Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
michel said:What if you happen to be ugly ?
My answer ? I guess to learn to try and become more God - like spiritually, and less like humans.
may said:The conclusion of the matter, everything having been heard, is: Fear the [true] God and keep his commandments. For this is the whole [obligation] of man ... Ecclesiates 12;13
divine said:why would you expect there to be a purpose? or a reason?
ProfLogic said:The age old question: Why are we here and what is our purpose?
Sunstone said:My hunch is that wondering about the purpose of things is to some extent hardwired into the human brain and heavily reinforced by the business of going about our daily lives.
An animal on the look out for "the purpose of things" is more likely to figure out that a rock can be fractured into a cutting blade and useful tool than an animal that doesn't speculate about the alleged purpose of things. So, there might be evolutionary reasons why we ask for purpose.
Sunstone said:That is also to say that seeing a purpose in something is a human construct. Nature itself does not come organized into categories of human purpose. Rocks are not naturally for fracturing into cutting blades. Instead, we impose purpose on nature, rather than actually discover it all ready made for us in nature.
divine said:sure - while i don't believe it's 'hardwired into the brain', i suppose it's something of a universal human trait to be curious and find out how and why things work. a trait we share with a lot of animals. i'd say finding purpose and meaning in life and existence, as a whole, is hardwired in our culture though. i don't think it must be unescapable human nature.
exactly. so my answer is - why must there be more purpose, and meaning, than there already is? why must we seek external purpose, instead of being satisfied with what we already have? why...:sleep:
i don't think your language was clumsy, though i suspect that mine was. (i can always blame the fact that english is my second language, though most often it rather has to do with laziness) i just feel that, though it is definitely possible you are right, perhaps we often look a little too readily to biology for answers. cultural explanations, i feel, are often overlooked.Sunstone said:My language was clumsy... When I said that looking for purpose was hardwired into the brain, I didn't mean to imply we are always required by our brains to look for purpose. I merely meant that we are predisposed to look for purpose,
it would seem so, but how many are actually sure about their purpose in life? how many know exactly what it is? despite what they would tell you, how often is a christian, muslim, new ager etc. completely without doubt? that sense of meaning seems to me unstable and in the end, a source of much anxiety. this is of course a completely personal and subjective opinion, but i feel that looking for meaning and purpose outside of the moment, project or task at hand, is frequently a source of unhappiness in people's lives.Sunstone said:Having a purpose gives us a sense of meaning, doesn't it?
yes - but i'd reply that just because your life has no 'cosmic' or 'grand' meaning, doesn't make it meaningless.Sunstone said:I suspect most people are emotionally averse to feeling their life or even one of their days is meaningless, and escape from that feeling through launching themselves into a purpose(s).
i don't understand...:sorry1:Sunstone said:Is it possible to act according to a purpose without feeling a sense of meaning come from it?
divine said:i just feel that, though it is definitely possible you are right, perhaps we often look a little too readily to biology for answers. cultural explanations, i feel, are often overlooked.
it would seem so, but how many are actually sure about their purpose in life? how many know exactly what it is? despite what they would tell you, how often is a christian, muslim, new ager etc. completely without doubt? that sense of meaning seems to me unstable and in the end, a source of much anxiety. this is of course a completely personal and subjective opinion, but i feel that looking for meaning and purpose outside of the moment, project or task at hand, is frequently a source of unhappiness in people's lives.
yes - but i'd reply that just because your life has no 'cosmic' or 'grand' meaning, doesn't make it meaningless.
i don't understand...:sorry1:
ProfLogic said:The age old question: Why are we here and what is our purpose?
Sunstone said:Wasn't it Goethe who said, merely set yourself to a task and the mind becomes heated, engaged, and interested? Normally, you have merely to get started doing something that fulfills a desired purpose, and a feeling of meaningfulness will eventually follow. It might not be a feeling of profound menaingfulness, but it will be some sort of feeling of meaningfulness. That is, to act to fulfill a desire seems to give us both a sense of purpose, and a feeling of meaningfulness. Do you agree? Or is this a flawed psychology?
yes - and i, for one, very much need to (further)internalize that insight. great post!Sunstone said:One most likely gets a genuine sense of meaning, not so much from what one believes about the cosmos, as from what one does in ones daily life.