The Kilted Heathen
Crow FreyjasmaðR
According to Heathen belief, Manson - as a murderer - has been devoured by the dragon Níðhöggr in the Hall of Náströnd. His name will live on, for a time, in infamy and dishonor.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Even though there is no such thing as hell, if there were, do you think Charles is there?
And do you think he SHOULD go there?
What if you gave me a more reasonable hypothetical? I don't see how that could happen with anyone if I were to grant the hypothetical scenario of infinite time in an afterlife.
Crazy? If it's a disorder we're talking about, I don't think punishment is the right approach. That's just cruel and likely ineffective anyway.It does not have to be infinite time in the afterlife it could merely be infinite punishment that happens again and again and again till the person knows they are wrong. I think that it is reasonable because there are people who do not care about punishments, they will do it repeatedly, they are just crazy.
Crazy? If it's a disorder we're talking about, I don't think punishment is the right approach. That's just cruel and likely ineffective anyway.
Well "crazy" isn't a very useful term. Could you be a little more clear about what you meant?Who is to say it is a disorder?
Why did you support your argument with a premise you do not know the truth of?Even though there is no such thing as hell, if there were, do you think Charles is there?
And do you think he SHOULD go there?
This statement comes from complete ignorance.What about that Jesus guy? He is responsible for way more deaths than Hitler.
Absolutely not.So then, nobody deserves infinite punishment?
It’s don’t think it necessary for me to prove the nonexistence of something.Can you prove there isn't one?
Why did you support your argument with a premise you do not know the truth of?
1. Not only do you not know whether a Hell exists or not, you couldn't possibly know there was no Hell..
2. Even if it true that there is no such place as Hell exists, you still couldn't possibly know it.
3. You can't prove a universal negative. You have never been to every spot in this universe and checked to see that every square inch of it is missing a Hell. Even if you physically went to every part of the universe and never detected no Hells on your imaginary Hell detector you still couldn't claim that a spiritual Hell does not exist even if a physical one.
Not being able to prove a universal negative is such a universally accepted fact, you only undermine your own credibility by declaring the exact opposite. I would suggest you do a little bit of research into philosophy and metaphysics.
It’s don’t think it necessary for me to prove the nonexistence of something.
But your question was quite valid.
I should have phrased the question “even though I don’t think hell exists, etc”
My apologies.
Absolutely not.
No, it's the reasonable default setting.But isn't it conjecture on your part to assume something you've never experienced does not exist?
No, it's the reasonable default setting.
What seems more reasonable: believing everything till disproven, or believing things as evidence of existence appears? Everything is an awful lot of stuff to believe in.
His life was already hell. It's a given he wasn't a happy guy.Even though there is no such thing as hell, if there were, do you think Charles is there?
And do you think he SHOULD go there?
God alone is judge of that. We simply cannot know, neither the state of his soul nor what happened between him and God.And do you think he SHOULD go there?
What bible would that be? The Christian bible refers to Hell dozens of times.Actually I do know some truth, but the ONLY truth I know is that which I read in my bible. My bible version has no hell in it. None. Nothing. Zip.
Hold the phone you switched arguments here.I avoid purposefully mistranslated versions, and watch out for errors, and take the entire bible as a whole to conclude what God’s message is on a subject. Also, I never ever believe anything said by any person unless I can verify it. So, for me, the truth is no hell. I trust the Word of God only, not what a bunch of dead men invented centuries ago to scare people into following them.
So in the end what you consider to be true is equal to what you prefer. Your basically remaking God in your own image.I don’t need to research philosophy and metaphysics in order to ask a simple question.
If you were so offended by my simple question, I can only assume you need a hell for some reason. Maybe it’s a requirement of your religion. Feel free to keep the belief alive, just ignore my crazy ranting in the future.
Peace and God bless.
2. I did not claim or suggest I need a Hell to exist, I didn't even say I believe there is one."Even though there is no such thing as hell"
Cite one.The Christian bible refers to Hell dozens of times.