• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What are the chances?

MikeF

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
The elephant metaphor is about all having pieces which are correct but not the entire picture which is beyond their grasp (being blind)

The problem with this metaphor in relation to religious beliefs is that the assumption is always that there is some external truth that is being sensed in different ways. What if it is not an external truth, but an inherent characteristic of human beings themselves? What if it is human need and desire that drives the creation of the religious? What if that is the shared truth by all?
 

Skywalker

Well-Known Member
The problem with this metaphor in relation to religious beliefs is that the assumption is always that there is some external truth that is being sensed in different ways. What if it is not an external truth, but an inherent characteristic of human beings themselves? What if it is human need and desire that drives the creation of the religious? What if that is the shared truth by all?

I believe that having a relationship with God exists because we all know that God exists and that he wants a relationship with us, and religious rituals exist because people turn away from God's clear revelation to make other gods for themselves.
 

MikeF

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
I believe that having a relationship with God exists because we all know that God exists and that he wants a relationship with us, and religious rituals exist because people turn away from God's clear revelation to make other gods for themselves.

That's great. All I am saying is that there are incongruities and conflicts in religious beliefs and the pat answer that they are all different parts of the same truth in no way addresses or resolves those conflicts. If you can overlook the conflicts, then great. I prefer to sort out the real from the imaginary.
 

thomas t

non-denominational Christian
If Christianity is right, 5,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
in my opinion, the numbers are wrong.
In Germany, only 75% percent of the members of the Catholic church believe in God, and only 67% of the Protestants.*
However, according to the Bible there is no Christian who does not believe. Faith is a prerequisite of being a Christian.
And this is only the ones who believe in God. They could be general theists, though.

So, only 61% of the German Catholics and only 58% of the Protestants in Germany actually believe ** that Jesus rose from the dead, which is also a prerequisite of Christian faith. This is at least as I see it.
Some say that you need to repent in order for you to be Christian.
This is what a small minority believes, I think.

In brief, there are much less Christians than the often cited 2.3 billion.

Thomas






* source in German: Umfrage: Viele Christen glauben nicht an Gott
** source in German language: Christen, die nicht an Gott glauben? Neue Umfrage enthüllt Erstaunliches über die Deutschen | Politik
 

Skywalker

Well-Known Member
I don't know. I am an agnostic and don't do theology. If pressed I am a sort of pan-deist. God is the world, because that is all I have access to as a part of the world.

I believe in the existence of the Christian God because He is the God who wants all of his creation saved. A pantheistic or deistic God is impersonal. How could God be the world if God created the world?
 

Skywalker

Well-Known Member
in my opinion, the numbers are wrong.
In Germany, only 75% percent of the members of the Catholic church believe in God, and only 67% of the Protestants.*
However, according to the Bible there is no Christian who does not believe. Faith is a prerequisite of being a Christian.
And this is only the ones who believe in God. They could be general theists, though.

So, only 61% of the German Catholics and only 58% of the Protestants in Germany actually believe ** that Jesus rose from the dead, which is also a prerequisite of Christian faith. This is at least as I see it.
Some say that you need to repent in order for you to be Christian.
This is what a small minority believes, I think.

In brief, there are much less Christians than the often cited 2.3 billion.

Thomas






* source in German: Umfrage: Viele Christen glauben nicht an Gott
** source in German language: Christen, die nicht an Gott glauben? Neue Umfrage enthüllt Erstaunliches über die Deutschen | Politik

Do you think believing Jesus was born of a virgin and was God is a prerequisite to the faith? Some Christians believe that Jesus was the Messiah but isn't God.
 

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
I believe in the existence of the Christian God because He is the God who wants all of his creation saved. A pantheistic or deistic God is impersonal. How could God be the world if God created the world?

I don't know. You are asking for logic and evidence. I don't have that and I don't need it to believe.
 

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
How does it make sense that God created the world, and the world is also logic? It doesn't take any amazing faith to believe that God is real, but it takes a lot of faith to believe in an impersonal God and God being nature.
That is your thinking. I do it differently.
 

sojourner

Annoyingly Progressive Since 2006
Has it occurred to anyone that,

If Christianity is right, 5,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If Islam is right, 5,500,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If Hinduism is right, 6,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If there is no god, 6,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?

Now, out of honesty, I have to admit that if atheism is right, then it's even worse, because 6,500,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong.

What a conundrum!

I wonder why all those people, with all their sincere beliefs, can be so confident that they're right? What are the chances?
Art Wholeflaffer (The Firesign Theatre): “Everything you know is wrong.” And: “There’s a seeker born every minute.”
 

sojourner

Annoyingly Progressive Since 2006
Has it occurred to anyone that,

If Christianity is right, 5,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If Islam is right, 5,500,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If Hinduism is right, 6,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?
If there is no god, 6,000,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong?

Now, out of honesty, I have to admit that if atheism is right, then it's even worse, because 6,500,000,000 humans on this planet are wrong.

What a conundrum!

I wonder why all those people, with all their sincere beliefs, can be so confident that they're right? What are the chances?
What if it’s not about being right, but about being in relationship?
 
Top