cataway
Well-Known Member
but you dont believe the bible to be true . sooo ,how can i believe you?From the Bible, the Qur'an, and the Writings of Baha'u'llah.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
but you dont believe the bible to be true . sooo ,how can i believe you?From the Bible, the Qur'an, and the Writings of Baha'u'llah.
I do believe that the Bible is true....but you dont believe the bible to be true . sooo ,how can i believe you?
So now you have decided that the word means "death" which means that no one is commanded to follow laws after he dies. Thanks for the clarification. You are stuck with a textual contradiction and you solve it with an irrelevant piece of unique interpretation. This means that the claims in Heb 13:20 are also until death. So Jesus could not have been resurrected because the "blood of the eternal covenant" was ineffectual once Jesus died and the covenant's "eternal" status disappeared.
I believe I made a mistake in post 847 and it is the Jews who say that God has no Son, even though their own scriptures speak of God's Son.
Because you say so, got it.It is plain that the slave in Ex 21:6 is speaking about someone who will be a servant for life,,,,,,,,,,not forever even if it says forever.
well, the Greek word is used in both cases but here you have decided that it means forever. Got it.The word for eternity in Heb 13:20,21 means forever.
And there are other phrases that qualify that singular word in the Hebrew and show how it means forever in other cases but not in Ex 21, but I'm sure that I said this already.There is another word (albeit from the same root) which can be translated as forever but also in other ways showing a lesser time. But I am sure I have said this.
And you got around it by simply saying that the word means something else when you need it to, not looking at other grammatical and linguistic constructs.If I am stuck with a textual contradiction then so are you. Rashi got around it and so did I.
You can figure it all you want but that's not what Jewish law teaches.I figure with the servant of Ex 21:6, he would keep serving even though Jubilee came, because he said that he loves his master and wife and does not want to go free.
Feel free. But the Torah is the compilation of laws which form the stipulations of the Mosaic covenant. When the text demands that Jews follow the eternal laws, that is because the covenant endures forever.[/QUOTE]I doubt that the Hebrew text anywhere says that the Mosaic Covenant is forever but I think it speaks of some laws being forever.
Baha'is do "believe" in the Bible. Very similar to the way liberal Christians "believe" in the Bible. Things that don't line up with science are called "superstitious" beliefs. And I'd agree. Who wants to believe in a 6 day Creation that supposedly happened less then 10,000 years ago. Or, that about 6,000 years ago the world was completely flooded. Or that a man came back to life after being dead for three days? Who believes this stuff literally? Well Fundy Christians do. Your beliefs about the Bible probably differ from them. But when you say, "I believe in the Bible".... it is not what a liberal Christian or a Baha'is means.but you dont believe the bible to be true . sooo ,how can i believe you?
Except that the start date can clearly be interpreted in different ways. Once again, I'll bring these links:
The L-rd's Anointed - Source Book
The 70 weeks in Daniel 9
I recommend you peruse them.
but why
I see there is layers of salvation and in this age it is collective, it is the salvation of Humanity as a whole. Abdul'baha wrote a Tablet of Salvation, it is yet to be translated, there is a section done as a provisional translation and you may like to read it in this blog
Salvation: For One and All
Personally it does not motivate me, as I see it is just the right thing to do, that is live one's life for the good of all. Try to. Find ways to give of yourself to help others, it is a daily challenge we can all participate in.
A prayer CG, that one can choose to offer and I give it for you today.
"O my God, the God of bounty and mercy! Thou art that King by Whose commanding word the whole creation hath been called into being; and Thou art that All-Bountiful One the doings of Whose servants have never hindered Him from showing forth His grace, nor have they frustrated the revelations of His bounty. Suffer this servant, I beseech Thee, to attain unto that which is the cause of his salvation in every world of Thy worlds. Thou art, verily, the Almighty, the Most Powerful, the All-Knowing, the All-Wise. – Baha’u’llah, Baha’i Prayers, p. 146."
Regards Tony
It is all about the state we choose to be in CG, we have discussed this quite a few times. Heaven and Hell are states of being. We are in those states in this life and when we die that state carries over as we traverse all the world's of God.
So see a rock as the state of hell and Human as Heaven. What would you want to be in this world, a rock or a Human.
If we grow no spiritual limbs here, we become a rock, if we do grow them we carry on with a level of comprehension that will enable us to see more of our next existance.
‘Abdu’l-Bahá has said that when human beings “become illuminated with the radiance of the sun of reality, and ennobled with all the virtues, they esteem this the greatest reward, and they know it to be the true paradise. In the same way they consider that the spiritual punishment…is to be subjected to the world of nature; to be veiled from God; to be brutal and ignorant; to fall into carnal lusts; to be absorbed in animal frailties; to be characterized with dark qualities…these are the greatest punishments and tortures…”
Regards Tony
"may be different"? But the text refers to them as the same Torah, and has already said that the covenant is eternal. So why do you suggest "may be different"?
The New Covenant is eternal yes. The Torah is the full revelation of God's Word to us. That is God's perfect Word.
Well, first off, "maybe"? Next -- non-Jews aren't the ones spoken about in the renewed covenant.
31 explicitly names Israel and Judah (the two nations that split after Solomon's time and are made up of the 13 tribes of the children of Jacob), and God says he will forgive. No person has to get that forgiveness for anyone.
So you want to jump to chapter 23? OK. In that chapter, there is a promise of a future messiah. Nothing about forgiveness. Just a king who will rule (which hasn't happened). So why do you bring this up? To point out more things that Jesus didn't fulfill?
I don't see any mention in those verses of "saving" of any sort - do you mean the promise that those who invoke the name of God won't be killed in the great war? I do see that everyone will be a prophet, and that there will be war and then Jews will rule. Have you seen any of this happen? Of course, 3 verses later, God specifices that he is talking about his people, Israel, but whatever.
No, the whole Torah is the whole Torah. Not a different text or another set of understandings. The whole Torah.
Obligations are fulfilled by fulfilling them. Nit by claiming they no longer exist.
Says who? I'm currently still alive. People who claim that one cannot follow the laws and live is ignoring that people do follow the laws and live.
Sure it is. I can understand the dilemma of Christians who want to deny the authority of the Torah when it suits them and rely on it at other points. I guess that's why so many Jews have refused to change their religion for so long -- they see the foolishness of the pick and choose approach.
What parts of the Law can't Jews do completely? Even if they did something wrong, there was a sacrifice they could do. So that gets them back with being right with God doesn't it? And even if Jesus did a sacrifice that was once and for all time, Christians keep sinning. So like the Jew, a Christian do things to get back in good standings with God. They have to pray and ask for forgiveness and are supposed to repent. Maybe now, without a Temple, I assume they don't do the sacrifices, but maybe they have an alternative. But to pray, fast and repent are still there for them. What do you think?
Baha'is do "believe" in the Bible. Very similar to the way liberal Christians "believe" in the Bible. Things that don't line up with science are called "superstitious" beliefs. And I'd agree. Who wants to believe in a 6 day Creation that supposedly happened less then 10,000 years ago. Or, that about 6,000 years ago the world was completely flooded. Or that a man came back to life after being dead for three days? Who believes this stuff literally? Well Fundy Christians do. Your beliefs about the Bible probably differ from them. But when you say, "I believe in the Bible".... it is not what a liberal Christian or a Baha'is means.
Abdu’l-Baha, The Promulgation of Universal Peace. We must cast aside such beliefs [superstitions] and investigate reality. That which is found to be real and conformable to reason must be accepted, and whatever science and reason cannot support must be rejected as imitation and not reality.In an article about the Baha'i Faith and the Bible, it says...
The Báb, Bahá'u'lláh and 'Abdu'l-Bahá frequently refer to the Gospels as a 'record' of events, for example: "To this testify the records of the four Gospels"[26] and one might interpret this as meaning a mere historical record. Shoghi Effendi lends weight to this possibility when he writes that "The Bible is not wholly authentic"
"You must know the Old and New Testaments as the Word of God"[24] ('Abdu'l-Bahá)
Bahá'u'lláh contradicts a point of historical detail in the Old Testament when he relates the story of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son Ishmael[28]. Genesis 22:9 says that this son was Isaac.
"When 'Abdu'l-Bahá states we believe what is in the Bible, He means in substance. Not that we believe every word of it to be...the authentic saying of the Prophet."[34] (written on behalf of Shoghi Effendi)
At a Christian site comparing the two religions, I found this quote...
With particular regard to the Bible, a letter dated 28 May 1984 written on behalf of the Universal House of Justice in response to questions raised by an individual believer outlines two principles to be observed in studying this book. “In studying the Bible Bahá'is must bear two principles in mind. The first is that many passages in Sacred Scripture are intended to be taken metaphorically, not literally, and some of the paradoxes and apparent contradictions which appear are intended to indicate this. The second is the fact that the text of the early Scriptures, such as the Bible, in not wholly authentic...”
“...we cannot be sure how much or how little of the four Gospels are accurate and included the words of Christ and His undiluted teachings, all we can be sure of, as Bahá'is is that what has been quoted by Bahá'u'llah and the Master ('Abdu'l-Baha) must be absolutely authentic.
The problem I have is with the sincerity part. I still like doing and thinking things that Christians say are sinful. I'm not going to change. I'm not going to repent. And that leads to the hypocrisy problem... I know Christians and Baha'is that do those same behaviors. They say they believe in God. They say they love God, yet... they don't and can't repent and stop doing those sinful behaviors. I've seen it tear at a Christian friends heart. He felt so guilty. But, the worse thing, I think, is when they continue in the behavior and stop feeling guilty.Sorry it has taken so long to reply. I'm trying to catch up with posts.
I guess a Jew could do what he wanted in the temple times and just offer sacrifice and say "I have kept the Law and am forgiven". God however told them that it was not sacrifice that He really wanted
Hosea 6: 6 For I desire mercy, not sacrifice, and the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings.
Psalm 40:6 Sacrifice and offering you did not desire
but my ears you have opened— burnt offerings and sin offerings you did not require.
7 Then I said, “Here I am, I have come—
it is written about me in the scroll.
8 I desire to do your will,
your law is within my heart.”
It is the same these days with repenting and not really wanting to change.
But of course sacrifice and repentance are good things and can cover up sins for the Jews (as they say) until the true forgiveness comes through the sacrifice of the Messiah. (this is seen to be the one speaking in Ps 40:7,8
Christians also do what is wrong and God forgives because of the sacrifice of Jesus in the New Covenant. It is complete forgiveness and not just a covering of sins for now. But of course God knows sincerity and hypocrisy and does not like the latter.
But, the worse thing, I think, is when they continue in the behavior and stop feeling guilty.
Next problem... if we go back to the start of this thread, the NT has some questionable "fulfilled" prophecies. Baha'is can't reject Jesus, so how do you explain those? Most of the ones I question are from Matthew. I think I already asked Adrian, but maybe you could comment on them too, or remind me of what you said if you already have. Matthew says, I'm going to paraphrase, Jesus and the family goes to Egypt to fulfill "out of Egypt I called my son," He has Ramah crying because her children are gone... They were taken into captivity... as a fulfillment of Herod's men killing little boys in Bethlehem... an event that no one else mentions. He has Jesus being called a "Nazarene", which refers to vows being taken and has nothing to do with where you live... But Matthew calls him that because his family lives in Nazareth. These are just little prophecies, but they are very arguably false. Probably not a detail that comes up often for Baha'is to have to explain, but it's very important, because without a good explanation, we have a gospel writer making up false prophecies. Pull your symbolic magic Tony and tell me what's up with this.Well researched and written again CG.
That would be how I see the Bible, to be as a Spiritual guide, it gives me no reason but to use it in such a way. By doing that, I can focus on what Christ asked me to do. This one Passage tells me I should not reject any Faith based on the fact I have accepted Christ, because Jesus also told us how to Judge a True Prophet.
1 Thessalonians 5:21“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.”
Regards Tony
God did lie to the disciples because the disciples did not write the NT. The NT came to us by way of oral tradition, so it is not the exact words of Jesus. Or even anything close.That is a problem I have with Baha'i. There is no idea that God tells us the truth in the scriptures. God lied to the disciples and deceived them into thinking that Jesus had risen bodily and it is fine by Baha'i to have a God who does that.
No, Jesus did not say that, men wrote that Jesus said that and it got recorded in the NT. Then a whole bunch of naïve people believed that Jesus said it because they could not reason that it would have been impossible for anyone who never even knew Jesus to know what He said and write it down decades later.John 2:19 Jesus answered them, “Destroy this temple, and I will raise it again in three days.”
Believe whatever you want to believe, they are just beliefs, nothing you can ever prove, so why argue about them incessantly?It does not matter what Baha'u'llah has written about anything. He is not the return of Jesus and as such his words are not important to anyone except a Baha'i.
It should matter but it does not matter to Christians.OTOH what the Bible tells us about false Christs and about the return of Jesus should matter to us all,,,,,
No, we are not denying the power of God, we are denying that God used His power to bring a decomposed body back to life, because it God would not do such a stupid thing since there would be no reason to do it, so it is obvious to any logical person that those are just stories men wrote in a book.They like you are denying the power of God.
That is not Jesus saying He is coming back to earth. Face it, Jesus never promised to return. Of course Jesus knew he could not return in the same body because Jesus knew His body died.John 14:3 And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come and take you to be with me that you also may be where I am.
You always have an answer, a way to say we are wrong.Baha'i likes to use the KJV it seems and that is wrong in places. The more modern translations are more accurate in terms of their understanding of the ancient languages and having correct scriptures to translate from.
By discrediting do you mean like this passage Baha’u’llah wrote about Jesus?Baha'u'llah does more discrediting of Jesus that telling us what the Bible tells of Jesus.
No, that is just putting Jesus on par with all the other Messengers of God, just where He belongs.Calling the Son of God just another Messenger from God is lowering Jesus status.
“And I say unto you that no calumny is able to prevail against the Light of God; it can only result in causing it to be more universally recognized. If a cause were of no significance, who would take the trouble to work against it!” Paris Talks, p. 106Usurping Jesus work that He will complete on His return and closing down the gospel message for all people after 1844 is..................so despicable and is the work of a false Christ and of the one who wants to attack the work of God which He did and is doing in Jesus and take down as many people with him as possible....................imho.
It would not matter to you what Baha’u’llah did because you want Jesus to return, but we do not always get what we want, although we can hope for it till hell freezes over.If Baha'u'llah had done one thing to complete this work that would be at least something,,,,,,,,,,but he has not.
By all scholarly accounts it had been, but you can always look for loopholes and they will always be found because most prophecies can be interpreted so many ways, so you can always say they do not apply to Baha’u’llah, even when they are so specific they are too obvious to deny, like Micah 7:12.Yes I know you want to believe that the gospel was preached to all the world by 1844 but in reality it has not even been preached to all the world by now.