• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Go ahead. Take your top off

Would you ever permit your daughter to do a topless scene in a movie?

  • Yes

    Votes: 21 72.4%
  • N0

    Votes: 8 27.6%

  • Total voters
    29

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
I would suggest that just photos or depictions of the naked body by itself is not "porn".
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
I think Godobyer said it having the posts that say it's okay because it is an art while porn is an art too.

@Godobeyer : could this be the reason?
Porn is group of people filming while making sex , and publish it.

for your opinion SG :
Is sex scene consider as cuckold or art ?
if yes, is cuckold is good ?
 

Skwim

Veteran Member

Since the picture was removed, you may want to edit a substitute in its place. Perhaps a link to
would suffice?

It would be entirely a factor of how much I trusted the society she lived in. In Brazil I would not.​
Thank you for the suggestion, but I no longer have the ability to edit my OP, and I think the picture has been up long enough for most people to have seen it. However, I will post a link to the video of the scene, which is: HERE


.
 

Draka

Wonder Woman
Then what is sex scene lol
Uh, a scene in which people are having sex. The naked body alone is not sex. A breast is not sex. Two, or even more, people engaged in sexual relations like vaginal intercourse or oral or anal sex and the like would constitute a sex scene. But a boob...is just a boob.
 

Draka

Wonder Woman
Porn is group of people filming while making sex , and publish it.

for your opinion SG :
Is sex scene consider as cuckold or art ?
if yes, is cuckold is good ?
What if the sex scene in question is of a husband and wife? If a married couple sets up a camera in their bedroom and records themselves having sex is that "cuckold"? If for their private viewing pleasure? If for public viewing pleasure with both their consent?
 

Smart_Guy

...
Premium Member
Porn is an art? i don't know if I would classify it as such. Either way, since porn is not the discussion here, the naked breast is, I still don't see the connection. :shrug:

Well, porn is not what couple typically do in real life and it involves studies performance. Many call porn actors performers and, well, actors. But given the conditions you provided, I tend to agree.

It still worries me because I typically think of young woman out there as my own daughters *I'm not a father, but I have nieces and I'm 33) and sisters in what they go thru. Play Boy started with just boobs, then escalated to lower parts and finally many of its models became porn stars.
 

Skwim

Veteran Member
At 16, no, I would not approve of it...and, it is against the law as far as I know, at least in the US (I think actors have to be 18 under federal law). .
Obviously it isn't against the law because she did it and there were no legal repercussions, for anyone.


No, I would not consent to porn. There are numerous reasons for that that I think should be self-explanatory. But as for just nudity, being topless, I don't see an issue. We aren't talking about sex, we're talking about boobs.
Right, boobs that in many states any female is allowed to bare.

Porn is an art? i don't know if I would classify it as such. Either way, since porn is not the discussion here, the naked breast is, I still don't see the connection. :shrug:
Of course there isn't any, but oftentimes when a person's point is fairly well shot down they exaggerate the issue by bringing in irrelevancies. Hardly a commendable practice, people. :thumbsdown:


I would suggest that just photos or depictions of the naked body by itself is not "porn".
And they're not. I think that some of the members here are simply uptight about nudity.


.
 

4consideration

*
Premium Member
Obviously it isn't against the law because she did it and there were no legal repercussions, for anyone.

.
It is against the law. I think you might have overlooked what he was responding to. The question he was replying to was whether or not those that said yes about being topless would approve of their 16 year old daughter doing hard-core porn.

Hard core porn is against the law for a 16 year old.
 
Last edited:

Draka

Wonder Woman
Well, porn is not what couple typically do in real life and it involves studies performance. Many call porn actors performers and, well, actors. But given the conditions you provided, I tend to agree.

It still worries me because I typically think of young woman out there as my own daughters *I'm not a father, but I have nieces and I'm 33) and sisters in what they go thru. Play Boy started with just boobs, then escalated to lower parts and finally many of its models became porn stars.
I dont know about many Playboy models becoming porn stars, I havent heard of that at all really. And Playboy I find artistic actually. In fact, there's a pile of some just a few feet from me. Now, magazines such as Hustler are more on the pornographic side, but Playboy? No. Not really. At least not in my opinion.
 

Smart_Guy

...
Premium Member
It is against the law. I think you might have overlooked what he was responding to. The question he was replying to was whether or not those that said yes about being topless would approve of their 16 year old daughter doing hard-core porn.

Hard core porn is against the law for a 16 year old.

Also, even as older than 16, they are still our daughters. The thread is about permission and approval which is verbal, not allowing which involves letting or making them not. One may not permit or approve but still leaves the person do what they want. I think it is all about family ethics. People with good family bonds tend to respect what their parents' wishes unconditionally. Then again, I think even that is a cultural thing.
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
Uh, a scene in which people are having sex. The naked body alone is not sex. A breast is not sex. Two, or even more, people engaged in sexual relations like vaginal intercourse or oral or anal sex and the like would constitute a sex scene. But a boob...is just a boob.
Here,it's different,breast is consider as sex scene,and shamefull :p
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
What if the sex scene in question is of a husband and wife? If a married couple sets up a camera in their bedroom and records themselves having sex is that "cuckold"? If for their private viewing pleasure? If for public viewing pleasure with both their consent?
No I am talking about someone agree that his wife doing sex scene with man.
 

Draka

Wonder Woman
Also, even as older than 16, they are still our daughters. The thread is about permission and approval which is verbal, not allowing which involves letting or making them not. One may not permit or approve but still leaves the person do what they want. I think it is all about family ethics. People with good family bonds tend to respect what their parents' wishes unconditionally. Then again, I think even that is a cultural thing.
Permission for a minor to do something is such situations is not verbal, but written and signed contract. The minor cannot make legal decisions on their own, and to ensure that the film company cannot be sued for anything in particular that the minor may do in their movie, they must have the contractual permission of a parent or legal guardian.
 

Draka

Wonder Woman
Here,it's different,breast is consider as sex scene,and shamefull :p
But no actual sex is involved. It is just a body part being shown, like a foot or a man's chest. Is a baby breastfeeding a sex scene? It involves a breast. Does that make it a sex scene?
No I am talking about someone agree that his wife doing sex scene with man.
So porn made by married couples is okay? What if it is the married man engaging in porn instead of the wife? Is that different?
 
Top