• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

is his opinion is fact or propaganda (lies) ?

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
hello all

is that true that Ben Gurion said that ?

is true that Israel wish that Iraq and Syria and Egypt get destructed and split to pieces ?

Is true that Jewish Lobby (AIPAC) is who control USA policy ?

 

Debater Slayer

Vipassana
Staff member
Premium Member
The people fighting each other in Syria are not Jews.

The two major political poles conflicting with each other in Egypt (the Islamists and supporters of As-Sisi) are not Jews.

The Shi'as and Sunnis killing each other in Iraq are not Jews.

The extremist scholars and their supporters in Saudi Arabia are not Jews.

If Israel is indeed trying to bring down the Arab world, it is doing so by the hands of the Arab world's own inhabitants. Israeli is but a mere spot on the map of the Middle East. The Arab world has oil, land, and a numerical advantage on Israel. Guess who is the main culprit in getting the Arab world to reach its current miserable state.

My guess: It is not Israel.
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
The people fighting each other in Syria are not Jews.

The two major political poles conflicting with each other in Egypt (the Islamists and supporters of As-Sisi) are not Jews.

The Shi'as and Sunnis killing each other in Iraq are not Jews.

The extremist scholars and their supporters in Saudi Arabia are not Jews.

If Israel is indeed trying to bring down the Arab world, it is doing so by the hands of the Arab world's own inhabitants. Israeli is but a mere spot on the map of the Middle East. The Arab world has oil, land, and a numerical advantage on Israel. Guess who is the main culprit in getting the Arab world to reach its current miserable state.

My guess: It is not Israel.

Shias and Sunnis start killing each other after MORE after USA invade Iraq

Saudi Arabia host Mecca and Medina and very big media , so most of Muslims listen and may follow to their scholars .

These extremist scholars belong (could controled) by Saudi Arabia regime (agree ?),Saudi Arabia regime is follower (sheeps) to USA (agree ?) and USA policy dominated by AIPAC(agree ?),the result = AIPAC is root of the problem .

I hope you understand my view by linked all together ; I am talking about influence indirect and intervention of West (AIPAC) in Arab world .
 

Debater Slayer

Vipassana
Staff member
Premium Member
Shias and Sunnis start killing each other after MORE after USA invade Iraq

Saudi Arabia host Mecca and Medina and very big media , so most of Muslims listen and may follow to their scholars .

These extremist scholars belong (could controled) by Saudi Arabia regime (agree ?),Saudi Arabia regime is follower (sheeps) to USA (agree ?) and USA policy dominated by AIPAC(agree ?),the result = AIPAC is root of the problem .

I hope you understand my view by linked all together ; I am talking about influence indirect and intervention of West (AIPAC) in Arab world .

1) Yes, the Sunni-Shi'a conflict was arguably made worse by the United States' intervention in Iraq, but the seed of hatred between them had already been there. The U.S. didn't plant it.

2) So a lot of Muslims listen to Saudi scholars without any intervention from the "West" or Israel. Whose fault is that? Right... neither the West's nor Israel's.

3) The extremist scholars are supported by the Saudi regime, yes, and I agree that the Saudi regime is a puppet of the U.S.

4) No, I don't agree that the policies of the U.S. are dominated by the AIPAC. Things don't work so simply in a powerful country like the U.S.

The U.S. and some Western countries definitely intervene in the Middle East to bolster their own interests, but the seeds of many of the Middle East's problems weren't planted by anyone but some Middle Eastern people. Blaming others for the mistakes of a lot of Middle Eastern people reeks of intellectual complacency and lack of self-examination.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Get the tin hats ready, boys.
You're so old school.
We wear aluminum these days, toots!

And we may look fabulous!
th
 

columbus

yawn <ignore> yawn
Shias and Sunnis start killing each other after MORE after USA invade Iraq
I don't think that this is true. USA policies did more damage before that. We instigated the war between Iraq and Iran, with casualties estimated at close to a million.
After toppling Iran's democracy we supported a king, Shah Pahlavi. When Saddam Hussein toppled Iraq's government, we supported him. What the two governments had in common was being "good for USA businesses" and being hated by majorities of their people. When the Iranians gave Pahlavi the boot the USA turned to Hussein to regain control of Iranian oil fields, supporting his invasion. That didn't work. Then Hussein tried to take control of Kuwait, but the USA did not need that so we opposed that invasion. USA knew Hussein was weak and expected the Iraqis to overthrow him, but he hung on for years. To regain control of the oil fields we had to topple him ourselves.
So we did. Although that didn't work out well either.

And the end result of all this greed is the mess with which we are all currently living.

Tom
 

David1967

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
hello all

is that true that Ben Gurion said that ?

is true that Israel wish that Iraq and Syria and Egypt get destructed and split to pieces ?

Is true that Jewish Lobby (AIPAC) is who control USA policy ?

My own personal opinion is that Israel would prefer a peace with those countries such as the treaty they had with Egypt from the Jimmy Carter presidency. That seemed to work pretty well for several years. And, no there is no "Jewish Lobby" controlling USA policy.....We have many , many, countless lobbies that do that:rolleyes:
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
1) Yes, the Sunni-Shi'a conflict was arguably made worse by the United States' intervention in Iraq, but the seed of hatred between them had already been there. The U.S. didn't plant it.

2) So a lot of Muslims listen to Saudi scholars without any intervention from the "West" or Israel. Whose fault is that? Right... neither the West's nor Israel's.

3) The extremist scholars are supported by the Saudi regime, yes, and I agree that the Saudi regime is a puppet of the U.S.
we seem almost agree except 4

4) No, I don't agree that the policies of the U.S. are dominated by the AIPAC. Things don't work so simply in a powerful country like the U.S.
I believe AIPAC had dominated US policies , that's why USA vote against Palestine many times , that's why USA invade Iraq and that's why Israel want to push USA in war against Iran .

I believe AIPAC is strongest lobby in USA , there is no US president can access to white house without permission of AIPAC .

some claim by saying USA is occupied by Israel


it's weird that USA Jewish Lobby helped Israelis instead helping of millions of poor Americans , inside America .
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
My own personal opinion is that Israel would prefer a peace with those countries such as the treaty they had with Egypt from the Jimmy Carter presidency. That seemed to work pretty well for several years. And, no there is no "Jewish Lobby" controlling USA policy.....We have many , many, countless lobbies that do that:rolleyes:
Which strongest Lobby in USA ?
 

columbus

yawn <ignore> yawn
I believe AIPAC had dominated US policies , that's why USA vote against Palestine many times , that's why USA invade Iraq and that's why Israel want to push USA in war against Iran .

AIPAC is powerful, but not for the reasons you think. Nor are they as powerful as you think that they are.

Most Zionists in the world are probably US Christian fundamentalist. They believe that Israel will bring about the Second Return of Jesus. Oil companies also want an army close to the oil fields of the ME. Weapons manufacturers make billions supplying the armies.
There are many reasons for AIPAC that have almost nothing to do with Jewish people.
Tom
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
Here is a link to a site that names some of the largest lobbies in the USA. Yes the pro Israel lobby is big but its not the biggest. There are lots of lobby groups in the USA and no single one or even ten controls the country. Anyway here is the link, enjoy;
http://www.businesspundit.com/10-of-the-biggest-lobbies-in-washington/
I was talking about which take had almost full control on USA foreign politics , not
The Tech Lobby
or The Agribusiness ,
The Mining Industry


which one is top, is not AIPAC ?
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
AIPAC is powerful, but not for the reasons you think. Nor are they as powerful as you think that they are.

Most Zionists in the world are probably US Christian fundamentalist. They believe that Israel will bring about the Second Return of Jesus. Oil companies also want an army close to the oil fields of the ME. Weapons manufacturers make billions supplying the armies.
There are many reasons for AIPAC that have almost nothing to do with Jewish people.
Tom
I know that many US Christains are Zionists and support Israel , so how is work that they support Jews for bring back Jesus (pbuh) to Christians lol

actuatly i will feel shame if am Christian , then i believe that Jesus (pbuh) will comeback to Jews , not to me .

AIPAC full control in USA VETO when it's about Palestin .
 

columbus

yawn <ignore> yawn
I know that many US Christains are Zionists and support Israel , so how is work that they support Jews for bring back Jesus (pbuh) to Christians lol

actuatly i will feel shame if am Christian , then i believe that Jesus (pbuh) will comeback to Jews , not to me .
I'm not the best person to explain this, I think it is a bunch of nonsense. But Jesus comes back for everyone, and Israel must exist and rebuild the Temple first, according to many people. If anyone blows up Al Aqsa it is more likely to be Christians than Jews.
AIPAC full control in USA VETO when it's about Palestin .
They are not as powerful as you think. But they do have support from a lot of people for very different reasons.
Tom
 
Top