• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Is Trump / MAGA / the US Fascist?

Daemon Sophic

Avatar in flux
For this debate, I'll use The 14 Characteristics of Fascism, by Lawrence Britt, Spring 2003 as a basis. It isn't a definition of fascism, but a collection of characteristics fascist countries had.

  1. Powerful and Continuing Nationalism
    Trump: yes; MAGA: YES; the US: yes
  2. Disdain for the Recognition of Human Rights
    Trump: partly; MAGA: yes; US: no
  3. Identification of Enemies/Scapegoats as a Unifying Cause
    Trump: yes; MAGA: yes; US: partly
  4. Supremacy of the Military
    Trump: no; MAGA: yes; US: it's complicated
  5. Rampant Sexism
    Trump: YES; MAGA: yes; US: no
  6. Controlled Mass Media
    Trump: no; MAGA: some (DeSantis); US: NO
  7. Obsession with National Security
    Trump: no; MAGA: partly; US: yes
  8. Religion and Government are Intertwined
    Trump: not really; MAGA: some: US: NO
  9. Corporate Power is Protected
    Trump: yes; MAGA: yes; US: yes
  10. Labor Power is Suppressed
    Trump: doesn't care; MAGA: yes; US: it's complicated
  11. Disdain for Intellectuals and the Arts
    Trump: doesn't care; MAGA: yes; US: no
  12. Obsession with Crime and Punishment
    Trump: no; MAGA: yes; US: yes
  13. Rampant Cronyism and Corruption
    Trump: YES; MAGA: yes; US: it's complicated
  14. Fraudulent Elections
    Trump: YES; MAGA: yes; US: no
Trump: 6/14; MAGA: 11/14; US: 4/14

That's how I see it from the outside. Trump has fascist tendencies, and if he wins in November, the US may be on the road to fascism, but he himself is not a fascist.

Controlled Mass Media
Trump: YES; MAGA: some (DeSantis); US: NO
He has repeatedly made it very clear that he will try to yank the broadcasting licenses of all non-Trump-supporting networks, and arrest the administrators of those networks on day one.
1st amendment be damned.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
Let me as the following:
  1. Did yo read the VOX interview of Albright?
No.
  1. How do you think you would have answered the questions posed in the OP with regards to Hitler on January 1, 1933?
"Mein Kampf" was already out in '33. His fascist ideas were known.
What we have from Trump is "The Art of the Deal", which he didn't write himself, and, afaik, it doesn't contain fascist ideas.
 

Daemon Sophic

Avatar in flux
Fascists are the new communists for some people, I guess.

And the new and dangerous fascists for others.
Sorry. :confused: I don’t get what either (or both) of you are implying.

Are you suggesting a McCarthy-esque unreasoning hatred of Fascisism? Or aspiring autocrats?
Or somehow knowingly citing The Insurrectionist’s repeated threats to sic the military on the Left-wingers (“enemies within”) in our nation?

Because the former would suggest a willful ignorance on your parts of how autocrats historically come to power, as well as tRump’s own words.
While the latter….. you’re not conveying; but the McCarthy-esque fear-mongering and divisive anger, report your neighbor and family members sort of madness, is actually directly from The Insurrectionist’s *******-shaped mouth. :shrug:


 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Fascists are the new communists for some people, I guess.
Sometimes terms are applied as mere insult.
Few of the many accused "communists" advocated
that individuals may not own property, both private
& the means of production.
Example....
Harris is a hard leftie, but....

But Trump does arguably fit definitions of "fascist".

The big question is whether he'd be able to implement
a fascist regime. He's been a rather weak leader because
the 2 party system requires working with the opposition
to accomplish much. So while he'd steer the country in
a more authoritarian & theocratic direction, full blown
fascism looks unlikely (but possible).
 

Kathryn

It was on fire when I laid down on it.
Many Magas are uneducated & have no penis.
Some people need to hear it.
Yep, some people do. We can say it together if you like. Many people bandy about the Fascist word and many (but not all) MAGAS are uneducated and have no penis.
 
Last edited:

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
No.

"Mein Kampf" was already out in '33. His fascist ideas were known.
What we have from Trump is "The Art of the Deal", which he didn't write himself, and, afaik, it doesn't contain fascist ideas.
Harris on the other hand is definitely Marxist communist friendly.

Price controls for instance are straight from the communist handbook.

I have yet to hear a Republican yelling , "Fascism wins" ! Either.
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
Harris on the other hand is definitely Marxist communist friendly.
Not a true or relevant statement in any way.
Price controls for instance are straight from the communist handbook.
Like Trump's tariffs? It's direct government control, but in the wrong dirction to what will help the American consumer. He wants to implement them and they will increase prices dramatically. He thinks this will force corporations to manufacture in the USA. It won't. And retailers like Walmart and Target will see fewer sales since the disposable income will have less buying power, and that means less profit.

What Harris plans to do is fine any corporation that increases prices on products when there's clear evidence it was not due to increased costs of production. Like if a company sells 12 ounces of cookies for $4 and suddenly the packages are 10.2 ounces at the same price. It's called shrinkflation and a common practice these days.
I have yet to hear a Republican yelling , "Fascism wins" ! Either.
No fascists ever do. They pretend they are democratic and the other side is their enemy. Look at Jan 6. Those gullible fools thought they were fighting for democracy, and only because they believed Trump's lies. That's how fascism happens: stupid citizens believing a disturbed and chronic liar.
 

Saint Frankenstein

Here for the ride
Premium Member
No, if he were an actual Fascist, he'd care more about the environment, want the government to have the ultimate say over the private sector, set up state controlled labor unions (which is what Fascist corporatism is), wouldn't have been a draft dodger, have public works programs, would promote high brow art and culture, stop sending our money and weaponry to other countries, etc. I'd honestly like him more. Lol. People just like using it as an insult, like "communist" or "socialist". Both the modern Democrats and the Republicans have general authoritarian leanings these days, and both are agents of the Empire, keeping the military-industrial-corporate-prison complex going.
 

Copernicus

Industrial Strength Linguist
No, if he were an actual Fascist, he'd care more about the environment, want the government to have the ultimate say over the private sector, set up state controlled labor unions (which is what Fascist corporatism is), wouldn't have been a draft dodger, have public works programs, would promote high brow art and culture, stop sending our money and weaponry to other countries, etc. I'd honestly like him more. Lol. People just like using it as an insult, like "communist" or "socialist". Both the modern Democrats and the Republicans have general authoritarian leanings these days, and both are agents of the Empire, keeping the military-industrial-corporate-prison complex going.

I have no idea why you associate fascism with environmentalism, but JD Vance did say back in May that one could call the US a "fascist state". Maybe that's what he was thinking of--a country with environmental, safety, and public welfare regulations. Most Americans define it more closely to Trump's former Chief of Staff John Kelly's description:

Kelly pointed The New York Times to a definition of fascism: “It’s a far-right authoritarian, ultranationalist political ideology and movement characterized by a dictatorial leader, centralized autocracy, militarism, forcible suppression of opposition, belief in a natural social hierarchy.”​
“So certainly, in my experience, those are the kinds of things that he thinks would work better in terms of running America,” Kelly said.​
Kelly added that Trump is in the “far-right area,” and “admires people who are dictators,” which in Kelly’s view places Trump in “the general definition of fascist.”​
Source:

People are calling Trump a fascist. What does that mean?

 
Top