Mohammad Nur Syamsu
Well-Known Member
According to you Mozart, Hitler and Stalin's "souls" had "free will" and "chose" to do what they did. What do you think a hypothetical person without a "soul" would have chosen? Would he have a free will and be capable of choosing anything or would he just be a vegetable?
As mentioned about 12 times to you, it is a matter of opinion what the agency of the decision is. It means we just see the facts of decisions being made, but don't and can't see what it is that makes the decisions turn out the way they do.
You fail to comprehend not matter how many times it is explained to you, the the conclusion the soul does not exist, is just as valid as the conclusion it does exist, same as that the paiting is beautiful or ugly are equally valid opinions.
It's a matter of logic. The concept of choosing does not function when the agency of the decision is regarded as fact.
Last edited: