I am not buying the article to check there work.
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Risks of harm from spanking confirmed by analysis of 5 decades of research
- Thread starter Sunstone
- Start date
I am not buying the article to check there work.
It's free, PDF link on the right hand side. The study is there, you are simply not going to put in the effort because it might suggest you are incorrect in your thinking.
I want to see the results of there study not an opinion piece on the study.
I have linked it twice, shall I link it again?
Its not free for me they want $11.95
Here you are, a direct link to the pdf. Try this.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycarticles/2016-17153-001.pdf
Then pay the $12 and gain access to the journal the study was published in.
To read what I already know it flawed thanks but I'll pass and leave the thread to its opinion.
You already know it's flawed because you're a fair-minded, rational, reasonable person? Or is there some other reason you already know it's flawed without actually reading it?
Seriously, can no one else see the PDF? Or is there some paywall I magically got behind?
Are you on a college or university wifi? I can't see the free PDF either.
A Vestigial Mote
Well-Known Member
This needs further investigations into the types of parents who routinely turn to spanking vs. other forms of punishment, and also the degree to which the child is physically caused discomfort or pain in the instances where it has been found to be most detrimental. My thoughts on this are that there is probably a strong correlation between parents who spank harder or more often and parents who tend to be hands-off with the kids' developmental needs - either not playing with them, ignoring them often, showing disdain more than any other emotional response toward their children, etc. Meaning that parents who are all too willing to harm their child in the act of spanking, or turn to it as the preferred/default punishment method probably don't really show their kids all that much actual, heartfelt "love" either. And I wonder which of those two things is more detrimental to the outcome? Spanking or less than stellar love?
A problem is that we don't have access to those statistics without investing $13 & much time.
Perhaps someone who has done so can enlighten us, eh?
Looking at the free summaries, I see some questions.....
1) Is age a factor? I can see a possibility that a light spank on a 2 year old would be OK, but not on a 3 year old.
2) One summary mentions debate between researchers & the public. Does this mean researchers don't all agree, or only that the public disagrees?
3) Are there critiques of the study by those in the field?
4) Your question here.... _____________________________________
That worked! Thanks so much!
This looks like one of those late nite reads.
Have you yet?
It is riveting! Edge of your seat writing for sure!
Right now, I am going through their tables and analysis of the various studies that have been done in the past.
Right now, I am watching a TV show about guys who are wrecking the cars they're supposed to be testing.
(You high brow intellectual types are so intimidating!)
I am still waiting for Junkyard Wars to come back on TV...