Akivah
Well-Known Member
Whenever I've tried to think about God as all loving or just a God guy/gal I find it rather difficult. The biggest problem with someone being omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent is that it makes it impossible for said being to escape blame for literally everything.
But He also gets credit for everything. I've noticed on these old "problem of evil" threads, the poster tends to ignore all the good that G-d does.
Also, G-d has no responsibility for our own choices, that's on us.
IMO, good/evil don't really apply to G-d, He just does. Good & evil is for humans.
Any wrong doing was allowed by God to happen but not only that, it was more or less programed to happen.
The old argument of knowledge vs. control, again. Does knowing the creation's choices equal controlling the creation's choices? For me, the answer is no.
If God is the creator of man then he has more or less programed every negative aspect of ourselves into our heads. The inclination towards violence and tribalism? You can thank God for that. The sexual urges of pedophiles and rapists? You can thank God for that. Hatred? The list goes on and on.
And the positive ones, too. Love, admiration, charity, restraint, etc. Actually all the urges that G-d created us with are not absolutely good or evil. It is how we humans use them that determines that.
In Judaism, we say that humans are good with a prediction for evil.
The concept of sin is more or less God getting upset with you for things he set you up to do. It's a little ridiculous honestly.
I wouldn't say that G-d gets upset, more disappointed. The concept of sin gives us the opportunity to choose better. We couldn't learn and grow if we didn't have the opportunity to make mistakes.