Why?
In answer to why I'm not 100% convinced I exist:
1. I'm not sure what it means to exist
2. I'm not sure 'I' am a single entity
3. Maybe I am a figment in the dream of another
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Why?
How can you be so certain?
A person can be absolutely certain of beliefs but that does not guarantee they are right about them.
I am certain I exist and I am certain that one day I shall die. All else is varying shades of grey.This is a discussion about Absolute Certainty.
First I will give what I see are Absolute Certainty.
100% Certain of God - Unknowable.
100% God sends Messengers.
100% Certain those Messengers are all we can know of God.
100% Certain that if you believe in one of those Messengers, one has found a source of Truth.
100% Certain that we are in true form, we are Spirit.
100% Certain that creation is a Relative Certainty.
100% Certain that all people have this knowledge within.
100% Certain, that we will mess up that Certainty.
Well that is a good start.
What about you, what are your Absolute Certainties?
Do your Certainties find any agreement in Mine?
Do you think we can have Absolute Certainty?
Regards Tony
This is a discussion about Absolute Certainty.
First I will give what I see are Absolute Certainty.
100% Certain of God - Unknowable.
100% God sends Messengers.
100% Certain those Messengers are all we can know of God.
100% Certain that if you believe in one of those Messengers, one has found a source of Truth.
100% Certain that we are in true form, we are Spirit.
100% Certain that creation is a Relative Certainty.
100% Certain that all people have this knowledge within.
100% Certain, that we will mess up that Certainty.
Well that is a good start.
What about you, what are your Absolute Certainties?
Do your Certainties find any agreement in Mine?
Do you think we can have Absolute Certainty?
Regards Tony
I am 100% certain, that the only 100% certatude? Is in Mathematics.
Math is the sole Human Endeavor, where Proof is both meaningful and accurate to 100%.
Not ironically? Math is also only and ever exists within our collective heads-- oh, sure, you can write it out, but without a Key to the Symbols? What is written out is essentially meaningless.
So. Proof and 100% is only and ever for Maths. Yaaay Maths!
Everything else? Is subject to at least a small level of uncertainty. As the famous philosopher quipped? Cogito Ergo Sum. I think, therefore I am.
Of course... the skeptic has to ask: how certain are you that you are actually thinking? And not just a computer sim, being run on a Galactic Sized Quantum Computer? And are simply following your programming, which is only a simulation of thinking?
In truth, even Descartes could not be 100% sure-- he could be fairly sure, though.
As the Russian Space Program Engineers often observed?
Good Enough For Service. (and hopefully won't kill too many cosmonauts....)
Descartes quote is Good Enough For Service.
Everything else, is relative to the individual.
Which is, not ironically, why Einstein's Theory Of Relativity was such a double entendre...
Am I 100% sure of any of this? Well.... relatively speaking? No.
I am not so sure that most people live harmony and unity. I think some people like to argue in order to prove they are right. That is ego. I used to be that way when I first came to forums and along time after that but eventually I changed and now I do not want to argue anymore because I have no need to prove I am right and others are wrong.Most people love harmony and unity. But people who don't agree and indicate that agreement is impossible disturb harmony and unity. In olden times those people were killed or exiled.
There is a difference between believing and declaring. Believing is personal but declaring is saying I am right and you are wrong.Semantics, semantics, semantics. It's all pretty much all the same..
No, I am not ashamed of anything I think or believe. I just exposed my opinions about sex and homosexuality on another forum and I will probably get guff back, but I have strong beliefs and opinions and I did not insult anyone, so I don't care what they think. I just gave them something to think about, they can take it or leave it. That is what these forums are all about. We can be polite and still express opinions.Why? Is there something that you would not like to admit in public? Open up, we are all friends here.
I said that things do not seem right, but I do not consider that selfish. Allah cannot be selfish because Allah is not a human. No, to be honest, I do not worship Allah, I just try to follow His teachings and laws to the best of my ability. I fully understand how you feel about Allah. I have understood atheists for years since I have posted to so many atheists for about six years and I listen and try to understand..
You are but a bundle of contradiction. Allah allows suffering, has wrath, wants you to love him before he can give his love to you. You accept that it is absolutely selfish. Things do not seem right. But you still worship this Allah who does all these things. For this reason alone I do not believe that there can be this kind of Allah.
I know I exist because I have a body and a soul. That is what it means to exist from my perspective.In answer to why I'm not 100% convinced I exist:
1. I'm not sure what it means to exist
No, because what we are certain of could be wrong.I see. I t is possible to have absolute certainty and be wrong? Doesn't that contradict the concept of certainty?
Some have dreams vividly but they probably don't know they're sleeping. I am happy I don't remember my dreams. I have hope but that hope is based on the Bible and that hope is in my mind and heart when I am awake.I see dreams as another world, where it plays out between what is reality and what life has done to influence our state of mind.
Dreams can be quite bizarre!
Regards Tony
Are you saying that it is possible, despite your beliefs, that you are wrong?No, because what we are certain of could be wrong.
I am certain I am right about my beliefs. I am certain that Baha'u'llah was who He claimed to be, a Messenger of God, and everything else follows from that belief.
I am certain that Christians are right about many things but dead wrong about other things, yet they are certain they are right about all their beliefs.
Certainty has nothing to do with evidence, although evidence can lead to certainty. For me, that is what happened. Had you asked me about seven years ago if I was certain of my beliefs, I would have said I was 80 or 90% certain, but now I am 100% certain. The reason I am 100% certain now is because of seven years on forums posting to people, answering questions and being challenged, which forced me to look further into the evidence for my beliefs... So all those atheists and Christians trying to refute me did me a big favor.
Some have dreams vividly but they probably don't know they're sleeping. I am happy I don't remember my dreams. I have hope but that hope is based on the Bible and that hope is in my mind and heart when I am awake.
Not sure what you mean there. Some people are absolutely certain that there is a burning hell that is awaiting to have people (souls?) thrown into it and thereby torturing them forever. They are certain about this. I am certain they are mistaken.All my Absolute Certainty also finds Foundation in the Bible.
Regards Tony
Of course that is possible, hypothetically speaking, because beliefs do not create reality.Are you saying that it is possible, despite your beliefs, that you are wrong?
I am not sure what Tony meant, but as Baha'is, we believe that the Bible was God's greatest testimony to His creatures because Baha'u'llah wrote that in our second most holy book.Not sure what you mean there.
I don't think there is absolute certainty of anything. I could be insane. The world could be an illusion of my mind. Science seems to indicate that our perception of the world is quite imperfect. Etc.This is a discussion about Absolute Certainty.
First I will give what I see are Absolute Certainty.
100% Certain of God - Unknowable.
100% God sends Messengers.
100% Certain those Messengers are all we can know of God.
100% Certain that if you believe in one of those Messengers, one has found a source of Truth.
100% Certain that we are in true form, we are Spirit.
100% Certain that creation is a Relative Certainty.
100% Certain that all people have this knowledge within.
100% Certain, that we will mess up that Certainty.
Well that is a good start.
What about you, what are your Absolute Certainties?
Do your Certainties find any agreement in Mine?
Do you think we can have Absolute Certainty?
Regards Tony
I don't think there is absolute certainty of anything. I could be insane. The world could be an illusion of my mind. Science seems to indicate that our perception of the world is quite imperfect. Etc.
No offense to your beliefs, you have every right to them. However, IMHO I think that if you think about these things deeply enough, you will spot other explanations for why things seem the way they do.
For example, I firmly believe in God. Yet at the same time, I acknowledge that God may simply be an expression of an evolutionary trait to find meaning and purpose, and to see a designer when none is there, much like we are evolved to see faces when none is there (think happy faces, faces in clouds, etc.). IOW, I may believe in God because I need to believe in God. But need does not always translate to reality. And so I remain what I have been told is an "agnostic Theist."
I also think about it about that amount of the time, and then I realize why I am thinking it.But there is always that 0.1% of the time when I am deep in thought, and think about it.