Aslamekum

[chinu]

If i say that am a muslim, do you agree ? if agree than its ok, if not, than why ?

 

[Iti oj]

Well how do you feel about Mohamed pbuh and the Quran? But I can see you as a muslim perhaps a suffi?

 

[Assad91]

No, if you say "As Salamu Alaykum", you are not a muslim. It is fine for non muslims to say such an we are allowed to respond properly.

To be muslim, you need to say shadah, as shadu an la ilaha ill Allah wa asshadu ana Muhammadan asoolulah

 

[Iti oj]

No, if you say "As Salamu Alaykum", you are not a muslim. It is fine for non muslims to say such an we are allowed to respond properly.

To be muslim, you need to say shadah, as shadu an la ilaha ill Allah wa asshadu ana Muhammadan asoolulah

I do not think that was his question. I think he asked what if I say I am a muslim? Am I? What would you say if I said I was a musilm/

 

[Assad91]

I do not think that was his question. I think he asked what if I say I am a muslim? Am I? What would you say if I said I was a musilm/

If that is the case then sure. Unless he commits kufar

 

[chinu]

Well how do you feel about Mohamed pbuh and the Quran? But I can see you as a muslim perhaps a suffi?

Mohamed phuh was god in man, and the holy quran is written by him.

Now, what do you say, am i muslim ? do you agree ?

 

[chinu]

No, if you say "As Salamu Alaykum", you are not a muslim. It is fine for non muslims to say such an we are allowed to respond properly.

To be muslim, you need to say shadah, as shadu an la ilaha ill Allah wa asshadu ana Muhammadan asoolulah

Ok, if i learned to respond properly, than am a muslim ? are you agree then ?

And, what do you say about any new born child in a muslim family who has still not learned to respond properly, is such child a muslim ?

 

[chinu]

If that is the case then sure. Unless he commits kufar

Here's a question for you, Assad.

If one doesn't know to how to pronounce ''Thankyou", but, heartly want to say thankyou, is it a kufar ?

 

[Sumit]

Mohamed phuh was god in man, and the holy quran is written by him.

Now, what do you say, am i muslim ? do you agree ?

Now I am sure that you are not a muslim. Because muslims believe that Mohammad was prophet of Allah and Quran was not written by Mohammad but was revealed on Mohammad by Allah through Gabriel.

 

[chinu]

Now I am sure that you are not a muslim. Because muslims believe that Mohammad was prophet of Allah and Quran was not written by Mohammad but was revealed on Mohammad by Allah through Gabriel.

Are you a muslim, Sumit ?

 

[Sumit]

Are you a muslim, Sumit ?

No

 

[chinu]

No

Than how can say, what muslims believes truely ?

 

[Muffled]

No, if you say "As Salamu Alaykum", you are not a muslim. It is fine for non muslims to say such an we are allowed to respond properly.

To be muslim, you need to say shadah, as shadu an la ilaha ill Allah wa asshadu ana Muhammadan asoolulah

I can say that but without a translation I am just repeating words. I think it means something like God is one God, Allah and Mohammed His prophet. I would agree with that.

 

[Sumit]

Than how can say, what muslims believes truely ?

Muslims told me that and you can also read Quran to understand how to be muslim.

 

[Muffled]

If that is the case then sure. Unless he commits kufar

I am not familiar with this word but if it means telling a falsehood, that isn't my practice.

 

[chinu]

Muslims told me that and you can also read Quran to understand how to be muslim.

If your understanding about islam and muslim's understanding about islam is same, than what's the difference between you and muslims ?

 

[Sumit]

If your understanding about islam and muslim's understanding about islam is same, than what's the difference between you and muslims ?

This is not my understanding of Islam, these are the beliefs of Muslim Scholars. Why don't you hear them on you tube.

 

[chinu]

This is not my understanding of Islam, these are the beliefs of Muslim Scholars. Why don't you hear them on you tube.

Ok, i'll hear them on you tube.

 

[GURSIKH]

Quran was not written by Mohammad but was revealed on Mohammad by Allah through Gabriel.

i have a question for my Muslim frnds ,it may sound silly ,so sorry in advance

why not Allah revealed directly to Mohammad sahib instead thru a Jinn/angel Gabriel ? is Allah Shy ?

 

[Sumit]

i have a question for my Muslim frnds ,it may sound silly ,so sorry in advance

I also have a lot of questions about Islam and Quran.

why not Allah revealed directly to Mohammad sahib instead thru a Jinn/angel Gabriel ? is Allah Shy ?

Swami Vivekananda explained this in his book. However I can't explain it as this will create a debate here and the thread is about a different topic.