I looked there and didn't see to what you referred. I don't know why you didn't quote yourself in your reply above to remove ambiguity and save this step. If you want to proceed with this sub-thread, I'll need you to be explicit, something like, "Here's is my definition of [definendum]: '[definiens]'." I can work with that, but not what you posted instead.I think you mustta missed this from #6075; My definition was quoted. I present definitions and evidence and they remain unseen or gainsaid.
I wish I could say that I could do the same with your words. As you know by now, I seldom know what you mean. I literally do not know what you mean by sudden (or gradual), language, life, or consciousness. You can fix that, but you'll need to provide definitions that allow me to correctly identify which things you would use such words with and which fall outside of the extension of your definition. Does cladking consider the sun alive or the pull of gravity a language between massive objects? Maybe. I can't answer. But I'll bet you can answer them both about me and every other poster on this thread.I must parse the many definitions and connotations of every word to reflect your beliefs; your intent. I'm sure I do this quite adequately.
Incidentally, what does cladking mean to you? Can I get a concise, direct answer such that I could explain it to somebody else? Maybe it means a fashion expert of some sort.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven dwarfs.You can't count what doesn't exist
Unique things can be counted.everything that exists is unique.
On a related tangent, are you familiar with what countable and uncountable nouns mean in grammar? Furniture is an uncountable noun, but table and chair are countable, thus the furniture comprised one table and four chairs, but furniture itself isn't counted, as in there were two furnitures. Less is the adjective for uncountable nouns (less furniture, less money, less water) but fewer for countable nouns (fewer chairs, fewer dollars, fewer ounces), which is why this drives some language purists nuts:
They do to me.this orange plus that apple still don't make two of anything.
Yet consciousness appears on nobody else's list of the qualities that define life. Being cellular does. Being organic does. Growth and repair do. Metabolism does. Reproduction does. But being aware doesn't.There is no such thing as unconscious life.