Your position about Islam

[Tabb]

True Christians do not consider all religions equal.That would defeat the purpose of spreading Christianity as the one true religion.True Christians although do respect all religions.All people.This is what Christ taught.To do onto others as you would have them do onto you.The Golden Rule.

Islam was invented 600 years after Jesus Christ walked the Earth.There is much plagiarism going on in the Quran.Many stories in the Quran have been taken from the Talmud.

I'm sorry but how can someone plagiarise something that you claim is a reality. I mean it's ok for a non believer to make that accusation but if you really believe that whats in the bible happened than Islam is only recounting history. You can't plagiarise the truth, right? Are you saying the Talmud is fiction?

 

[Kilgore Trout]

My position on Islam is similar to my position on many other religions: It would be fine if nobody actually practiced it.

 

[YmirGF]

My position on Islam is similar to my position on many other religions: It would be fine if nobody actually practiced it.

Hehe. You'd think that by now some would have perfected it.

 

[Kilgore Trout]

Hehe. You'd think that by now some would have perfected it.

It's hard to perfect inconsistency to such an exacting degree.

 

[Nada]

I'm sorry but how can someone plagiarise something that you claim is a reality. I mean it's ok for a non believer to make that accusation but if you really believe that whats in the bible happened than Islam is only recounting history. You can't plagiarise the truth, right? Are you saying the Talmud is fiction?

You are incorrect.It is not recounting history.Islam has taken Jewish stories from the Talmud,changed names,sequence of events, and passed it off as its own.

Plagiarism: the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.

 

[FunctionalAtheist]

You are incorrect.It is not recounting history.Islam has taken Jewish stories from the Talmud,changed names,sequence of events, and passed it off as its own.

Plagiarism: the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.

Sooo, what's the difference between the plagerism of the quaran and the bible?

 

[Jayhawker Soule]

1- What is your position about Islam?

2- Do you have any questions that you would like having answers to?

3- Why do you think Islam is wrong?

1. I do not believe is angels.
2. What is your view of abrogation?
3. I don't understand the question.

 

[Nada]

QUOTE=FunctionalAthiest;3958911]Sooo, what's the difference between the plagerism of the quaran and the bible?[/QUOTE]
Your outta here........... Added to my list.:sad4:

 

[outhouse]

You can't plagiarise the truth, right?

Your factually wrong.


Stealing ideas, is stealing ideas right or wrong

Are you saying the Talmud is fiction?

In places it is.




Who doubts the factual plagiarization muhammad did ???

Only the faithful?


Its the same as asking YEC for an honest answer about evolution .

 

[outhouse]

Sooo, what's the difference between the plagerism of the quaran and the bible?

The spelling is correct there. "plagiarism"


They are all plagiarized material. Why should we give exceptions to muslims for their plagiarism ?


Israelites plagiarism includes Mesopotamian and Canaanite sources

Christians plagiarism includes Judaism

Islams plagiarism includes it all because it came later in the game

 

[FunctionalAtheist]

QUOTE=FunctionalAthiest;3958911]Sooo, what's the difference between the plagerism of the quaran and the bible?

Your outta here........... Added to my list.:sad4:[/quote]
What list is that? Qustions for which there is no response which is both supportive of your views and rational?

 

[outhouse]

What list is that? Qustions for which there is no response which is both supportive of your views and rational?

Closed minded people often want to only deal with the same mentality

 

[Kilgore Trout]

Your outta here........... Added to my list.:sad4:

What list is that? Qustions for which there is no response which is both supportive of your views and rational?[/quote]

Some people like to systematically ignore all views and opinions which don't coincide with theirs. It's like only wanting to watch Fox News, but first you have to go through and manually deactivate all the other channels.

 

[Tabb]

You are incorrect.It is not recounting history.Islam has taken Jewish stories from the Talmud,changed names,sequence of events, and passed it off as its own.

Plagiarism: the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.

That's simply not true. The Qur'an starts off by acknowledging that they believe in the same God that is in Judaism. They don't take stories out of the Talmud and make them their own. They use the same information that Christians use. Also how can Christians make such an accusation when the Old Testament is virtually the Torah word for word.

 

[outhouse]

They don't take stories out of the Talmud and make them their own. .

:biglaugh:


What do you call rewriting different stories of Abraham, Moses, Noah, Adam and Eve ?????????????????

 

[outhouse]

They use the same information that Christians use.

.

:biglaugh:

And Christians plagiarism of the OT is noted


In your case the word "USE" is you admitting plagiarism

 

[Nada]

That's simply not true. The Qur'an starts off by acknowledging that they believe in the same God that is in Judaism. They don't take stories out of the Talmud and make them their own. They use the same information that Christians use. Also how can Christians make such an accusation when the Old Testament is virtually the Torah word for word.

Thats incorrect.The Jews believe in Yahweh,Yehowah,Jehovah.Islam believes God's name is Allah.Allah is not a name,it is a title.It simply means God.God has a name.It is Yahweh,Yehowah,Jehovah.Yes Islam does acknowledge the God of Moses in the Quran,but they change much around.Islam has taken stories from the Talmud and made it their own.

Watch this entire video and you will know the truth.

[youtube]hYsreMPiI8Y[/youtube]

 

[Nada]

:shout Speak to you later Tabb.I must get ready for my personal bible study.

 

[Tabb]

Your factually wrong.


Stealing ideas, is stealing ideas right or wrong

Ah but here's the Rub. At the time of Muhammad's alleged Plagiarism, was it his belief that the information he wrote was factual. If he did believe what everyone in the civilized world did at that time that it was the truth or common Knowledge, than its not plagiarism.

I don't mean to go all legal on you but you usually associate plagiarism with a willful act of stealing someone's intellectual property. Basically what he did was take from what was considered the known history of the World. Did he use information from the Talmud, of course he did as did the creators of the Bible.

Besides Muhammad would tell you Gabriel told him all this anyway.

 

[Tabb]

Thats incorrect.The Jews believe in Yahweh,Yehowah,Jehovah.Islam believes God's name is Allah.Allah is not a name,it is a title.It simply means God.God has a name.It is Yahweh,Yehowah,Jehovah.Yes Islam does acknowledge the God of Moses in the Quran,but they change much around.Islam has taken stories from the Talmud and made it their own.

Watch this entire video and you will know the truth.

[youtube]hYsreMPiI8Y[/youtube]

Wrong. It clearly states the God of Abraham in the Qur'an. I don't know if you know but Muhammad's claim is that he got his information from the Angel Gabriel.