This is what i agree with you from your answer
And this is were it gets tricky
Actually it is that Consciousness is a byproduct of intelligence in the whole procces of Evolution.
So as you can see in this article size is the measure of importance in some part of evolution.
Take,for example the time of the dinosaurs and the species that co-existed with them.You need only species to have a valid chain of hunters in the animal kingdom.
So those that were not on the top of the chain probably had to group and co-exist together since they were hunted by something bigger or stronger.In the same sense the hunters hunted because they knew they were hunting something smaller.
We know that intuition is in our genes as it is in other animal's.
We know that intution is what survived through species and evolved by the examples in some animal activity such as hunting.
How do migratory birds, herding dogs, and navigating sea turtles do the amazing things that they do? For hundreds of years, scientists and philosophers have struggled over possible explanations. In time, one word came to dominate the discussion: ...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
I know also other examples when we speak about instinct.
I remember the name of the one who made this study.I think it was Kuo or something like that but i can re-check it if it is neccessary.
He was studying the development of the heart in chicken embryos, he inserted a catheter into the tiny structure which was growing to be a heart. Every day, he measured the volume of the fluid extracted by the catheter On the 21 day, (the time chicks normally peck out of the egg), he withdrew the catheter and waited for his chicks to peck out.
None of them did, so he had to crack each shell to let them out.
This guy Kuo also discovered that none of them pecked for food and had to be hand fed.
Now, we know that pecking its way out of an egg is done by instinct since there is no little elf inside the egg telling the chick to 'peck on the dotted line'.
And similarly, chicks who don't peck for food, die.
So. what happened to Kuo's chicks?
Kuo retraced his steps. When chicks normally develop, they do so in a ball shape.The head is folded down to rest directly over the heart. But in order to expose the heart for placement of the catheter, the head was moved to the side..
So what could that do.?
Well, when the head is over the heart, every time the heart beats, the head bobs.When the head is displaced, It does not.
So think about what a head looks like when it bobs to the beating heart for most of the 21 day gestation. It looks like pecking, right?
So the pecking 'instinct' isn't directly encoded into the genes, but relies upon the shape of the developing creature to help it along.
When those features are tampered with, the 'instinct' does not appear.
The point is, there is a very complex interaction between what is carried by genes and what is promoted by the environment. They are really inseparable. But it is fair to say that whatever structures are provided by genetic information, they are not 'good to go' unless the proper environment is present.
And this does not apply only to instincts. It applies to most aspects of brain development and function.
That's OK , but being comfortable doesn't mean anything.
What kind of observation ?
Even what you said has no sense.What unseen agents? The deluded ones of the pseudo ID?
I can't belive that they are using such heretic terms.
But they belive they live in a stimulation and that's their best way to explain it.
That is how you measure their intellect.
It seems to me that they have confused themselfs with the meaning of 'Creator' and used some alternative as 'Designer'.
But your answer has value only when you adress their view , so it may be that you are to focused on the deluded ones.
I agree completly.
Maybe you will find it too..
What people?
You have every kind of people beliving in God
There are scientists , athlets , teachers , Gardeners , Postmans , Killers , Lunatics , Maniacs , War Criminals , Sick people , Christians , Muslims , Jews , Budhist.
Each one of them might say in its own way why he belives in God and that might not always be connected with science.
And that is how it is , Science and the Spiritual Realm are two different categories of study and each one of them speaks about different things.But there are those who think otherwise , that they are connected in some strange ways.That Science should give precise answers about the Spiritual Realm and the other way around - Spiritual Realm giving precise answers in the way of Science.
Evolution is a procces in the tree of life and this Universe.It's not just a given name for some sort of definition.
Nobody did it.