• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What makes you think Islam is a false religion?

Let me just ask this simple question, can I as a non-muslim live in peace in a muslim occupied region?

I have answered this kadzbiz.

I am an eye witness on that...I live in Egypt.

There are millions of Christians who live in peace in my country, there are tens of Christians in my company...we are all friends...claims otherwise are silly.

the same goes to many other countries like Syria and Jordan.
 
Then post those verses again so I can see them. I have not seen any verses that contradict "Fight the non believers" yet.

Learn

60-9
''Allah does not forbid you to deal justly and kindly with those who fought not against you on account of religion and did not drive you out of your homes. Verily, Allah loves those who deal with equity.''
 
Probably your belief on Jihad (holy war). Would you kill a being created by God (through war) to extend/spread your religion? I have many Muslim friends but I wasn't able to ask them so , I want an answer here.

Muslims do not kill to spread their religion...killing in Islam is only allowed as self-defense.
 

Darkness

Psychoanalyst/Marxist
Suraj said:
Hey Darkness I did not originally post that! :angel2:

Sorry about that.

The Qur'an is a vicious and deadly book, but somehow many Muslims have managed to get good out of it. The same goes for the Bible. Nowadays, most Muslims and Christians do not run around burning the heretic, but those that do are still true Muslims and Christians. It is safe to say that there are true Muslims who are evil and true Muslims who are good.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
You assume I hate Islam. I don't hate anything. Pointing out hatred is not the same as hatred. If I was saying that the Nazis preach hatred, would you say I myself am a Nazi hater?


No. I am referring to this:

Like I said I am going to control myself, but my blood boils just thinking of what Islam did to my people.

That is hatred, whether you admit it or not. It doesn't matter if you 'control' it or not, it is still in your heart.

Besides, it's not your place to point out or judge such evils. Such is the responsibility of the ones who commit the crimes. If they never see that they are doing horrors, then such be their lot. They will destroy themselves in the end. My advice to you is to just forgive what they may have done to your ancestors as that was in the past and cannot be altered. You will not do them an injustice by hating men who have been dead for so many years.

Besides, when you claimed that Islam has more in common with Nazism, that is just incorrect. Hitler's army invaded many places without provocation and killed 7 million people unjustly and horribly. He made no effort to hide that he hated every one who didn't agree with him in every detail. Islam is far more tolerant than Hitler will ever be, as Muslims here have proven that they are tolerant of Jews and Christians(and of other religions) in many places, and that the Qur'an says that any one who submits to the will of God, including Jews and Christians, is good.

Unbelievers are described in detail, and they are described as being those who are violent and aggressive, fitting the description that you're giving of Islam. I don't submit to the will of any god, but I know that the Qur'an doesn't call me an unbeliever, because they're described as being ones who would wish destruction of Muslims. I like Islam, and do find wisdom in many verses of the Qur'an. I ignore all the war parts of it or cultural parts of it, so I can look at what is there to be gleaned in terms of wisdom.


And by the way, you'll never convince me by giving me a number. 161 verses of violence... so what? That's less than 1% of the Qur'an; the second Surah is longer than that. Besides, did you count that yourself, or get it from some anti-Islam website? I can say that there are verses in the Bible that are far more subtle in their warmongering, but that I feel is more effective. Such as the verse I quoted above. Some could regard that as to mean that since unbelievers are going to be cast in the fire anyway, they mean nothing therefore can be oppressed or killed. I also seem to remember a point in the Gospels where Jesus said something along the lines of "those who go to war in my name will receive due reward."
 

Sententia

Well-Known Member
1-Mohamed: It is fair to say that a poor man would never throw himself into the endless trouble of inviting his people to a new religion, in a very tough community, unless he is really God-sent.
There is no point whatsoever to falsely claim prophecy for nothing.


What does he having been poor have to do with it? There are many reasons for claiming to be a prophet but there is not an expectation that there must be a reason behind it all.

Second Joseph Smith of the mormons proposes a new religion and a new book and by your qualifications alone Joe must then be a true prophet... There is nothing wrong with believing what you will but dont delude yourself into thinking so because of false reasons.

2-The Quran: In addition to the countless miracles in the Quran (which I am ready to explain God-willing)... most of the Quran includes verses where God tells about himself.
People who question the integrity of the holy Quran must ask this: Why hasn't God answered back Mohamed. (If you assume that the Quran is nothing but Mohamed's words).

God does not answer back to anyone... Does that also prove everyones religion? (As contradicting and strange as it is?)
 

Surya Deva

Well-Known Member
That is hatred, whether you admit it or not. It doesn't matter if you 'control' it or not, it is still in your heart.

Nope this is being angry at the brutal and cold blooded killing of innocent men, women and children. Most humans feel the same.

Besides, it's not your place to point out or judge such evils. Such is the responsibility of the ones who commit the crimes.

:biglaugh:

Honestly if some people in this world got their way we would be back in the stone age. No sorry, judging whether somebody has commited a crime is not up to the criminal, it is done by the judicial system.

My advice to you is to just forgive what they may have done to your ancestors as that was in the past and cannot be altered. You will not do them an injustice by hating men who have been dead for so many years.

I don't hate the men; I hate the ideology. That ideology is still alive. Something is only forgiven if the crime is admitted. Much less admitting, the Muslims who have posted here have justified their past. As soon as they do that they claim responsibility. Do you think the Jews would be quiet if Germany did not apologise to them? Would the blacks go quiet if the West did not apologise for the slave trade.

I am more than willing to forgive but I can only forgive if the mistake is accepted and an apology is made. I don't see that happening which only proves to me that the evil still lives on and long as that is there history will continue to condemn. Also Karma is already at work the persecutor has become the persecuted. If they still don't atone for it then the future is going to be rough.

Besides, when you claimed that Islam has more in common with Nazism, that is just incorrect. Hitler's army invaded many places without provocation and killed 7 million people unjustly and horribly. He made no effort to hide that he hated every one who didn't agree with him in every detail.

What are you talking about. Go and read the history of Islam. It has been on a constant rampage ever since it was born. It has killed hundreds of millions of people all over the world over 1000 years. In India alone the estimates are up to 80 million killed. The death and destruction that was spread by Islam is far more deadly than what Hitler ever did. Look around the world all countries where Islam rules are some of the most violent places in the world and also places of terrorism.

The hatred one can read in the Quran for the non-believers is as bad as the hatred one reads in Nazi propoganda.

Why do people lie to defend Islam? What motivates one to lie?

Unbelievers are described in detail, and they are described as being those who are violent and aggressive, fitting the description that you're giving of Islam.

Of course the unbelievers are horribly demonized in the Quran. You were not expecting them to be described as "peaceful, warm and lovely people" were you?
It is the only religion I know of which preaches such open hate. I told you the closest that comes to it is the Nazi religion. In the UK Mullas are openly preaching death and destruction on the streets.

Why do you people blind yourself to these facts? Where there is smoke there is fire. Did your red flags not shoot up when you saw Muslims in this thread alone say they hate all other religions. Why is this such a common sentiment in this religion?

Stop attacking the critic. The critics job is only to point out the facts. If it is a fact, if it is the truth, it needs to be told and it needs to be discussed. It is time we take of our focus of the critics of Islam and put it on Islam itself.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
Nope this is being angry at the brutal and cold blooded killing of innocent men, women and children. Most humans feel the same.

And most humans react by brutally killing the killers. Sorry, but I've very little faith in humanity when things like the death penalty still exist in so-called 'civilized' countries.



:biglaugh:

Honestly if some people in this world got their way we would be back in the stone age. No sorry, judging whether somebody has commited a crime is not up to the criminal, it is done by the judicial system.

Which judicial system? Ours? The one where judging is based on how much money one has? (I know that's not how it's supposed to be, but that's what I've seen)

I don't hate the men; I hate the ideology. That ideology is still alive. Something is only forgiven if the crime is admitted. Much less admitting, the Muslims who have posted here have justified their past. As soon as they do that they claim responsibility. Do you think the Jews would be quiet if Germany did not apologise to them? Would the blacks go quiet if the West did not apologise for the slave trade. I am more than willing to forgive but I can only forgive if the mistake is accepted and an apology is made. I don't see that happening which only proves to me that the evil still lives on and long as that is there history will continue to condemn.

Just like the God of the Qur'an... unable to forgive unless forgiveness is asked.

I can forgive without having to be apologized to. Does that make me a fool? Maybe. But it allows me to not dwell on things long past and continue to perfect myself. I try not to hate anything, person, ideal, act, bad movie, ANYTHING. I'm with the Jedi on this one.

Also Karma is already at work the persecutor has become the persecuted. If they still don't atone for it then the future is going to be rough.

Therefore let it happen. I'm not defending the political leaders who caused all those deaths. They got what was coming to them, and the ones who right now are doing the killing are feeling the same.



What are you talking about. Go and read the history of Islam. It has been on a constant rampage ever since it was born. It has killed hundreds of millions of people all over the world over 1000 years. In India alone the estimates are up to 80 million killed. The death and destruction that was spread by Islam is far more deadly than what Hitler ever did. Look around the world all countries where Islam rules are some of the most violent places in the world and also places of terrorism.

Numbers, numbers, numbers... As I said, people were getting it wrong from the beginning. And I, like Muslims, equate the killing of one individual (I differ in that I believe it is the same with even insects) as the same as killing all life. Numbers mean nothing to me. But the ones responsible for those crimes are long dead; what's the point of dwelling on them?

The hatred one can read in the Quran for the non-believers is as bad as the hatred one reads in Nazi propoganda.

Why do people lie to defend Islam? What motivates one to lie?

Favoritism. And also if there is a lie, it has not come to light for the defenders. So far, you've not provided anything to sway me except a bloody history long past. That's not what the Qur'an AS A WHOLE taught, and I'd argue that any verses that are in there that do promote killing were added later when it was first being written down. Therefore people who commit the crimes do not listen to God. It would make sense because otherwise, you're pointing out contradictions; Muslims here have provided verses promoting peace.



Of course the unbelievers are horribly demonized in the Quran. You were not expecting them to be described as "peaceful, warm and lovely people" were you?
It is the only religion I know of which preaches such open hate. I told you the closest that comes to it is the Nazi religion. In the UK Mullas are openly preaching death and destruction on the streets.

As is their right. As long as they don't actually do anything, words can be ignored. Besides, America did awful things to Iraq when they invaded; I frankly don't blame them. Nevertheless their hate is their own business as long as they remain without violence.

Unbelievers in the Qur'an are described in detail, and while I do agree that it was biased, it was not without cause; the first Muslims were heavily persecuted early on.

Why do you people blind yourself to these facts? Where there is smoke there is fire. Did your red flags not shoot up when you saw Muslims in this thread alone say they hate all other religions. Why is this such a common sentiment in this religion?

Sorry, I haven't read all the posts; I jumped in the middle. Perhaps you could quote some? Did they actually use the word hate? Besides, I've tried to burn all my red flags; they've done me no good in the past.

Stop attacking the critic. The critics job is only to point out the facts. If it is a fact, if it is the truth, it needs to be told and it needs to be discussed. It is time we take of our focus of the critics of Islam and put it on Islam itself.

Therefore take it away from the corruption of politicians and place it on the actual believers. I already said that I don't defend the ones who have committed those crimes. If all the Muslim people followed them, then all the Muslims got it all wrong. Haven't you figured out that that's how I think?


By the way, want to know what I think about it? God sent the Law down. People got it wrong. God sent the Gospel down. People got it wrong. God sent the Qur'an down. People STILL got it wrong. Recently God sent the revealed Baha'i scriptures. People are FINALLY starting to get it. Nevertheless, just as in ages past, new prophets aren't listened to. Jews believe that the Torah as it is is the Word of God alone(I'm not saying they're wrong, mind you). Christians feel that their entire Bible as decided by the Nicean Creed is the Word of God alone. Muslims feel that the Qur'an is the Word of God alone. Not sure honestly about the Baha'i, but I think they believe the Kitab-i-Aqdas and Kitab-i-Iqan to be the Word of God, INCLUDING all other major religions. If it makes you feel better about how I think it works, I feel the Baha'is are the ones getting it right at the moment. (ALONG WITH many people from the other faiths)


And by the way, I equate calling the Qur'an a war book because of a small number of verses: with calling Tolkien a warmonger because of Aragorn's marching to war near the end.
 

darkendless

Guardian of Asgaard
And most humans react by brutally killing the killers. Sorry, but I've very little faith in humanity when things like the death penalty still exist in so-called 'civilized' countries.

Some people don't deserve to breathe the air of the innocent, i think the death penalty should be enforced upon people who bring down civilised nations.

Why do you reject numbers? Do they contain evidence you do not wish to acknowledge as true?
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
Some people don't deserve to breathe the air of the innocent, i think the death penalty should be enforced upon people who bring down civilised nations.

I don't play the 'deserve' game; I prefer to take Gandalf's advice.

Why do you reject numbers? Do they contain evidence you do not wish to acknowledge as true?

No. I'm saying that I equate the unjust murder of a single person (even insects) with murdering hundreds. I don't have levels of guilt or equal crime. Stealing a diamond from the king is equal to a common mugger. Attempting to break into Fort Knox is equal to breaking into a common bank. Murdering hundreds is equal to murdering a single individual unjustly. Stealing is not equal to murder, of course, unless it's for the same reason. Reason is as important to the crime itself. Stealing from a market because you're starving is not equal to stealing from a market because you can't afford the best food. Killing a person in self-defense is not equal to unjust murder.

Therefore a single verse promoting murder is equal to a thousand verses promoting murder.
 

darkendless

Guardian of Asgaard
Why death?

Why not, would you rather let a person live who has killed and raped? Even if they spent their life in prison? Most of the time prisons are more confortable than any homeless person's day to day life.
I don't believe in life time sentences or parole, if we have to be humane about it at least keep people in total isolation. Even then they're a drain on our resources, food and water. But why do they deserve to live and breathe, when they showed no sympathy for the person's life they destroyed?
 

darkendless

Guardian of Asgaard
I don't play the 'deserve' game; I prefer to take Gandalf's advice.



No. I'm saying that I equate the unjust murder of a single person (even insects) with murdering hundreds. I don't have levels of guilt or equal crime. Stealing a diamond from the king is equal to a common mugger. Attempting to break into Fort Knox is equal to breaking into a common bank. Murdering hundreds is equal to murdering a single individual unjustly. Stealing is not equal to murder, of course, unless it's for the same reason. Reason is as important to the crime itself. Stealing from a market because you're starving is not equal to stealing from a market because you can't afford the best food. Killing a person in self-defense is not equal to unjust murder.

Therefore a single verse promoting murder is equal to a thousand verses promoting murder.

Well not deserve, i just think in terms of "an eye for an eye"

I see what you mean with statistics, but then again, 1 verse of hatred is enough to be of concern. Think about impressional minds and what they would read.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
I am sure that Muslims here on RF will be flattered by having their Holy Book compared to high fantasy. :rolleyes: Yeah, that ought to go over well. ;)

LOL!!! I wasn't comparing Tolkien's works to the Qur'an. I was stating my feeling on deserving in response to Darkendless' statement.

Besides, I'm a nerd who loves LOVES LOVES high fantasy trying to get into Dungeons and Dragons. I think I'm allowed to reference the philosophy of the guy who brought fantasy to the modern age, in a religious debate.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
Well not deserve, i just think in terms of "an eye for an eye"

I see what you mean with statistics, but then again, 1 verse of hatred is enough to be of concern. Think about impressional minds and what they would read.

Fair enough. And believe me, I agree with the 'impressional mind' thing, which is why I made the above quote from Revelations, and why I believe warlike "muslims", who sadly have represented the majority of them in history, have gotten it all wrong.
 

Sententia

Well-Known Member
Why not, would you rather let a person live who has killed and raped? Even if they spent their life in prison? Most of the time prisons are more confortable than any homeless person's day to day life.
I don't believe in life time sentences or parole, if we have to be humane about it at least keep people in total isolation. Even then they're a drain on our resources, food and water. But why do they deserve to live and breathe, when they showed no sympathy for the person's life they destroyed?

Why does it matter? What difference to you does it make if they are removed from your society or if they are killed or tortured or hurt?

I dont believe in today's legal system at all... But I also do not believe in nor think the death penalty is required.

I'm an atheist mate and all anyone has is life and you who have not walked a mile in their shoes wish to judge and kill them on whatever evidence we can find after the fact...

IMHO too many innocent people have been imprisoned and killed.

I take an ardent stance against mindless torture and the death penalty. Understand I hold you in the highest regard but I would soon disagree with my own mother should she take a stance similar to your own... however since I can't let my opinion also be unknown.... [clicks submit]
 
Top