rape justice?

[Titanic]

What about him?

Would you not have wished rape on him instead of just the Death Penalty?

 

[Curious George]

None of his tax dollars should go to help people who screwed up; rather, they should go to helping an already disabled reform system get back on its feet.

Security in prisons is not reform.


Raping is not reform.

but some would argue that prison is not nor should it be a "reform" system.

Incidentally I agree that rape is not reform, however I believe my friend was suggesting it as a additional punishment.

Both views espouse retributivist perspectives.

 

[Aquitaine]

but some would argue that prison is not nor should it be a "reform" system.

Incidentally I agree that rape is not reform, however I believe my friend was suggesting it as a additional punishment.

Both views espouse retributivist perspectives.

Then let's hope your friend never gets arrested for failing to send off is tax in-time, or smoking Marajuana etc. I wonder if he thinks being raped in prison will help him be a better citizen upon leaving?

 

[DallasApple]

It would also be saying ANYONE who has ever done an illegal drug lets say 3 or even 4 times but didn't get caught in actuality deserves to get raped.Not just lose your freedom but be raped . Well you screwed up so BEND OVER!

 

[Curious George]

Then let's hope your friend never gets arrested for failing to send off is tax in-time, or smoking Marajuana etc. I wonder if he thinks being raped in prison will help him be a better citizen upon leaving?

SHE was speaking only about rapists, and child rapists. She also suggested castration via butter knife sans anesthesia, but I figured prison rape was the funner of the two.

Cheers.

 

[Titanic]

SHE was speaking only about rapists, and child rapists. She also suggested castration via butter knife sans anesthesia, but I figured prison rape was the funner of the two.

Cheers.

They could have done that to Ted Bundy before they executed him but that was a long time ago so I guess its irrelevant...

 

[DallasApple]

Report Finds "Deliberate Indifference" to Prison Rape Epidemic | Alternet

 

[Aquitaine]

SHE was speaking only about rapists, and child rapists. She also suggested castration via butter knife sans anesthesia, but I figured prison rape was the funner of the two.

Cheers.

Y' see in my opinion the problem with stuff like that (leaving out the ethical aspects) is that people falsely accused of rape/pedophilia will face the abuse.

"Do this or I'll say you raped me, and you know what they'll do to you in prison."

Out of curiosity, when she advocated the used of butter knives for Neutering, did she explain how exactly they'd be able to use said knives to spay the female prisoner..... or did she just assume all Rapists are Men?

 

[DallasApple]

Um speaking of rapist are all men? No they aren't but this link states that more rapes occur to men in prison every year (that would have to be by mostly other men right?) than women are raped every year in the u.s outside of prison.

Prison Rape: A Silent Epidemic | PSJ

 

[HiddenDjinn]

They could have done that to Ted Bundy before they executed him but that was a long time ago so I guess its irrelevant...

To what end? Wasn't death enough?

 

[MysticSang'ha]

Would you not have wished rape on him instead of just the Death Penalty?

No. I don't think torture is justifiable.

 

[Titanic]

No. I don't think torture is justifiable.

Even for his particular case? He was a real strange case that guy.

 

[Titanic]

To what end? Wasn't death enough?

Well they could of at least raped him once before they executed him. Please remember this guy raped and tortured women. Then killed them and then done things with there bodies afterwards. A evil guy.

 

[HiddenDjinn]

Well they could of at least raped him once before they executed him. Please remember this guy raped and tortured women. Then killed them and then done things with there bodies afterwards. A evil guy.

Revenge like that will come at the cost of righteousness of our system. Not that I believe our system righteous, but why would we consciously deprive our penal system of what legitimacy it has left?

 

[Titanic]

Revenge like that will come at the cost of righteousness of our system. Not that I believe our system righteous, but why would we consciously deprive our penal system of what legitimacy it has left?

So you believe the electric chair was justice enough?

 

[HiddenDjinn]

So you believe the electric chair was justice enough?

I think it was over the top. Life, no parole, in punitive isolation, would have been sufficient.

 

[Titanic]

I think it was over the top. Life, no parole, in punitive isolation, would have been sufficient.

For Ted Bundy?

 

[dawny0826]

while speaking with friends we began talking about prison reform. Several comments were made by my friends.

The first was questioning why more of his tax dollars should go to help people who have screwed up. He was not saying he should pay less taxes but felt that enough is already spent on prisons and were any extra security measures put in place the funding would need to come from the existing funds.

Another friend believed that child rapists especially should be subject to a regular raping by fellow inmates.

Your thoughts?

Inprisonment should, in my opinion should serve as punishment and a means for rehabilitation, unless of course, penalty does not allow for the person to integrate back into society.

Humanitarian treatment should be mandatory, while individuals are imprisoned.

 

[HiddenDjinn]

For Ted Bundy?

Was I, in any way, unclear?

 

[Alceste]

So you believe the electric chair was justice enough?

If you think torture is OK, why does it bother you what Bundy did?