Does that really happen though? Maybe I'm being naive but I don't think all that many people would claim to be a particular gender just for some legal advantages.
Hi all
What would you say are the beliefs (if any) one has to have to be justified to call oneself a Hindu? For instance it's generally accepted that to be a Christian, you have to at least acknowledge Jesus as your saviour. Do you think there are Hindu equivalents?
My understanding of Hijras is they are a mix of transgender, non-gender conformists, transvestites and gay and bisexual men who were lumped into one category by those that rejected them, rather than they themselves uniting due to common feeling. And certain superstitions developed about them...
Sorry for being silly - I just get so confused about all this!
If Vishnu is Brahman, why is Vishnu necessary, why can't Vaishanavas just say they worship Brahman directly? And why worship "everything" anyway as opposed to a positive aspect of everything? For instance, would it not make more...
Thanks Terese.
As regards Vishnu being Brahman with attributes, would not these attributes also be part of Brahman if Brahman is everything? How can Vishnu possess something Brahman does not?
By these views then, Krishna and Rama had no physical bodies?
So would you say that Vishnu has no personality as such as he is Brahman and Brahman is everything? Or is there a difference in personhood between Vishnu and Brahman? For instance, Christian philosophy says God is one substance...
I must admit I struggle a bit with this concept in Hinduism. As far as I can gather one could hold any of the beliefs below and still be regarded a Vaishnava:
1. Vishnu and Brahman are interchangeable names for everything
2. Vishnu is the greatest manifestation of Brahman
3. Vishnu is a...
Thanks guys - I can see this is quite a complex issue!
So essentially you would argue that passage should be translated as "Know him to be the supreme source of all religions, ruler of the world of light, where there is neither day nor night, neither what is nor what is not, but only the...
Thanks Aup.
Axlyz, I suppose I'm thinking of 4.18-19 of the Easwaran translation which says:
"Know him to be the supreme source of all religions, ruler of the world of light, where there is neither day nor night, neither what is nor what is not, but only Shiva. He is far beyond the reach of the...
Hi all
I was just reading through axlyz's topic on the greatness of Lord Vishnu and he stated that all the upanishads praise Vishnu as the supreme. But doesn't the Shvetashvatara Upanishad indicate Shiva is the supreme? Or is there a different way it can be interpreted?
Wow, thanks for all the respones everyone.
Fascinating. I think like a lot of westerners, my view of Kali has been way too coloured by watching Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom as a kid. I'll have to look into her maternal side more.
Yeah, I'm beginning to realise that you can pick and...
Yeah that's the impression I'm getting. I definitely find this appealing but given my Roman Catholic upbringing it's very differeent to what I'm used to!
Yes, it does seem so rich and varied to me. Regarding ISKCON, is Krishna the only one of the avatars of Vishnu that ISKCON accepts or do they...
Hi all. I'm fairly new to Hinduism, but more and more I'm feeling I could have found the religion for me. However there ae some things I find plain confusing and would appreciate some guidance about. To start off I want to apologise if I misrepresent any group's views - like I say I'm a bit...