• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

US Government Shutdown

Monk Of Reason

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ
Can't believe there isn't a thread for this. It may be the most important political event of the year. Its not got its own thread? I am ashamed RF.


Basic questions.

Who is to blame? Democrats in General? Obama specifically? Republicans in General? Tea party members in General? John Boehner specifically? Both? None?

What bills proposed have the best answers for America?

Is this really all about Obamacare or another agenda?
 

Dirty Penguin

Master Of Ceremony
Can't believe there isn't a thread for this. It may be the most important political event of the year. Its not got its own thread? I am ashamed RF.


Basic questions.

Who is to blame? Democrats in General? Obama specifically? Republicans in General? Tea party members in General? John Boehner specifically? Both? None?

What bills proposed have the best answers for America?

Is this really all about Obamacare or another agenda?


There are a couple "healthcare" threads going on where this is being talked about.

Back in March/April this year Democrats submitted their budget. Republicans had already submitted their budget. The Republican budget was Austerity on steroids known as the (Paul Ryan Budget). Mr. Ryan and Romney reintroduced elements of that budget in the election campaign. The results of the election clearly show that a majority of the people/electorate rejected it and them.

Back to the Democrat budget. Patty Murray and other Democrats in the Senate, after submitting their budget, requested in the Senate to go to "conference". This is where they do budget reconciliation. They take the Ryan Budget and the Democrat Budget and they compromise to find a middle ground for a long term budget solution.

Well....Republicans in the Senate blocked any attempt to reconcile the budgets 18 times. Basically they filibustered any attempts to go to conference. To make matters worse Democrats in the Senate and in the House requested John Boehner to appoint conferees so that they could reconcile the budgets. He refused to do it. So now you have the Senate blocking Democrats 18 times to go to conference as well as John Boehner denying request to appoint conferees. So both sides had a budget. Democrats had their negotiators but not the Republicans and it was the Republicans blocking and denying the opportunity to compromise on a long term budget solution. It's worth noting that John McCain, in the Senate, Requested 10 times for the tea party obstructionist, to stop blocking Democrats and to go to conference.

So that was 6 months ago. Since Congress is fond of taking time off (weeks of time off)...not much of anything got done. So fast forward six months and here we are. They need to pass a "Continuing Resolution" (a budget extension) to fund the govt. A "Clean CR" was sent to the House. A Clean CR is a request to fund the govt. with no other riders, pet project funding or any other type of pork barrel spending. It's worth noting that the amount in the CR came from the Republicans. Democrats agreed with the republican CR amount which is based on Sequestration level spending. The Democrat number was higher by $70 or $80 Billion but they compromised with Republicans and went with their lower CR Budget number. So Democrats don't want anything on the CR (a Clean CR). They want to fund the govt. for a few weeks, for Boehner and others along with their votes to raise the Debt. Ceiling without caveats...but to save the budget requesting for the time period during the CR extension to work on a long term budget.

Now, the CR was sent back to the Senate with a provision to Defund the ACA. As you know this went on and on. Republicans wanted a rider on the CR to "Defund" the ACA then when they couldn't get that they want a rider to "Delay" the ACA for a year. They explicitly said they wanted to delay it in the hopes of winning the Senate so that they could control both houses and then kill the law. So even if the President vetoed them they would have enough votes to override him if they controlled both houses. It's worth noting that the ACA is (mandatory spending) and has nothing to do with the CR.

So here we are. Republicans are content on keeping the government shutdown and blaming it on Democrats while stalling to open the govt. They're trying to piece meal opening the govt. branch by branch...dept. by dept. but trying to hold off because of the looming Debt Ceiling where they feel as though they can extract more concessions in exchange for opening the government and raising the Debt Ceiling......:sad:
 
Last edited:

Slapstick

Active Member
Can't believe there isn't a thread for this. It may be the most important political event of the year. Its not got its own thread? I am ashamed RF.


Basic questions.

Who is to blame? Democrats in General? Obama specifically? Republicans in General? Tea party members in General? John Boehner specifically? Both? None?

What bills proposed have the best answers for America?

Is this really all about Obamacare or another agenda?
The Government could shut down for the rest of the year and capitalism will still be around.

I don’t think any political party is to blame, just the idiots that are currently in charge of running it.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
It's not like the first shutdown. Theres been around 17 already since the mid to late seventies instigated by both parties. Nothing new which is probably why there is no real interest over it.
 

Dirty Penguin

Master Of Ceremony
The Government could shut down for the rest of the year and capitalism will still be around.


The govt. being shutdown affects capitalism on various levels in this country. Closing down govt. for a whole year is expensive and detrimental to our national and global economy.
 

Slapstick

Active Member
The govt. being shutdown affects capitalism on various levels in this country. Closing down govt. for a whole year is expensive and detrimental to our national and global economy.
Not really. Capitalism is what keeps this country running not the government. Although when it comes to public education a lot of kids would be out of luck.
 

Monk Of Reason

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ
Not really. Capitalism is what keeps this country running not the government. Although when it comes to public education a lot of kids would be out of luck.

Capitalism as a concept it doesn't affect. However government is an important system in our capitalistic society today. Having major disruptions there also leads to disruptions and lack of confidence in the market.
 

Slapstick

Active Member
Capitalism as a concept it doesn't affect. However government is an important system in our capitalistic society today. Having major disruptions there also leads to disruptions and lack of confidence in the market.
Well, the government isn't suppose to have any sway, power or influence over the market other than providing a level playing field where there isn't one. I think it has become apparent that our government has overstepped its boundaries.

As in, its putting its nose where it doesn't belong.
 

Monk Of Reason

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ
Well, the government isn't suppose to have any sway, power or influence over the market other than providing a level playing field where there isn't one.
Why?
I think it has become apparent that our government has overstepped its boundaries.

As in, its putting its nose where it doesn't belong.
Only if you assume the above premise is correct. It sounds far more opinion than fact. Regulation is a natural and necessary action by the government especially in capitalistic nations.
 

Slapstick

Active Member
Go back to college and find out.
Only if you assume the above premise is correct. It sounds far more opinion than fact. Regulation is a natural and necessary action by the government especially in capitalistic nations.
Again, look at the current state of our governing body. It has nothing to do regulation. Our government can't regulate itself much less anything else.
 

Monk Of Reason

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ
Go back to college and find out.
College grad and majored in Economics and Accounting. Please construct your arugment why government should innately have nothing to do with the economy.
Again, look at the current state of our governing body. It has nothing to do regulation. Our government can't regulate itself much less anything else.

It has everything to do with regulation. It doesn't interact with the economy in any other way than regulation. The whole argument being made by those who want to cut back on governent is to minimize regulation.

I agree our government is in a ****** state and I don't in any way defend it. But I think it requires support for the idea of your claim that if a government shutdown affects the market it means that government has gone to far.
 

Reverend Rick

Frubal Whore
Premium Member
I find it amuzing that we call this a government shutdown in the first place. The government is not shut down it just has to pay as it goes. Actually I believe the government being forced to make hard choices is a good thing.

The government is too big and needs to live within its means.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
I find it amuzing that we call this a government shutdown in the first place. The government is not shut down it just has to pay as it goes. Actually I believe the government being forced to make hard choices is a good thing.
The government is too big and needs to live within its means.
Locally, we saw the Gerald Ford Library closed. It seems one of the many examples of things we
needn't fund at all, especially in bad times. For researchers who want access, let them pay for it.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
The govt. being shutdown affects capitalism on various levels in this country. Closing down govt. for a whole year is expensive and detrimental to our national and global economy.
I thought it worth pointing out that I agree with you here.
 

Reverend Rick

Frubal Whore
Premium Member
The same thing for medicare, rebuilding people so they can collect a check longer when the funds are just not there seems wrong to me.

One generation drives a cadillac while the next generation walks when both generations could have had a toyota.
 

Knight of Albion

Well-Known Member
The Republicans lost the election. Obama won fair and square. They (the Republicans) should accept the result - that's democracy - and stop obstructing the course of governance.
 

Knight of Albion

Well-Known Member
We Brits just don't 'get' the fuss about "Obamacare". Isn't the gist of it that the poor and disadvantaged in American society will be helped with healthcare? Sure, some will pay more to cover those in need, but come on, common humanity....
 

Reverend Rick

Frubal Whore
Premium Member
I guess it boils down to if you believe we have a right to have our every complaint looked at by a very expensive system no matter what our finances look like.

Right now in our country, no one with a life threatening condition is turned away. Poor folks get a healthcare plan called medicaid. Old folks get medicare.

Many working folks get insurance.

Why not just spend a trillion dollars and open up a medical facility for people with pre-existing conditions as a not for profit?
 

Treks

Well-Known Member
Yeah I don't get it either KoA...

I wonder how the librarians will pay their rent?
 
Top