• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Is America a Police state?

SageTree

Spiritual Friend
Premium Member
oh jeez! I heard about this too dude....

I SO can't wait to get back into Canada this summer and watch this from a distance.
 

SageTree

Spiritual Friend
Premium Member
I cross it a lot... going into Canada is the LEAST of my concerns on the directions I could be heading.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
I cross it a lot... going into Canada is the LEAST of my concerns on the directions I could be heading.
I don't mind the Canadian side.
It's the Americans who cause me grief. (Brutish, aren't we?)
I'm done having guns pointed at me, so I don't drive across that border anymore.
 

SageTree

Spiritual Friend
Premium Member
I had a gun pulled on me when they asked me what was on my belt, could they see it...

So when I reached for my CAMERA, they also reached for their guns.

"Easy boys.... when I shoot this thing no one gets hurt unwarranted."

They didn't think I was being funny, but ***** dude..... I nearly got a gun put on me for that....


Again I say... when is Iraq going to come liberate us!?

It's their turn!


Funny how America was founded on getting rid of the oppression of the king, unsubstantiated detentions and no rights to a lawyer if deemed unworthy... etc etc etc...

Looks like kids just wanted to be their own kings w/ their own subject.

:(
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
I had a gun pulled on me when they asked me what was on my belt, could they see it...
So when I reached for my CAMERA, they also reached for their guns.
"Easy boys.... when I shoot this thing no one gets hurt unwarranted."
They didn't think I was being funny, but ***** dude..... I nearly got a gun put on me for that....
Again I say... when is Iraq going to come liberate us!?
It's their turn!
Funny how America was founded on getting rid of the oppression of the king, unsubstantiated detentions and no rights to a lawyer if deemed unworthy... etc etc etc...
Looks like kids just wanted to be their own kings w/ their own subject.
:(
True dat.....
 

Road Warrior

Seeking the middle path..
Police continue to harass citizens who record them | Washington Examiner

www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdxMjjTu44s

Your thoughts about recording the acts of public 'servants'?
Has anyone had a bad experience with law enforcement?

No, the USA isn't a police state but, yes, the police are wrong about harassing those who video tape them in public.

This will go to the Supreme Court if necessary. The implication being, that if citizens can't video in public, then how can the government put up security cameras and video innocent citizens without just cause?
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
This will go to the Supreme Court if necessary. The implication being, that if citizens can't video in public, then how can the government put up security cameras and video innocent citizens without just cause?
I wouldn't put it past the USSC to construct some extra-constitutional rationale that gov may do what citizens may not.
The light of day frightens the bejeezus out of authorities who are used to doing what they do with impunity.
 

Road Warrior

Seeking the middle path..
I think many citizens, including myself, would be very upset in such a circumstance. Which is why I do not believe it will come to pass. Remember, despite all the urbanite attacks on the issue, it's "We, the People" who have most of the guns.

Gadsden-animated.gif
cowb.gif
 

Nashitheki

Hollawitta
Is America a police state ?

I seem to remember first asking that very same question back in 1976. The pay phone down the street was tapped and there was often an unmarked Plymouth Fury parked across the street from our pad.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Is America a police state ?

I seem to remember first asking that very same question back in 1976. The pay phone down the street was tapped and there was often an unmarked Plymouth Fury parked across the street from our pad.
I wasn't watching you.
I just had trouble keeping that pile of junk running, so it stayed put a lot.
 

Road Warrior

Seeking the middle path..
LOL.

Yes, the police do seem to monitor certain areas of illicit activities. It works for me. Public security cams? Does that make good sense or does that make us a police state?
 

painted wolf

Grey Muzzle
LOL.

Yes, the police do seem to monitor certain areas of illicit activities. It works for me. Public security cams? Does that make good sense or does that make us a police state?
Depends on where those cameras are doesn't it.

Do all citizen need to be monitored by the state whenever they are outside their homes?

wa:do
 

Road Warrior

Seeking the middle path..
Depends on where those cameras are doesn't it.

Do all citizen need to be monitored by the state whenever they are outside their homes?

wa:do

Of course. Which is why I said "public security cams". Obviously we still have our Constitutional rights in the USA especially, as in this case, our Fourth Amendment rights.

Monitor all citizens? My perspective is that public areas are monitored. Nobody cares if you and I meet, have a drink and a few laughs. OTOH, if, while we were doing this, we were mugged by some guy who takes off on a motorcycle, wouldn't it be nice if there was a videotape of both the crime and the getaway vehicle?
 

painted wolf

Grey Muzzle
Of course. Which is why I said "public security cams". Obviously we still have our Constitutional rights in the USA especially, as in this case, our Fourth Amendment rights.

Monitor all citizens? My perspective is that public areas are monitored. Nobody cares if you and I meet, have a drink and a few laughs. OTOH, if, while we were doing this, we were mugged by some guy who takes off on a motorcycle, wouldn't it be nice if there was a videotape of both the crime and the getaway vehicle?
And what if someone does care if you and I meet? It's not like there is no precedent for innocent people to be unfairly tracked by the state here in the USA.

wa:do
 

Road Warrior

Seeking the middle path..
And what if someone does care if you and I meet? It's not like there is no precedent for innocent people to be unfairly tracked by the state here in the USA.

wa:do

Why would they care? It's a public area. If you and I were concerned about being seen on a public security cam we could go to a private area where our Constitutional rights protect us.

As for "innocent people to be unfairly tracked", in this nation we're innocent until proven guilty so, yes, "innocent" people are being tracked because they haven't been convicted of anything. However, due to budget cuts and standard financial reasons, police don't have the time or money to track just anyone they feel like. They'd focus on those whom they think are actually involved in illicit activities.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Why would they care? It's a public area. If you and I were concerned about being seen on a public security cam we could go to a private area where our Constitutional rights protect us.
To be observed in some public areas ain't so bad. The danger is that eventually we might be observed in any public area,
including private areas which can be seen from a public area. The USSC appears to be heading in the direction of allowing this.
Their "expectation of privacy" is more liberal than mine.....or rather less (classically) liberal.

As for "innocent people to be unfairly tracked", in this nation we're innocent until proven guilty so, yes, "innocent" people are being tracked because they haven't been convicted of anything. However, due to budget cuts and standard financial reasons, police don't have the time or money to track just anyone they feel like. They'd focus on those whom they think are actually involved in illicit activities.
Hmmmm....it sems the best way to preserve liberty is to limit government's funding.
Starve the beast!
 
Top