Wow. I didn't know we were there yet. It's just that when you critisise her i would like to know very specifically your problem with exactly what, exactly what was done, exactly what you suppose should have been done...etc. i was asking a whole new question.
Oh no. I share their arguments largely. They will soon stop discussing with you when they realize that you are not trying to be right. And that is for the best. Life is too shiort to be shared with a parrot.