(quote)
Hi
Thank you so much for giving me an idea of your beliefs and thoughts on the matter. I do appreciate your sharing of your perspective on the subject. And I don't think it would be possible for either of us to 'change' the mindset, or beliefs of the other. But it does make for good conversation, no?
I actually agree with you that the planet earth was not created in 6 literal 24 hour days, as some seem to think. Oh, I am of the mind that it was more like billions of years during the creative periods.
There are other things that some religious people who use the Bible for their basis, ( so they say) seem to believe and teach that I also do not agree with. Their interpretation does not agree with what I understand the Bible to be saying most of the time. oh, they may have a few things similar, but as a whole, we are oceans apart in our beliefs.
And certainly, the Bible is not a science textbook. But if properly understood, I do believe that when questions of or statements made of a scientific nature as it applies to creation, etc., the Bible is correct. As I said, there are many who argue that the Bible 'says' or 'teaches' things that I don't necessarily agree with. There is a plethora of false doctrines out there, (and they may say the same about mine) and even many 'Christians' are not in agreement on what it really teaches.
However, there is one group that is of a global scope, and in over 700 languages and dialects, that DO agree on the teachings of the Bible. But then, going back to Biblical understanding, 1 Corinthians 1:10 tells us that the true faith will 'speak in agreement, with no divisions among them'. That would be the group that I identify with, and that is no small feat, actually, when it is considered in the scope of the divisive world in which we live today.
From my perspective, that could only happen with God's Spirit directing the nearing 9 million peoples around the world of all nationalities, language groups, tribal affiliations, races and socio-economic groupings existing in peace together today in unity.
thanks for the pleasant exchange of ideas,
peace to you
(quote)
There is a
(quote)
Hi
Thank you so much for giving me an idea of your beliefs and thoughts on the matter. I do appreciate your sharing of your perspective on the subject. And I don't think it would be possible for either of us to 'change' the mindset, or beliefs of the other. But it does make for good conversation, no?
I actually agree with you that the planet earth was not created in 6 literal 24 hour days, as some seem to think. Oh, I am of the mind that it was more like billions of years during the creative periods.
There are other things that some religious people who use the Bible for their basis, ( so they say) seem to believe and teach that I also do not agree with. Their interpretation does not agree with what I understand the Bible to be saying most of the time. oh, they may have a few things similar, but as a whole, we are oceans apart in our beliefs.
And certainly, the Bible is not a science textbook. But if properly understood, I do believe that when questions of or statements made of a scientific nature as it applies to creation, etc., the Bible is correct. As I said, there are many who argue that the Bible 'says' or 'teaches' things that I don't necessarily agree with. There is a plethora of false doctrines out there, (and they may say the same about mine) and even many 'Christians' are not in agreement on what it really teaches.
However, there is one group that is of a global scope, and in over 700 languages and dialects, that DO agree on the teachings of the Bible. But then, going back to Biblical understanding, 1 Corinthians 1:10 tells us that the true faith will 'speak in agreement, with no divisions among them'. That would be the group that I identify with, and that is no small feat, actually, when it is considered in the scope of the divisive world in which we live today.
From my perspective, that could only happen with God's Spirit directing the nearing 9 million peoples around the world of all nationalities, language groups, tribal affiliations, races and socio-economic groupings existing in peace together today in unity.
thanks for the pleasant exchange of ideas,
peace to you
(quote)
You have not outlined in any detail what your specific beliefs are or why you think they are true. I usually request a detailed description of what a person believes and why they believe it so there is no confusion in the discussion. I have found that there are so many versions of Christianity, and so many nuances believed by individual Christians, that without that information, I can spend hours with a discussion and then be told "that's not MY god". So minimally, I would need to know all the claimed attributes of the proposed deity. You have to keep in mind that I see your god in the same light that you see all other gods.
That being said.......
Well, "Speaking in agreement with no divisions between" them could apply to most any group, since even if you took a small group out of any given denomination who agreed, then you have the same thing......a group that now agrees. That even could be said of groups of non-religious people. So by your logic on that, a group of atheists who agree on things must have the truth. This is a logical fallacy, actually. The truthfulness of a proposition does not depend upon the number of people who think it is true.
It can even be true if no one believes it is true.
I would point out to you, also, that from my point of view, the Bible is nothing more than a collection of short stories arbitrarily compiled out of dozens or perhaps hundreds of others by a small group of people who had their own religious and political ends in mind. For it to be quoted as if it came from the mind of a god, or even indicated the presence of a god, you first have to establish that the god exists, and then you have to establish that said god had anything to do with the stories in the Bible. So you would have a lot of work ahead of you. After two millennia, professional apologists who have devoted their lives to the task have come up with nothing of merit on these two key points.
Now, to be fair, I really don't know what sort of evidence would convince me of the existence of a god. but it is reasonable to assume that a god would know what would be required and if it wished me to know that it existed, then it would provide me with the evidence. Faith certainly won't do it. Faith is to me the rough equivalent of gullibility, because there is nothing one cannot believe on faith alone. Faith is evident in virtually every religion, as are prophecy, miracles, visions, personal experiences, and so on. so none of those things carry much weight in determining the truth of a claim, else all religions are true. And if we can agree on anything, certainly we can agree that they can't all be true.
I can say that the god presented in the Bible is not a god that I would deem worthy of my worship even if it were real. I find too many distasteful things in his character and actions.
And, again, all THAT being said, I would be happy to continue this discussion with you if you feel up to it and would enjoy such a thing.
Let me pose some questions to you:
1. Why are you a Christian and not a Muslim, or Hindu, or Buddhist, etc?
2. What would it take for you to not believe? (Big question, take your time.....)
3. Do you only use the New Testament, or do you believe the Old testament is also true?
4. What, outside of the Bible itself, leads you to believe it's claims are true?
5. What evidence, outside of the Bible itself, indicates to you that any god at all really exists?
I may challenge your answers, so take your time. There is no hurry. If you don't feel you can articulate your positions well enough and/or just don't care to be challenged, just answer them anyway and I will keep my own analysis to myself. Let me know which you prefer. Some people like the back and forth and some do not. As is evidenced on this forum, discussions can become somewhat intense at times. I prefer to keep the emotional element out of it as much as possible. It clouds logic.
Thanks again for your posts.