• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What convinced you that Evolution is the truth?

TLK Valentine

Read the books that others would burn.
I believe there will never be enough evidence for one that believes evolution is true, until they first deal with the root Belief of every atheists core belief! And that is...there is NO god! so then, No matter what evidence is shown or given that there is intelligent design, there will always be the perception that it is wrong.

Our world view determines our core beliefs.

Ok then - looking at intelligent design, we can see a boatload of flaws in any living thing - the designer may have been intelligent, but not particularly good with details.

Worship that? Be our guest.


To the one who Believes in God, it only makes logical and intelligent sense that with everything man has ever designed and imagined, to list simply a hand full, i.e. phones, vehicles, books, pencils, paper, computers, websites :) etc., that these were infact designed, made by intelligent thought, and not put together by accident or chance, and I challenge anyone to prove me wrong that a car, a book, computers etc., can thru millions, hey how about billions of years of chance can somehow create themselves......

And I challenge you to put two phones, vehicles, books, pencils, papers, computers, websites, etc... in a room together, put some John Coltrane music on, and see if they go about creating themselves.

Perhaps living things are different?


So if these and the thousands of other things we (man) have created (logically speaking) could not come into being by chance, how in the world can anyone (logically speaking) believe that we humans, not to mention all the thousand of other living organisms, came into existence by CHANCE! The mathematical probability for that is so far beyond a number anyone could ever calculate, that is simply does not make sense to believe that. AND all this came into being (according to the evolution Theory, NOT SCIENCE) With no Purpose, no thought for BEING! Because if evolution which is really FAITH BASED is true, we came from nothing and we will all end up being............ NOTHING!

Big numbers scare you. Fair enough.

I am not saying this to insult you Estro, but really would like to know..........IF THAT IS THE CASE, that there is no God who has created and designed us for PURPOSE, where as we have a written account in which he clearly says that he did infact create us, and created us for a reason, WHY please tell me, why would anyone even CARE TO ASK the QUESTION Estro!

I have a written account of a girl named Dorothy Gale whose house got picked up in a tornado and blown clear over the rainbow...WHY please tell me, why would anyone even CARE TO WRITE such a thing?


There is no hope in the belief of evolution, no sense of Purpose, no Future, except a for a few hard decades of existence then death! And our whole existence then ends up becoming NOTHING!

And that idea frightens you. Fair enough.


I don't want to live in that world, and that World View is the reason for so much hopelessness and fear in this world!

Here's the rub - the world does not care what you want, has never cared, and isn't going to start anytime soon.


For God so LOVED the world that he gave his only Begotten Son, that whosoever would BELIEVE IN HIM, would not die (cease to exist) but have Everlasting life!.........What a promise of HOPE!

I remember when I was 16 years old, I made a promise to Marcie McCormack of HOPE... as well as the MOON, STARS, and SUN... if she'd just climb into the back seat with me...

She turned me down - and wisely so. Anyone can make a promise.
 
This assertion is appalling. It is false witness against hundreds of millions of people of faith, including the majority of Christians, who both are theists and accept the scientific evidence for evolution and deep time.

It is a denigration of the faith of many and is an out-and-out lie about them. Shame on you.that someone would first say they believe in God,
 
This assertion is appalling. It is false witness against hundreds of millions of people of faith, including the majority of Christians, who both are theists and accept the scientific evidence for evolution and deep time.

It is a denigration of the faith of many and is an out-and-out lie about them. Shame on you.
I did not connect this to your comment, Can you please help me understand that we and all of life evolved, and yet we believe in God ..Evolution by definition is that life came to being without a Designer, with someone creating us.

Is that your understanding?
 

GardenLady

Active Member
I did not connect this to your comment, Can you please help me understand that we and all of life evolved, and yet we believe in God ..Evolution by definition is that life came to being without a Designer, with someone creating us.

Is that your understanding?
First of all, life coming into being is abiogenesis, not evolution. Evolution is the development of existing life through descent with modification involving mutation and natural selection.

There are MANY people of faith who believe God is who, evolution is how. To claim that those who accept scientific evidence of evolution and the age of the universe do not believe in God is to LIE about hundreds of millions of people of faith.
 

GardenLady

Active Member
To any who would care to read a different view from the belief that one can believe in God and at the same time believe in evolution, then please view the below link.

Nope, I've read enough creationist websites to know that they contain convoluted and dishonest arguments that misrepresent both science and the faith of most Christians.
 

TLK Valentine

Read the books that others would burn.
To any who would care to read a different view from the belief that one can believe in God and at the same time believe in evolution, then please view the below link.

Hmmm... "The Six Fatal Flaws in Theistic Evolution"

1. "ADAM VERSUS APES: THEISTIC EVOLUTION DENIES THE BIBLICAL CREATION OF ADAM AND MAKES APES OUR ANCESTORS"

Point 1 is an argument for Biblical literalism for the sake of... Biblical literalism.

So what?

2. "BIBLICAL ORDER OF CREATION"

Point 2 is a timeline which is more from point 1.

Again - So what?

3. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION MAKES DEATH, AND NOT GOD, OUR CREATOR"

Point 3 asks an interesting, but fundamentally flawed, question: "What kind of all-powerful God would need to use a cruel, experimental process to bring about the variety of life on earth?"

The flaw in this question is the word "need." Certainly, an all-powerful God doesn't "need" to do anything - He acts solely as He chooses.

An all-powerful God doesn't "need" to create life at all - no reason was given in Genesis regarding why... and none is needed. God does as God wants.

Having established God as arbitrary and capricious from the get-go, the question posed here quickly becomes moot.

4. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION PLACES DEATH BEFORE SIN"

A lot of literalistic doubletalk here to defend the idea that death is the punishment for sin... and emotional appeals to indicate that animals eating one another is a result of two naked people taking bad advice from a talking reptile.

5. "THE BELIEVER LOSES THE POWER THAT COMES FROM FULLY BELIEVING IN GOD’S WORD"

This one makes no sense. "Put simply, there is power that comes from fully believing in the Word of God."

Well, enjoy your power; I prefer facts.

6. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION HAS CHRIST DYING FOR THE SINS OF A MYTHICAL ADAM"

Literal genealogies combined with literalizing Paul's commentary in Romans 5:16-18 leads to a truly embarrassing conclusion.

It's very telling that the first link on this website is to their store - if you bought anything from there, I suggest you request a refund.
 

YoursTrue

Faith-confidence in what we hope for (Hebrews 11)
You may have believed what evolutionists said, but did you understand what they said and the evidence for their statements? If so, what was there about the Bible that made you reject this evidence
I understand what is considered as evidence of the theory. I do not consider the evidence as true any more to be considered as how it happened, such as (some?) fish (wonder how many) eventually becoming mammals.
 

YoursTrue

Faith-confidence in what we hope for (Hebrews 11)
Nope, I've read enough creationist websites to know that they contain convoluted and dishonest arguments that misrepresent both science and the faith of most Christians.
I'd love to hear what you think is the faith of most Christians.
 

YoursTrue

Faith-confidence in what we hope for (Hebrews 11)
Hmmm... "The Six Fatal Flaws in Theistic Evolution"

1. "ADAM VERSUS APES: THEISTIC EVOLUTION DENIES THE BIBLICAL CREATION OF ADAM AND MAKES APES OUR ANCESTORS"

Point 1 is an argument for Biblical literalism for the sake of... Biblical literalism.

So what?

2. "BIBLICAL ORDER OF CREATION"

Point 2 is a timeline which is more from point 1.

Again - So what?

3. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION MAKES DEATH, AND NOT GOD, OUR CREATOR"

Point 3 asks an interesting, but fundamentally flawed, question: "What kind of all-powerful God would need to use a cruel, experimental process to bring about the variety of life on earth?"

The flaw in this question is the word "need." Certainly, an all-powerful God doesn't "need" to do anything - He acts solely as He chooses.

An all-powerful God doesn't "need" to create life at all - no reason was given in Genesis regarding why... and none is needed. God does as God wants.

Having established God as arbitrary and capricious from the get-go, the question posed here quickly becomes moot.

4. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION PLACES DEATH BEFORE SIN"

A lot of literalistic doubletalk here to defend the idea that death is the punishment for sin... and emotional appeals to indicate that animals eating one another is a result of two naked people taking bad advice from a talking reptile.

5. "THE BELIEVER LOSES THE POWER THAT COMES FROM FULLY BELIEVING IN GOD’S WORD"

This one makes no sense. "Put simply, there is power that comes from fully believing in the Word of God."

Well, enjoy your power; I prefer facts.

6. "THEISTIC EVOLUTION HAS CHRIST DYING FOR THE SINS OF A MYTHICAL ADAM"

Literal genealogies combined with literalizing Paul's commentary in Romans 5:16-18 leads to a truly embarrassing conclusion.

It's very telling that the first link on this website is to their store - if you bought anything from there, I suggest you request a refund.
I am glad to know now that not only is there a God who cares, and humans are not apes, despite scientific categories classifying them as such.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I believe there will never be enough evidence for one that believes evolution is true, until they first deal with the root Belief of every atheists core belief! And that is...there is NO god!
No. That is not the core belief of atheism.
There are several subsets of atheism. Belief that there is no God, ie: "hard atheism," is one of them, but it's not the core belief. The core belief -- the definitive belief -- is the one thing common to all subsets: lack of belief.
so then, No matter what evidence is shown or given that there is intelligent design, there will always be the perception that it is wrong.
No, that's wrong, too. Atheism's an abstract, logic-based rejection of a proposition, based on the fact that theism has not met its burden of proof. As soon as theism can do so, atheists, being reasonable, will have no reasonable choice but to accept it.

Our world view determines our core beliefs.
Fair enough. And the most accurate predictor of religious belief is the belief of family and social group, not facts, reason, or critical analysis.
To the one who Believes in God, it only makes logical and intelligent sense that with everything man has ever designed and imagined, to list simply a hand full, i.e. phones, vehicles, books, pencils, paper, computers, websites :) etc., that these were infact designed, made by intelligent thought, and not put together by accident or chance, and I challenge anyone to prove me wrong that a car, a book, computers etc., can thru millions, hey how about billions of years of chance can somehow create themselves......

So if these and the thousands of other things we (man) have created (logically speaking) could not come into being by chance, how in the world can anyone (logically speaking) believe that we humans, not to mention all the thousand of other living organisms, came into existence by CHANCE!
Good explanation of theism's famous Watchmaker Argument. It's been extensively refuted. It relies on a false correlation of mechanisms behind the complexity.

Purposive intelligence is not the only mechanism by which functional complexity may come about, and while personal incredulity may have been understandable before the mechanisms of evolution and physiology were discovered and verified, there is no longer a good excuse for ignorance of this alternate mechanism.
Moreover, even absent the knowledge of evolution and physiology, positing magic and an uncaused, intentional, magician would be unevidenced and non sequitur.

The mathematical probability for that is so far beyond a number anyone could ever calculate, that is simply does not make sense to believe that.
It does when a demonstrable, alternative mechanism has been demonstrated.
Q: how would these probabilities be calculated?
AND all this came into being (according to the evolution Theory, NOT SCIENCE) With no Purpose, no thought for BEING! Because if evolution which is really FAITH BASED is true, we came from nothing and we will all end up being............ NOTHING!
Evolution is not faith-based, as you should know. Unlike magic poofing, it's mechanisms are easily observed and verified.

"Came from nothing and will end up being nothing?!" First, how does this follow from evolution? Second, who ever claimed we came from nothing?
Third, so what? Why is "being something" such a concern for you, and why do you consider it sine qua non?
I am not saying this to insult you Estro, but really would like to know..........IF THAT IS THE CASE, that there is no God who has created and designed us for PURPOSE, where as we have a written account in which he clearly says that he did infact create us, and created us for a reason,
We have hundreds of "written accounts," from many religions and mythologies, most disagreeing with each other. They are not evidence based or tested, so how are they any more believable than the orcs and hobbits from Lord of the Rings?
Your narrative follows from premises you have not logically or factually demonstrated. What empirical evidence do you have for this "God?"
WHY please tell me, why would anyone even CARE TO ASK the QUESTION Estro!

There is no hope in the belief of evolution, no sense of Purpose, no Future, except a for a few hard decades of existence then death! And our whole existence then ends up becoming NOTHING!
And how is this obsessive need for purpose and significance evidence for anything? It's epistemic nonsense.
I don't want to live in that world, and that World View is the reason for so much hopelessness and fear in this world!
Again, so what? Are you a child, who still needs a strong father protecting you to feel secure?
Why would a world with no religious conflict or coercion; no threat of Hell, so distress you?
 
Last edited:

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I understand what is considered as evidence of the theory. I do not consider the evidence as true any more to be considered as how it happened, such as (some?) fish (wonder how many) eventually becoming mammals.
Why do you not consider the evidence untrue? What flaws do you find in it?
 
First of all, life coming into being is abiogenesis, not evolution. Evolution is the development of existing life through descent with modification involving mutation and natural selection.

There are MANY people of faith who believe God is who, evolution is how. To claim that those who accept scientific evidence of evolution and the age of the universe do not believe in God is to LIE about hundreds of millions of people of faith.
We are warned by the God of the Bible to believe in him, by doing so we believe in his Word, which is the bible. Though I would be the first to say there is still much in which I don't fully understand all things, but STILL I take God for his Word. I take it by FAITH. And anyone or anything else that says different is to be rejected. I clearly understand this is an affront to most and even to many of the millions you mentioned, but my Faith does not stand by which millions or billions agree upon, but on every Word that proceeds from God. He has declared that he has given us an acount of the beginning of his creation, and yes there are virtually no details to how he created all things, BUT he makes it very clear it was done in 6 days, One evening and one morning ...ONE DAY, for each forms of life that HE created, and in Proverbs it says by WISDOM God created all things not evolution.

Proverbs 3:19-20
The LORD by wisdom hath founded the earth; By understanding hath he established the heavens. By his knowledge the depths are broken up,

I dont have to explain how it done, my responsibility is to Believe God even if others reject that> ( Example Noah, Joseph, David, Abraham, the desciples, and I could go on listing many many more in the bible). ALL took God for his word, even when they were laughed at, beaten, sold into slavery, mocked and many put to death, for taking God at his Word.

But to say also that Science has not also found many evidences that point to a young earth, opposed to the world's so called scientific facts would be a great error on the part of these millions you refer that are so quick to believe the ones who reject God, and they do, To the Word of God which is given to those would choose to Believe him. He needs us to accept ALL OF HIS WORD, not parts, there have been scoffers since Noah, and there always will be. We don't take a pulse of the world to determine what is true. We live and Die by the Word of God.

All things will truly be revealed one Day, don't you owe it yourself to seek out the truth according to the Bible!

But you eluded my question, Do you believe God created all life? You brought up the Word Abiogenesis I had to pull it up to know the definition. It says as you are aware:

Abiogenesis -
the original evolution of life or living organisms from inorganic or inanimate substances.
"to construct any convincing theory of abiogenesis, we must take into account the condition of the Earth about 4 billion years ago"

Evolution - the process by which different kinds of living organisms are thought to have developed and diversified from earlier forms during the history of the earth.

Both seem to say essentially the same thing, and neither state the need for a designer (God). And they mention the need for billions of years for life to EVOLVE to where we are at this point in life.

God, in Genesis said he did this in Days! AND, the first man and woman were created in his Image, not thru billlions of years of starting with lower life forms then 6 thousand years ago before getting to Adam and Eve.

This seems to be impossible for many including the Evolutionist Theist, or am I wrong? Please correct me if I am.
 

blü 2

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Of course this question is addressed both to theists and to atheists. Both to those who believe in evolution and those who believe it's untrue.
Explain why you, through your intelligence, reason and mind developped the awareness and the conviction that Evolution is the historical truth.

If you are a theist, please explain the theological implications, as well.

I will underline that we are not talking about Intelligence Design, here: we are talking about Darwinian evolution based upon the Darwinian principles like natural selection, etc..etc...
Thank you for participating- ;)
In the household I grew up in, rationality was taken for granted and religion was principally a matter of manners. So there were no religious alternatives on the table when I was very small or later,

Neither in Pisco Sunday school or in Pisco confirmation classes did anyone suggest anyone should take Genesis creation seriously ─ in fact I can't think of a single occasion when it was raised.

My schooling was secular, and pretty good quality. Reason prevailed effortlessly there too.

And now I'm big enough to go out on my own, I can't imagine why anyone would fail to recognize a folk-tale when they see one.

The religious mindset as such doesn't worry me, but taking the bible literally is very hard to distinguish from taking the Harry Potter books literally AND they're a lot easier to read and teach a good-guys morality that I have no trouble with.
 
Last edited:

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I did not connect this to your comment, Can you please help me understand that we and all of life evolved, and yet we believe in God ..Evolution by definition is that life came to being without a Designer, with someone creating us.
No! Apparently you don't even understand what evolution is, much less the mechanisms driving it.
Evolution is change, not creation.
In the household I grew up in, rationality was taken for granted and religion was principally a matter of manners. So there were no religious alternatives on the table when I was very small or later,

Neither in Pisco Sunday school or in Pisco communion classes did anyone suggest anyone should take Genesis creation seriously ─ in fact I can't think of a single occasion when it was raised.

My schooling was secular, and pretty good quality. Reason prevailed effortlessly there too.

And now I'm big enough to go out on my own, I can't imagine why anyone would fail to recognize a folk-tale when they see one.

The religious mindset as such doesn't worry me, but taking the bible literally is very hard to distinguish from taking the Harry Potter books literally AND they're a lot easier to read and teach a good-guys morality that I have no trouble with.
Perhaps early religious teaching retards intellectual development.....

Wired to Believe Trump’s Falsehoods," I explain that the children of Christian fundamentalists typically begin to suppress critical thinking at an early age. This is required if one is to accept Biblical stories as literal truth, rather than metaphors for how to live life practically and with purpose. Attributing natural occurrences to mystical causes discourages youth from seeking evidence to back their beliefs.

Consequently, the brain structures that support critical thinking and logical reasoning don't fully mature. This paves the way for heightened vulnerability to deceit and manipulative narratives, especially from cunning political figures. Such increased suggestibility arises from a mix of the brain's propensity to accept unverified claims and intense indoctrination.

-- MSN
 

blü 2

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Perhaps early religious teaching retards intellectual development.....
I have a very good friend and we go back to student days, where coming from different cities we collided at intervarsity sports. I mention him because he won't discuss religion generally and he won't hear a word against the Catholic church (enquiries into child abuse possibly excepted ─ he's made a few regretful remarks, which convention being what it is I reply only with a nod). That's because he came from a disadvantaged background and directly attributes his success academically and in the real world to the help he got from the brothers and the nuns who taught him at various times. The secret there I suspect is that he would have been a delight to teach, but that's not his view.

I mention that because religions are human institutions and quite possibly the decent, capable and proactive people handsomely outnumber the pedophiles.

The problem occurs where it mainly seems to occur, at the extremes. Trump is a good, if appalling, example. I wonder what percentage of fundy churchgoers are Trump supporters?
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
Can you really look at the night sky, with the hundreds of billions of stars in the Milky Way galaxy, and trillions of galaxies extending through a possibly infinite universe, and go on believing that the Earth, and human beings, are of any importance?
Certainly. We are THE unique sentient life form on this unique earth. (Or, for that matter, on any other planet, currently….UFO’s / UAP’s notwithstanding. Lol.)

Because life is so ubiquitous on this planet, it masks the fact that material life is extremely rare & valued throughout the universe.
Life is created.

From what I’ve come to learn about our Creator through studying the Bible, I can see where these planets that have been / are being discovered - or at least some of them - will be future homes for us humans as we become more populous.
Under the right Guidance, our scientific technology will advance to allow such travel, and exploration & discovery will always be a big part of mankind’s experience.

1 Corinthians 2:9; Ecclesiastes 3:11.
 

TLK Valentine

Read the books that others would burn.
I am glad to know now that not only is there a God who cares, and humans are not apes, despite scientific categories classifying them as such.

You are glad to believe that, but aside from the fact that it makes you glad, why do you believe it?
 

YoursTrue

Faith-confidence in what we hope for (Hebrews 11)
You are glad to believe that, but aside from the fact that it makes you glad, why do you believe it?
the "scientific" evidence that apes said to be closest to humans do not have the brain capacity to think as we do. You can believe what you want or perceive the evidence for, but I do not see "evidence" that humans are apes linked to gorillas, bonobos, chimpanzees, and earlier -- fish. They may be a step or two away genetically, but that does not mean (to me) that they evolved from some apelike ancestor unknown, and before that fish. That's one point. Another and very importantly to me is that by listening to God's standards I have benefited in many ways mentally and physically.
 
Top