But the choice isn't "A diamond ring OR more attention."
I guess I'm lucky. I get a diamond ring, diamonds in my ears, AND attention.
By the way, a little feedback from my husband. When he gave me my diamond stud earrings, he made it a point to give them to me in front of my parents. You should have seen the look on his face when he saw me squeal with delight. My dad went over and shook his hand and said, "Well done, man! I'm impressed." My husband had done his homework. He has a friend who owns a coin and jewelry exchange. He had her look for two perfect, matched stones for MONTHS before finally settling on these. They are absolutely beautiful, even though they are not huge. I've had strangers tell me that they are impressed - that whoever bought these for me knew what he was doing - and like I said, these aren't large, showy stones. But they truly are beautiful.
He paid about 1/4 what the same quality stones would have cost at a retail store.
I never take them off except to polish them about once a month. Knowing the effort he put into them, and the pride he had when he knew that I recognized the superior quality, they are very special to me. Every couple of months or so, he'll walk up behind me while I'm fixing my hair or whatever, and he'll put his hands on my shoulders and look at me in the mirror and say, "Do you still love your earrings? I notice you never take them off." And I tell him, "Of course, I still love them - I always will. They're beautiful and my favorite person gave them to me."
If bought under the right conditions, diamonds ARE a good investment - you can trade them in, or pass them down as an heirloom, and meanwhile, the emotional rewards are well worth the price.
That is, IF you are buying diamonds for a person who appreciates them. I guess that's the bottom line.