• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

An Opinion: Islam Is Not a Religion of Peace

allfoak

Alchemist
The verses I posted about Hell are in context. They mean what the text states. How can you interpret away the belief in Hell when it is so conspicuous in the verses' wording? I have no idea, but I think that would probably require a huge amount of mental gymnastics. At least that would be better than believing in eternal torture for large groups of people, though.

I'm not interpreting away anything.
My post says nothing about the verses other than that they are taken out of context.
Meaning, they are being interpreted literally.
The proper context is to apply them to your own experience.
If you try and interpret any scripture in a literal context you are going to end up with contradictions and horrible ideas like eternal damnation.

If i gave you a novel and told you to read it like it was a poem you would think i was crazy.
I think most religious people are crazy.
They read something that was written in the language of their soul as if it is a history book, twisting it's meaning to fit their own carnal desires believing that somehow they are escaping hell.

This idea of eternal torture for anyone is atrocious.
I would be an atheist before i would accept something so horrible.
The concept was created for the purpose of control.
It has worked so well that people pay to keep from ending up there.
People will do almost anything in fact if you can get them to believe that they will avoid hell by performing some ritual, act of allegiance or initiation.

I would be careful what it is i judge.
If you do not understand what you are reading and judge it to be something it is not, you are in danger of actions that will likely not be in your best interest.
 

outhouse

Atheistically
Fundamentalist Christians think every single word of the Bible should be viewed literally too...thus Creationism, etc. Think it's all about interpretation. I don't believe the Bible should be taken 100% literally, in all passages, does this make me 'less' of a Christian?

Your correct. It is factually a mistake to read the bible literally.

The difference between the two is all muslims are required to hold the same fanaticism as YEC Christian fundamentalist.


Even the really cool nice one's reject academia as far as historical knowledge goes, and there is no debate or sharing of possibilities if it goes against the book. It in my opinion is an "all in" or nothing religion.
 

Iti oj

Global warming is real and we need to act
Premium Member
Those who follow are called the believers.
you could factually prove so and so god and religion to me tomorrow that does not mean i would accept so and so god into my life or follow said religion. you postulate free will, then rebellion is always a choice. i wont side with what i find evil.

i am an atheist but is satan/shiatan? according to faith he knows but still does not serve.
 

MARCELLO

Transitioning from male to female
No, a simple no,again NO!

Lets avoid ideas of old muslims' hatred to their traditional religion,this cannot be world's problem can it?

I am of roman catholic origin (very) snow white European white ,though atheist ,lived in places such as pakistan,saudi arabia .They did nothing but helped me for everything.Why should I believe you? Do you think i live in a fantasy?

Maniacs are maniacs everywhere,nothing to do with the religion.
 

Iti oj

Global warming is real and we need to act
Premium Member
No, a simple no,again NO!

Lets avoid ideas of old muslims' hatred to their traditional religion,this cannot be world's problem can it?

I am of roman catholic origin (very) snow white European white ,though atheist ,lived in places such as pakistan,saudi arabia .They did nothing but helped me for everything.Why should I believe you? Do you think i live in a fantasy?

Maniacs are maniacs everywhere,nothing to do with the religion.
this thread isnt about muslims but about islam
 

MARCELLO

Transitioning from male to female
this thread isnt about muslims but about islam
Sorry,I could not figure out the difference between islam and muslims.

You are the reason why I have to go to a simple supermarket with a fully armed soldier. Because they say the same.
 

Iti oj

Global warming is real and we need to act
Premium Member
Sorry,I could not figure out the difference between islam and muslims.

You are the reason why I have to go to a simple supermarket with a fully armed soldier. Because they say the same.
that was a pretty rude comment considering you know nothing about me or my stances on these issues
 

Iti oj

Global warming is real and we need to act
Premium Member
now i don't blame Islam for terrorism, with or without Islam terrorism would have risen in that area for socioeconomic reasons. im more likely to be shot by a white 'mentally ill' guy then a Muslim.

in rea life i tend to defend islam, mostly because the arguments attacking it are strawmen bull**** made from ignorance.

almost all the Muslims i personally know are good people.

that doesn't mean Islam is a good religion on peace, none of the abhramics are. (actualy i don't know enough about judiasm to claim that )
 

MARCELLO

Transitioning from male to female
that was a pretty rude comment considering you know nothing about me or my stances on these issues
I do apologize.

But what do you know about me? Have you spent your life in islamic orient like me?In such a rough sector like construction? Do you know how many times ı was told not to leave home even for buying coke zero or they will cut me off my neck?

Pls try to understand me. Again I am so sorry if I were rude.
 

Debater Slayer

Vipassana
Staff member
Premium Member
For the sake of argument, assume that you were 100% sure that there is a punishment for the disbelievers, will you then believe ?

I would believe that there was punishment, but I would probably still don't know who was behind said punishment... that is, I would question if it was really a god that was behind the punishment and not any other entity or entities.
 

Iti oj

Global warming is real and we need to act
Premium Member
I do apologize.

But what do you know about me? Have you spent your life in islamic orient like me?In such a rough sector like construction? Do you know how many times ı was told not to leave home even for buying coke zero or they will cut me off my neck?

Pls try to understand me. Again I am so sorry if I were rude.
no, i don't know you but i haven't made any presumptuous statements about you. that being said thank you, i accept your apology and look forward to learning from your experiences.
 

Kirran

Premium Member
lol even Hindu Kirran , please don't say Hindu is special "religion" , had not contradiction and hindus don't pick and choose ?

Muslims are not pick and choose , we had something called "Tafsir" and historic references which explain Quran and Hadith .

I don't say Hinduism is in some way a special religion. Hindus pick and choose scriptures, even :D
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
I would believe that there was punishment, but I would probably still don't know who was behind said punishment... that is, I would question if it was really a god that was behind the punishment and not any other entity or entities.

My question was, will you believe if in a case that you were 100% sure that the disbelievers will be punished or you'll
rebel because you don't agree that the disbeliever should be punished and hence you'll accept to be punished as means
of protesting and to show your disagreement with God.
 

Debater Slayer

Vipassana
Staff member
Premium Member
My question was, will you believe if in a case that you were 100% sure that the disbelievers will be punished or you'll
rebel because you don't agree that the disbeliever should be punished and hence you'll accept to be punished as means
of protesting and to show your disagreement with God.

As I said earlier, I don't know. I would have to be in the situation to know exactly what I would do or say.
 

Debater Slayer

Vipassana
Staff member
Premium Member
You'll stay perplexed in which way to go ?

I think I would probably settle for one option if I were put in that situation. I would tell the god we're talking about what I thought, since he would be able to know anyway through his omniscience.
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
I think I would probably settle for one option if I were put in that situation. I would tell the god we're talking about what I thought, since he would be able to know anyway through his omniscience.

Let me put it in another way, if you were standing on a land which you know it'll be destroyed, you have 2 ways to escape,
one advised you to take the one way and not the other and he gave you some signs which you're going to see as a proof for what he said,
then while you were in the road you found these signs which he told you that you gonna to see, which way you'll choose, the one which he
asked you to follow or the other road, will you believe or disbelieve.
 
Top