• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Vegetarianism. How do you look at it ?

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
Interesting fact: I've heard similar argument is made for calcium. There's a passage from, I think, Walden, where Thoreau recalls a conversation with a neighbor about vegetarianism. The neighbor maintained that such a diet would furnish little to make bones -- all the while toiling behind his ox who, with vegetable-made bones, slowly pulled his plow along. This was nearly 200 years ago.
Well...
I tried one month without drinking milk...I felt very weak. Just reckon I am a post-SRS person.
And btw...I think that not all people are the same. Many people have a shortage of iron due to thalassemia..so meat can be useful.
 

Terrywoodenpic

Oldest Heretic
I am very fond of vegetables, and my Diet is dominated by them. though I do also eat meat and animal products.
Many people seem to major on meat and potatoes, and use vegetables as a garnish.
My plate usually looks the other way round, with mostly vegetables and a little meat, fish, cheese or egg.
Sometime I will eat a fully vegetarian meal as a choice, but I am not in the least a vegetarian.
I eat more fruit than my daughters family do, between them all.

It is natural for the the food chain to consist of animals that are carnivores and for some to be herbivorous. Both Plants and animals exist by living on each other or their remains. Even plants thrive on the nutrients suppled by the animal kingdom.

Humans are by nature omnivores, but can survive perfectly well and healthily on a balanced vegetarian or vegan diet.
Many westerners version of a vegetarian diet is unbalanced, as they have neither the knowledge nor tradition necessary to balance the various essentials. The result can be as unhealthy as a fast food protein diet.
 

A Vestigial Mote

Well-Known Member
I've seen those sources, too, but they leave out a lot, and get a lot wrong.
The points you've raised make sense, though I still see there being quite a difference between micro-organisms breaking down animal food sources (and waste products produced), and those breaking down food sourced from vegetation. We even craft to purposefully ingest broken down vegetation and bacterial waste (alcohol for example), and yet I can't think of a single corollary for meat broken down similarly. Dairy perhaps - in the form of a great many cheeses or sour cream. But meat? It's one of the main contaminants we're told to watch out for before consumption, and for good reason.

There's also something to be said for the extra energy it takes to break down plant cells to extract nutrients in today's modern "developed" societies. So many of us are extremely inactive relative to our ancient ancestors. The more your body has to work at processing your food under those conditions as "normal", it is probably for the better.
 

Marcion

gopa of humanity's controversial Taraka Brahma
It is natural for the the food chain to consist of animals that are carnivores and for some to be herbivorous. Both Plants and animals exist by living on each other or their remains. Even plants thrive on the nutrients suppled by the animal kingdom.
So what is stopping you from living the natural way among the lions, hyena's and wildebeasts in your self woven loin cloth and with just a self-carved wooden spear for hunting in the savannah?
 
So what is stopping you from living the natural way among the lions, hyena's and wildebeasts in your self woven loin cloth and with just a self-carved wooden spear for hunting in the savannah?

We are, we just got better and more efficient at capturing, containing, reproducing, killing, harvesting food. So the loin cloth became the full blown underwear, the spears turned to metal devices that shoot the animal in the head or something and also the walls and fences and all that.
 

Marcion

gopa of humanity's controversial Taraka Brahma
We are, we just got better and more efficient at capturing, containing, reproducing, killing, harvesting food. So the loin cloth became the full blown underwear, the spears turned to metal devices that shoot the animal in the head or something and also the walls and fences and all that.
Sadly we did not get better at it but we spoilt the climate and the balance in nature and now we and the rest of creation have to pay a terrible price for that huge mistake.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Oh, certainly you can get your protein needs met from dairy products. You have no idea how much milk I drink.
You don't even need eggs or dairy.
Plants have protein. There is more protein in a Calorie of broccoli than in a Kilo of beef, for example.

3,000 calories -- average male daily food intake: Broccoli: 336 gm. Beef: 276 gm. Recommended minimum: (WHO) 37 gm.
Unless you're eating a diet of 100% gummi-bears, failing to get adequate protein is well-nigh impossible.

Amino-acid balance is also important, though. The best balance for a given organism would be achieved by eating that organism. Ridiculous, of course. the next best would be similar organisms, but this isn't necessary. A shortage of one amino acid is easily made up for with other foods.

See Chart:
https://www.hypnosishealthinfo.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/Amino-Acids-Chart2.jpg
 
Last edited:

Terrywoodenpic

Oldest Heretic
So what is stopping you from living the natural way among the lions, hyena's and wildebeasts in your self woven loin cloth and with just a self-carved wooden spear for hunting in the savannah?

Not that keen on becoming part of that food chain yet.
but after I am dead they are welcome.
However I expect to end up under the same Oak tree as my late wife over looking a reservoir.

The main problem is that there are too many Humans...
we are out of balance with the environment.
 

stvdv

Veteran Member
Plants have protein. There is more protein in a kilo of broccoli than in a Kilo of beef, for example.
This line is of course not correct. Should be "There is more protein/kcal in broccoli than in beef"
 
Last edited:

Hellbound Serpiente

Active Member
Oh hey, guys, also found one another video I once saw. Chicken chicks are a''holes too, just like I pointed out earlier. Here's another video of even their chicks bullying the weaker one.

 

Stevicus

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
160305-vegetarians-kill.png
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
The points you've raised make sense, though I still see there being quite a difference between micro-organisms breaking down animal food sources (and waste products produced), and those breaking down food sourced from vegetation. We even craft to purposefully ingest broken down vegetation and bacterial waste (alcohol for example), and yet I can't think of a single corollary for meat broken down similarly. Dairy perhaps - in the form of a great many cheeses or sour cream. But meat? It's one of the main contaminants we're told to watch out for before consumption, and for good reason.
Bacteria in herbivores' guts break down the cellulose we can't. It takes time, energy and a lot of guts, but the ratios work. Herbivores survive.
Human's no longer need the long guts, long transit time, bacteria and constant eating. We process our food efficiently, and break the cell walls of plants, externally, by manual food prep and cooking.
Increased Energy/Reduced Digestion
Evolution by Fire
Why cooking counts

Contamination? Yes.You're right. It's dangerous to eat spoiled meat. Meat rots fast. It's cells are so easy to access and digest bacteria begin colonizing it immediately, as well as insects, worms, &al.
Plant cells, on the other hand, are much more difficult to access.
There's also something to be said for the extra energy it takes to break down plant cells to extract nutrients in today's modern "developed" societies. So many of us are extremely inactive relative to our ancient ancestors. The more your body has to work at processing your food under those conditions as "normal", it is probably for the better.
Hence, our epidemic of obesity, and obesity/inactivity related illnesses.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Marcion said:
So what is stopping you from living the natural way among the lions, hyena's and wildebeasts in your self woven loin cloth and with just a self-carved wooden spear for hunting in the savannah?
Overpopulation.
 

stvdv

Veteran Member
You're right. My bad.
Thanks for the correction. I'll fix the post now.
Below are some interesting links IF you want the most accurate (I have found) data on food ingredients

Below I use these abbreviations:
BR=broccoli...c=kcal
ME=meat.......p=protein
GR=Grass


BR100gr=c034.p02.82 --> p/c=0.08294 --> p8.3/c100 = p83/c1000 = p249/c3000
ME100gr=c198.p19.42 --> p/c=0.09808 --> p9.8/c100 = p98/c1000 = p294/c3000
GR100gr=c220.p18.00 --> p/c=0.08181 --> p8.2/c100 = p82/c1000 = p246/c3000

* beef ("Beef, grass-fed, ground, raw") has only a little more protein/kcal than broccoli. Beef lacks potassium, broccoli not
* broccoli has 166 grams of protein per 2000 kcal (daily need). Vegan gives abundant protein
* But you need to eat 16.6 kg broccoli to get 2000 kcal, which is a lot.

But if your diet would be only broccoli you would overdose on protein and potassium, which is not wise. No wonder that cows grow so fat with all that grass-protein:D they eat, and hence cow:cow: milk has so much more (4 times) protein than mother milk.
@stvdvRF
 
Last edited:
Top