• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

SCOTUS Overturns Bump Stock Ban

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
OK for the sake of argument (and because I'm too lazy to look it up) let's say 400 rounds per minute. PER MINUTE. I doubt that would melt many barrels any time soon, and I'd bet the person shooting it would know if it would.
I haven't heard of any barrels actually melting down lol. but it does do quite extensive damage to the rifling necessitating barrel changes after prolonged fire.
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
The gun does NOT fire a second round until AFTER the trigger is reset and pulled again.
That is why it is called a semi-automatic.
The firearm itself has to have the trigger pulled then reset before another round can be fired.
A bump stock simply uses the recoil of the weapon to force your finger forward to reset the trigger .

An automatic does not require the trigger to be reset between rounds being fired.

The end result is the same, i agree.
Two questions.

If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on a factory semi-automatic rifle how many shots fire?

If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on the same gun modified with a bump stock will the gun fire the same number of rounds?
 

Pogo

Well-Known Member
You want a fire rate high like that?

That would require a belt fed mag like a good vintage Pig has or a SAW. Probably a spare barrel as well.

Wanna know how fast it will be before a 10 round clip or even a 32 round clip empties with a fire rate of 400-800 RPM?

We both know the RPM is pure sensationalist banter when contrasting its real world limitations.
I can do the math, that is not the point, without the modification, you can't fire anywhere near 13 rounds per second even if the mechanism can in the real world. The proscription of the law was to keep weapons with this fire rate out of non-military hands.
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
Huh?

the fact of the matter is that until there is a magazine that holds 800 round you are not going to get 800 rounds a minute.
It is physically not going to happen.
There are many aftermarket clips that hold many dozens of rounds.

Nevermind the fact that the heat would melt the barrel.
Probably not a big concern for someone shooting up a school. Or concert. Or parade. Or sports event.
 

Pogo

Well-Known Member
Huh?

the fact of the matter is that until there is a magazine that holds 800 round you are not going to get 800 rounds a minute.
It is physically not going to happen.

Nevermind the fact that the heat would melt the barrel.
Does the nurse hold her finger on your wrist for a whole minute to tell you your heart rate in beats per minute?
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
There's going to be blood on their hands when terrorists and lunatics use them for mass murder.
 

McBell

Unbound
Two questions.

If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on a factory semi-automatic rifle how many shots fire?
one.
If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on the same gun modified with a bump stock will the gun fire the same number of rounds?
it will still only fire one round per trigger pull.

The bump stock will bump your finger forward, resetting the trigger so that you do not have to let off pressure before pulling the trigger again.
So it basically assists you in pulling the trigger faster.

So yes, it will increase the fire rate.
 

McBell

Unbound
OK for the sake of argument (and because I'm too lazy to look it up) let's say 400 rounds per minute. PER MINUTE. I doubt that would melt many barrels any time soon, and I'd bet the person shooting it would know if it would.
Firing 400 rounds from an AR-15 in one minute will create enough heat to melt the barrel.
By melt the barrel, I mean the heat created will soften the barrel to the point of being soft enough to stop a round from going through it.
Then you will have 400 round a minute piling up in the barrel.
What do you think will happen at that point?
 

Pogo

Well-Known Member
Two questions.

If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on a factory semi-automatic rifle how many shots fire?

If you pull the trigger and hold it for 15 seconds on the same gun modified with a bump stock will the gun fire the same number of rounds?
We are playing silly buggers with the definition of hold. Is it relative to the trigger or the finger stop on the bump stock.
Much of the progress in this century has been SCOTUS interpreting the spirit of the enlightenment era founders.

Reminds me of my HS history teacher who said in Berkeley that he was a conservative by which he meant an 18th century liberal.
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
one.

it will still only fire one round per trigger pull.
This doesn’t answer the questions.

The bump stock will bump your finger forward, resetting the trigger so that you do not have to let off pressure before pulling the trigger again.
So it basically assists you in pulling the trigger faster.

So yes, it will increase the fire rate.
Yes, it’s the bump stop that pulls the hand and finger, and the finger is held with constant pressure, which fore’s automatically until pressure is lifted.
 

Soandso

ᛋᛏᚨᚾᛞ ᛋᚢᚱᛖ
The topic of bump stocks came up in my friend group in discord and someone posted this video. I thought it was interesting


Not sure how I feel about them, personally. Seems like a cool toy, but I feel like after using a bump stock at the shooting range a couple times I'd get bored and just switch back to a more stable stock. I care more about bullet groupings than watching my money evaporate in seconds with how expensive ammunition is
 

McBell

Unbound
This doesn’t answer the questions.


Yes, it’s the bump stop that pulls the hand and finger, and the finger is held with constant pressure, which fore’s automatically until pressure is lifted.
That a bump stock makes a semi-automatic as effective (or ineffective depending on the PoV) as an automatic is not in dispute.
The fact still remains that a semi-automatic has to have the trigger reset between shots fired.
An automatic does not.
that is the difference between the two.

Now if you are merely gong to continue with the same defeated argument, i am out.
 

Kathryn

It was on fire when I laid down on it.
Firing 400 rounds from an AR-15 in one minute will create enough heat to melt the barrel.
By melt the barrel, I mean the heat created will soften the barrel to the point of being soft enough to stop a round from going through it.
Then you will have 400 round a minute piling up in the barrel.
What do you think will happen at that point?

Who needs that sort of fire power to begin with? Plus you are just talking about one type of rifle.
 

Pogo

Well-Known Member
one.

it will still only fire one round per trigger pull.

The bump stock will bump your finger forward, resetting the trigger so that you do not have to let off pressure before pulling the trigger again.
So it basically assists you in pulling the trigger faster.

So yes, it will increase the fire rate.
Or the gun will compress pad on the stock and your finger will remain stationary and the trigger will then trip the firing mechanism on it's return. So it is not a tr

The bump stock works when the shooter holds the pistol grip with one hand and the barrel of the gun with the other. A support step holds a person's finger in place when the gun is fired. A spring mechanism in a bump stock causes the rifle to bounce forward with every shot.

Either way the ruling is in contravention of the spirit of the law that was passed.
 

Subduction Zone

Veteran Member
My finger twitch can do it as well. Hence semi automatic.

Of course you being military as well knows full well what can change an AR 15 into an M16.

We both know it's not the stock.

I sincerely doubt if you can match the speed that a bump stock can give. And you miss the point, even if you can o that the bump stock makes it so that almost anyone can fire a rifle at speeds that are at least at old "Tommy Gun" levels. They may not be as fast as a modern day automatic rifle but they are more than fast enough.

It really does not appear to do what you claim at all. I have never seen anyone use it for that purpose. I have only seen it used to make a rifle close to being "automatic".
 

Wandering Monk

Well-Known Member
I already posted one video that refutes this claim. Here is another one


The man is an experienced shooter and he gets off his rounds very quickly at 2:00 in the video. At about 4:10 you seem the same gun fitted with a bump stock and the rate is much faster and he admits that he was not ready for that speed.
I watched another video where they measured the time it took to empty a 40 round magazine using a bump stock. The cyclic rate of fire on the first clip was 864 per minute. The second clip was 750 per minute.

This is the same rate of fire as a full auto M16.

The M16 rifle has a rate of fire of 700–950 rounds per minute when firing fully automatic. It uses 5.56-mm (.223-caliber) ammunition and has a muzzle velocity of over 900 meters per second.
 
Last edited:
Top