Wow threads certainly move fast in the new year! Anyhow, on topic... I think anime is a combination of acquired taste and watching the right ones. Like you, I don't like the over-the-top screaming etc, and as my introduction to anime was Pokemon and DBZ, and whatever else was supplied on afternoon kids TV, I never was interested.now, a few years ago I was introduced to Death Note. I was rather sceptical at first, but the story really Drew me in.it was complex and fast-paced, made me think, and there were no episodes where an entire half hour was devoted to charging some super move. So for me the story its important, and I've found anime to be able to deliver complex stories in ways that often western-made series don't do.
Also, I really dislike filler episodes.