• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The Goddess of the Wheel scenario

What is your choice given the GOTW scenario?

  • Door 1 - to Earth, the Universe and reincarnation

    Votes: 9 50.0%
  • Door 2 - to Heaven, and the chance of eternal bliss

    Votes: 1 5.6%
  • Door 3 - to Hell, and the glory of being the mightiest

    Votes: 1 5.6%
  • Option Four - the mysterious fate unkown to you

    Votes: 7 38.9%

  • Total voters
    18

Random

Well-Known Member
OK, the day comes for you to die. You die. After a brief spell of oblivion/non-consciousness whilst your psyche reconfigures, you are immensely surprised to find your soul-self in a spacious room where a rather charismatically attractive woman awaits you. There are three doors out of the room. After an exchange of pleasantries, the woman explains that you're physically dead and clears up confusions about what just happened to your spirit.

The woman tells you that you've got some serious Karma left to work off and you're going to be taking a new form (Reincarnating), but if you're interested she's got some jobs for you to do back on Earth. You feel pride and a sense of endowment at the thought of having this kind of purpose, and wonder what she wants you to do. But...

You're looking towards the plain doors, and wondering what the other options are.

She tells you that the door directly opposite leads back to Earth, the Universe and a new body. The other two lead to different places; one to Heaven of spiritual bliss and perpetual happiness, where you'll be tested and if you're worthy you'll be allowed to enter and stay for as long as you like, but if you're not worthy your soul will be deleted from Creation altogether -- and the other to Hell, where despite reports to the contrary you might actually enjoy it, because there it's all about physicaly immortality, sex, violence, pleasures of the senses and endless self-gratification, but you won't always be happy and there is ultimately no meaning to any of it.

You ask about a fourth option: she says there is one, but she can't tell you about that until, or if, you choose it. There is no fifth option.

You now have a quandry. You wonder about the woman, and various speculative thoughts spring to mind: could she be God? Or maybe the Devil? Or an Angel/Demon in disguise? Or perhaps some weird mind-program or creation of your own psyche? You don't know.

But you must choose. Door 1 back to Earth with a purpose, Door 2 to Heaven and the chance of eternal bliss, Door 3 to Hell and lots of action and excitement - or the as yet undefined mystery Fourth Option.

What is your choice going to be? Poll incl.

Please discuss and feel free to comment according to whatever comes to mind, also.
 

Halcyon

Lord of the Badgers
Cool thread Connor, frubals.

I'd choose door number 4 and hope for Oblivion, but if I'm denied that at least it'll be something utterly unknown, which is also cool.
 

Phasmid

Mr Invisible
Door 2. It's the only one without any chance of pain. And if I get "deleted" then it's not as if I'll be around to complain about it.

What happens if you decide you want to stay in the room with the attractive woman?
 

Nessa Nenharma

Goddess of my Domain
I chose Door 1, back to Earth for me. I can't see where going back means implied pain, you might not come back as a human ;).
 

Mike182

Flaming Queer
i'd take my chances with reincarnation, i still have a lot to learn from life, and certainly a lot more to enjoy from it.
 

3.14

Well-Known Member
earth = been there done that
heaven = eternal bliss is boring as hell
hell = senceless sinning would be fun for 800 years or so but not for forever (unless the attractive woman partakes the maby 900 years)
so all that is left is to take a chance, got 4 shots
1 my existance might be deleted
2 my existance might improve
3 my existance might get worse
4 my existance will stay the same
 

Willamena

Just me
Premium Member
Hell, I'd pick Door #1. That's not to say I picked Hell, but it is too; since Heaven and Hell are included in the Earth package, you're really getting 3 doors for the price of one.

(PS, arguably 4 doors for the price of one, since no matter what, my "fate is unknown to me.")
 

Hema

Sweet n Spicy
Option 1 - because it is more congruent with my beliefs. The second option has a catch that my soul can be destroyed...in my beliefs, all souls will merge with God eventually. :) As for the third option, I don't beleive in a permanent hell, but temporary hellish regions, where souls go if that is what they deserve. As for Option four, I don't think we can gamble with our destiny like that...we are given a body best suited to whatever purpose we need to fulfill. :)
 

Hema

Sweet n Spicy
ye but what will happen next time you die and she asks you the same thing?

Well as long as we have residual karma we will reincarnate but if we have offset all our negative karma, we will merge with God. :)
 

gnostic

The Lost One
I don't want heaven and hell. One lifetime on earth is enough for me, so I don't want to be recycled.

I would prefer complete deletion of the soul.

Is that option 4? Because that would be my choice - no soul and no afterlife.
 

Willamena

Just me
Premium Member
I don't want heaven and hell. One lifetime on earth is enough for me, so I don't want to be recycled.

I would prefer complete deletion of the soul.

Is that option 4? Because that would be my choice - no soul and no afterlife.
No offense, but that says a lot about what "you" are.
 

Ozzie

Well-Known Member
Cool thread Connor, frubals.

I'd choose door number 4 and hope for Oblivion, but if I'm denied that at least it'll be something utterly unknown, which is also cool.
Door 4 seems the most attactive since it might promise something other than oblivion. All others lead to it.

Ever noticed the infinite regress promised by eternal return?
 
Top