wrathful?
Evangelicalhumanist quoted (and agreed with) Hitchens: "created sick and ordered to be well." While the bible is an order to obey God's laws, and those laws presumably would make us well and keep us well, I think that Jesus's death is not an order, but a cure--it appeases God's request for demi-God sacrifice.
Deeje says (paraphrased): "original sin is a debt (of Adam, and others) passed to future generations, and Adam's sin was too great for Adam, alone, to pay."
This begs questions...."Do the deeds of an individual matter?" "Can you go to hell if you just handle your own debts and don't pay off Adam's debts?" "Do you accept Master Card?" Can a good person, devoutly committed to Jesus, Christ, and God (some believe all the same entity), go to heaven without paying off sins?
Now that Jesus died for our sins (God's idea for Jesus to die, of course), are we cleansed of sins or did generations that followed Jesus add more sins?
Wasn't the killing of Jesus a sin? After all, that was the son of God, and surely killing the son of t he most powerful being in the universe would be sinful? Why would God allow anyone to kill his son? Wouldn't God, like any parent, use whatever power he had to stop the horrible torture and killing of his son? Was killing Jesus God's way of teaching Jesus about the horrors of human torture?
Where were the awesome powers of Jesus as he was being totured to death? If Jesus could cure blindness, why couldn't Jesus cause blindness, and blind Pontius Pilate, and blind the Caesar who had ordered the death of Jesus (and ordered the death of all those poor tortured humans who lined every road to Rome)?
Was the death of Jesus purely the decision of humans or did God have a hand in making the decision to murder Jesus? Did God merely stand by and do nothing as Jesus was brutally tortured and murdered? If so, wouldn't that make God an accessory after the fact? In other words, it seems as though God sinned by allowing the death of his son.
A normal parent, with God's power, would be like Jeanie (I Dream of Jeanie) or Samantha (Bewitched), and blink him free, and smite all those who caused Jesus's death. But, notice that God did nothing to stop the Romans from killing (roads to Rome were littered with crucified humans). Furthermore, the Romans (seeing that they had a lot of power to control people) took over control of the Christian faith, and ruled it from the Vatican for thousands of years. The Vatican didn't have many non-Italian (Roman) popes, so Italia had a lock on Christianity. The Romans even put forth the false rumor that Jews wanted to kill Christ.
Deeje also said that God's law is "an eye for an eye, a thooth for a tooth, and a life for a life." While this is Jewish law, Moses also brought the commandment "thou shalt not kill (murder)," and Jesus changed "eye for an eye" to "turn the other cheek." Apparently these two conflicting orders from God were designed for a different people at a different time. In biblical times, Jews needed to kill to stay alive. In modern times, Christians are in charge of nukes, and one false move and the world will be turned to ash (as Vladamir Putin pointedly reminded the United States a few years ago when Hillary and Obama were suggesting nuclear war with Russia).
Deeje also said "perfect life offered willingly." Clearly Jesus was not willing to die, since he asked God "why hath thou foresaken me?"
Perhaps mankind's original sin is temptation, which we must constantly fight?
Eden, once hallowed ground where Adam and Eve dwelt, is still hallowed ground. The recent war in Iraq dropped bombs on Eden (located in Iraq between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers in an area strewn with pottery shards, and now strew with bomb craters and tank tracks). Remember that Revelation said not to attack Iraq or face God's wrath (example: Revelation 15 (seven plagues, including COVID)). Revelation says that God will destroy all life on earth for the attack on Iraq . This is because the attack on Iraq (which happened during our lifetimes) is the greatest sin that ever was.
The killing of 1,000,000 innocent Iraqis, who had nothing to do with terrorism, along with a torture camp in Guantanamo, while God ordered no attack on Iraq, and God ordered "thou shalt not kill" and God ordered not to "bear false witness against thy neighbor," was the greatest sin that ever was, and that will destroy all of mankind and all of life. The war in Iraq put us in the end times. According to Revelation, the ones who made the two wars in Iraq are father and son demons (dragon and beast). The administration that was (Bush Sr.) that is no more (Clinton), is again (Bush Jr.), as the bible put it. In other words, the bible predicted that there would be a gap between the two Bush administrations.
Deeje said: "we are not being punished....we are the vitims caught up in a tussle between the forces of good and evil." Why can't God kill Satan and smite evil? Ratiocinator is right....God shouldn't allow innocent humans to be caught up in such a tussle.
Deeje said: "If you want what God is offering then it requires very little effort on our part to obey the one who requires compliance with his clearly stated laws." What about the clearly stated law that God commanded in divinely inspired Revelation--attack Iraq and incur God's wrath. Why did many Christians stand by and watch that war happen? France objected. Russia objected. Italy objected. Iraq certainly objected. The pope objected and wrote a strongly worded See to the United States urging that we not fight the war in Iraq (knowing that was part of the end times, and knowing that the war in Iraq would identify both Bush presidents as demons from the foul bottomless pit of hell, as stated in Revelation about the people who attacked Iraq). Revelation even identified the attacker of Iraq as the most powerful nation in the world (Revelation 17:18, which calls the United States the Whore of Babylon).
Subduction Zone said: "Christianity was created sas a solution to a problem that was created by Judaism." No, the problem wasn't created by the Jewish religion, it was created by Adam. Adam existed before the Jewish religion. (Lets not blame Jews for everything). As Deeje pointed out, "There was no Judaism in Eden. There was no Judaism until Judah (fourth son of Jacob...the man after whom it is called) came into existence."
Deeje wrote: "Ignorance is not a terminal condition unless you seek no treatment for it." We can't find the meeting place for the treatment (because we're idiots). They said that we have to get sharp (but it hurts when we put our heads in the pencil sharpener).
Brian2 said "God told us that He can give us eternal life." Jesus said that we would have eternal life if we believe in Him (Jesus). Some dispute that God, Christ, and Jesus are all one. Some say that Jesus is called Lord, but he is the son of God, and that God is a jealous God who claims that He (God) is the only God and that there will be no other. The eternal life is not necessarily eternal life in heaven. It might be eternal life wandering the earth as a ghost (spirit), or eternal life burning in the lake of fire of hell. Remember that Jesus was nailed to a cross when he was "blessing" or "cursing" mankind with eternal life. Doesn't it seem like a curse, when a person begging for their life (asking God "why hath thou foresaken me)" bleeding from nail holes, decides to make souls live forever? That is what the average torture man would do (curse all of them to hell for all eternity).
Brian2 said: "death is the solution for all our sins." I thought that the death of Jesus was the solution for all our sins, and death is merely a jumping off point where we either go up or we go down (or perhaps stay where we are as a ghost). I think a lot of people would rather stay alive and continue sinning.
Brian2 said: "Bible says no one will be punished for the deeds of their ancestors according to Jeremiah 31:30." But Jeremiah 31:30 says that "every one shall die for his own iniquity (iniquity is immoral or grossly unfair behavior...Merriam-Webster quote from Oxford Languages). What if someone doesn't have immoral or unfair behavior? Jeremiah 31:30 is about dying, not about punishment.
Ratiocinator said "people who ask Jesus to fix their nature don't stop sinning." Jesus showed us how to behave (and if we follow the teachings of Jesus, we won't sin). The problem is, we know better but still sin. We ignore the homeless, ruin God's environment (Global Warming), lie about the environment, W. Bush redefined the word homeless so that the homeless don't exist....another way of lying, we pander to the rich (tax laws favor the rich getting richer while they have toilets made of God while others starve), we stand by idly as W. Bush sinned and defied God by attacking Iraq and bore false witness against them (like calling an Iraq the doctor of death), we watch as our Christian leaders ignore suffering (like Hurricane Katrina) and through apathy to kill, we stress our nation by outsourcing jobs for mammon while child slaves abroad manufacture our goods, etc.
Thomas T said "there's a difference between a mess and Christian trying to clean it up and just a mess." Christians are doing a lousy job of cleaning up (see paragraph above). The Exxon Valdez lesson was "don't drink and drive an oil tanker" (hmm....how did North America get there?) Texaco struck oil in South America, and the natives (living in grass huts) were feeling like uncle Jed....rags to riches. Until it was revealed that Texaco had paid a minor stipend to their chief for the oil rights and they got nothing. The chief had the best grass hut in the village, but the spills caused the game to die and go away, and caused their babies birth defects and cancer. Ordered to pay $500 person compensation (I know of no one who would enduring watching their baby die of cancer for $500 (mammon)).