Audie
Veteran Member
Did i say you are obligated? Try responding toPeople may ask about my belief, but I have no obligation to prove it is "real" to others. What others think is their thoughts, not mine
what is actually said.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Did i say you are obligated? Try responding toPeople may ask about my belief, but I have no obligation to prove it is "real" to others. What others think is their thoughts, not mine
Try to be nice for onceDid i say you are obligated? Try responding to
what is actually said.
If I talk nonsense, Id rather someone mention itTry to be nice for once
Has anyone felt God's presence?
I have, and I would describe it as enlightening.
Was it actually God? IDK, but the experience seemed to fit he bill of what I thought God's presence ought to feel like.
So we feel this presence and through it, justify our belief in God.
Through this personal experience.
Do you justify your belief through such an experience or do you have other means of justifying your belief in God?
This is a very fringe way of justifying the existence of God. Mostly we hear this kind of thing from hardcore internet evangelists. Very, very rare in general.
Historically the more common way of justifying the existence of God has been rationality.
As I asked another poster, how do you
apply reason and logic to something for
which you have zero, or extremely limited
information?
Abundant. You should explore a little.
"I have god inside me" is the most rare type of argument. But its more vocal and are on the internet so many who get their religious education from YouTube and street preachers think about it a bit.
Throughout history God and stuff like that has been always rationalisations. Logical arguments.
You " should" respond to what I actually asked.
You asked how do you apply reason and logic. Reason and logic is not always applied by empiricists like you which is unreasonable and illogical so you have to know and understand your own epistemology and intent prior to indulging in this.
I asked how to apply reason and logic to,
something for which there is no info.
What do you mean "there is no info"?
What do you consider "info"? Can you explain your epistemology?
If you cant, you will never be able to engage with reason and/or logic. Thats why I ask this question.
You mean distinguish justified belief from
opinion?
Its like the difference between belief in
Australia, and Atlantis.
There is info for Australia. Opinions for
Atlantis.
If you think there is "info" for god(s)
you may never be able to display reason or logic in this topic.
Do I have to justify to others that I believe in God?
God reveals himself to those whom he wants to. A person has to be awake enough to be aware of it. But if it is God doing the revealing there is no way the person is not going to know it. Although it is their choice if they chose to ignore it or not. Whenever I hear the argument "you can't prove God exists" I also think the logical answer, I don't need to. God already has proven his existence just by what he has made. Scripture says that his invisible qualities are clearly evident and demonstrated in his creation so that those who do not believe in God have no excuse:
"For his invisible qualities are clearly seen from the world’s creation onward, because they are perceived by the things made, even his eternal power and Godship, so that they are inexcusable."-Romans 1:20.
But God's word also tells us that not all people have faith:
"For faith is not a possession of all people."-2 Thessalonians 3:2.
And it reveals to us that true faith is only a gift granted to us by God himself:
"Each one as God has given to him a measure of faith."-Romans 12:3.
That measure of faith is granted to the person by God. And it is a part of the fruitage of God's holy spirit, so one would need to pray to God for such faith and have God's holy spirit active in their lives to have faith:
"On the other hand, the fruitage of the spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faith, mildness, self-control. Against such things there is no law."-Galatians 5:22-23.
ETA:
Sorry I hit post early. I wanted to add one more thing.
Jesus said:
"Keep on asking, and it will be given you; keep on seeking, and you will find; keep on knocking, and it will be opened to you; 8 for everyone asking receives, and everyone seeking finds, and to everyone knocking, it will be opened. 9 Indeed, which one of you, if his son asks for bread, will hand him a stone? 10 Or if he asks for a fish, he will not hand him a serpent, will he? 11 Therefore, if you, although being wicked, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more so will your Father who is in the heavens give good things to those asking him!"-Matthew 7:7-11.
If a person really wants true faith and a real relationship with the living God it is imperative that they ask him for wisdom and faith in prayer without doubting, and it will be given them.
This is a very fringe way of justifying the existence of God. Mostly we hear this kind of thing from hardcore internet evangelists. Very, very rare in general.
Historically the more common way of justifying the existence of God has been rationality.
Surely this is the issue - since you might be primed to interpret any such experience as being 'God's presence'. How could one determine this is the case from any number of other quite similar experiences or combinations of such to have produced this?
I hear it more often from what I'd call the mystic group of folks.
Also I heard it often from Christians.
Has anyone felt God's presence?
I have, and I would describe it as enlightening.
Was it actually God? IDK, but the experience seemed to fit he bill of what I thought God's presence ought to feel like.
So we feel this presence and through it, justify our belief in God.
Through this personal experience.
Do you justify your belief through such an experience or do you have other means of justifying your belief in God?
Has anyone felt God's presence?
I have, and I would describe it as enlightening.
Was it actually God? IDK, but the experience seemed to fit he bill of what I thought God's presence ought to feel like.
So we feel this presence and through it, justify our belief in God.
Through this personal experience.
Do you justify your belief through such an experience or do you have other means of justifying your belief in God?